4 ms·
I love the street art, but believe the article is fundamentally flawed. It picks three examples of placebo controls, crosswalk buttons, elevator door closing, a
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I love the street art, but believe the article is fundamentally flawed. It picks three examples of placebo controls, crosswalk buttons, elevator door closing, and office thermostats. Let's go through those
Crosswalk buttons - When traffic through an intersection (both pedestrian and vehicle) merits "knowing" when pedestrians want to cross, the buttons are considered. When such information will not change the flow, they are not. At some point in time if the cycle of walk/dont walk red/yellow/green will not differ based on button input, you can stop considering the button input. However, we get into situations in the Bay Area where the button is important and people who don't push it never see a walk sign. So sometimes they work, sometimes they don't.
Elevator buttons have a similar issues. There are regulations about how quickly after the doors open that the doors can close, and there are mechanisms that control the speed of closure (also regulated for safety reasons). Few people feel consider the door open button is a placebo because they can see, "Yup the doors are still open" but they feel that close is a placebo because the doors don't immediately start to close when it is pushed.
And office thermostats. Having been responsible for a company move, and consequently dealing with the landlord of the old and new space. The HVAC system was always divided into "zones". The thermostats were placed based on some previous zone. So when you reconfigure the space, new thermostats get added (if necessary) but old ones don't get removed. The old ones are either useful in the new configuration, or not useful now, but may be at a future date. Since it was $300+ to add a thermostat into the space, the landlord kept all thermostats that exist, so that future tenents might be able to use one that wasn't needed before but is already installed, saving $300+ in tenant improvement costs.
- greggman 10y agoYes, the myth of placebo buttons continues unabated. Maybe that's a NYC thing. I know plenty of crosswalks in SF and LA areas where if you don't press the button it will never say walk. Also, here in Japan nearly all elevator close buttons work instantly
- delinka 10y ago"Myth"? You have certainly not debunked ChuckMcM's detailed hypotheses about the reasons a placebo device exists. San Francisco, Los Angeles and (presumably all of) Japan are not indicative of much of the rest of the planet. There's still Chicago, Berlin, England (encompassing London), Brazil, Beijing...
- jcrawfordor 10y agoI don't think the burden of proof goes quite this way around, as every claim I've seen that crosswalk buttons do nothing has always been specifically about NYC. This seems to be a "fun fact" about a particular situation in NYC that everyone just started to repeat as if it was true everywhere.
- delinka 10y agoI have yet to see a 'working' crosswalk button in my nearest (non-NYC) metropolis. This would be because every light-controlled intersection I traverse on foot is on a programmed loop. Reliably, the crosswalk lights go to "walk" a second before the parallel street goes green. This happens five seconds after the perpendicular direction goes all red. That's not to say that sensor-controlled intersections which take the crosswalk button into consideration do not exist- there are far too many intersections which I haven't the time nor the inclination to tour. Ultimately, my point is this: simply because all the media on placebo buttons dwells on New York City does not mean similar devices don't exist elsewhere. I bet here, folks just don't care; they press a button and eventually get through a light.
- robocat 10y ago"Programmed loop" has little to do with whether buttons work or not. A button can speed up the cycle, similar to induction loops on low traffic density intersections (or that sometimes only work at night).
- Animats 10y agoBehavior may be very different during low-traffic periods. During busy periods, it's important to keep synchronization with nearby intersections. During off-peak periods, many traffic lights go to an on-demand mode, skipping directions where no traffic or pedestrians are waiting. The standard modes are called "pre-timed", "partially actuated", and "fully actuated".[1] In pre-timed mode, the pedestrian buttons don't do anything, but there's a WALK period somewhere in the cycle. In "fully actuated", you never get a WALK without pushing the button. [1] http://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/publications/fhwahop06006/chapter_7.htm http://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/publications/fhwahop06006/chapter_7....
- sitharus 10y agoIn New Zealand most of the pedestrian crossings don't show any lights until someone pushes the button. Occasionally someone will stand at the lights staring at a completely unilluminated crossing light until someone else pushes the button. Handily it means if the light is on it will change.
- phire 10y agoYeah, the 'don't walk' light doesn't illuminate until you press the button, there are even some pedestrian only lights where you must both press the button and stay standing on a mat, otherwise the light will not change. I've never seen a traffic light in New Zealand that won't change it cycle in some way during at least some part of the day when that button is pressed. During peak hours there are many traffic lights where the cycle doesn't change at all when you press the button, other than show the walk. Most other traffic lights modify their cycle slightly, with red turning lights to prevent drivers from turning across the crossing pedestrians. The button is only truly important outside of peak hours, when the traffic lights operate on sensors. And the cycles for cars are often so short that a pedestrians can't actually cross the road in time. So pressing the button not long makes the cycle change, but lengthens the cycle.
- jahnu 10y agoYeah, this is the problem. If you know that sometimes the button does have a purpose then it makes sense to always press them, since you don't know when you have to and it's basically no real effort to do so.
- jcrawfordor 10y agoA common scenario where elevator door close buttons are useful is hospitals. They often have a very long door open time set to accomodate the disabled and people handling gurneys, and the button will shorten it. This has been the case in most every hospital I've been in.
- larrik 10y agoFor the thermostats, I had a customer at a previous job who had a bunch of placebo thermostats installed for the "office ladies" would stop fighting. It actually completely solved the problem. ("office ladies" is my translation of what the customer actually said. I'm not trying to be sexist, although the customer had no problem being so.)
- Gracana 10y agoI did a similar thing to thwart a roommate who would always turn down the thermostat so it was frigid inside. I changed the calibration so it would show a temperature a few degrees lower than reality. He never touched it after that, and the rest of us didn't have to wear sweaters indoors.
- Zarel 10y agoAfter a few hours of Googling, I still can't figure out why these regulations exist. I managed to find a lot of people saying that the ADA requires a door to stay open for a certain amount of time, but nothing about why a Door Close button shouldn't override that.