3 ms·
> When you are granted options at $1 and the company IPOes with a valuation of $100 per share, all employees who have exercised their options are reputated havi
by prostoalex 10y ago
> When you are granted options at $1 and the company IPOes with a valuation of $100 per share, all employees who have exercised their options are reputated having made a $99 gain. So they have to pay, say, $30 per share. But it's so virtual money, because they may not have $30x number of shares in cash.
You're describing AMT, and the reason it exists is to account for an obvious behavioral pattern, which is never to sell. The pattern gets more attractive with increase in wealth, as loans against the public securities pledged as collateral are widely available at sub-1% in current rate environment, e.g. https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/?f=interest https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/?f=interest
While risky (with margin calls and what not), a loan against small portion of the portfolio is pretty tax-efficient, as loan proceeds are not income and are not capital gains.
If what you're describing in Australia is correct, my guess is that it's a bug in Australian tax system, not a feature. Wait for a few multi-millionaires or billionaires to prop up, never sell a single share of their portfolio while making their living through portfolio loans, and see what the public and tax authorities have to say about that.
- tajen 10y agoVery interesting, thank you for your explanation. It's funny because France is like Australia: CGT when you actually profit. But could it be that the Australian and French banking systems aren't as complete as the US system, hence not offering loans against public securities? Between that and the fact that "start-up millionnaire" is only really a SV syndrome (The French economy is so stagnating and our administrations so moronic that you wouldn't become millionnaire with a start-up in France), maybe our governments haven't faced the situation often yet.