3 ms·
Universal basic income is just communism 2.0. It's adapted for the sensitivities of the American middle and upper classes, who want to help the poor but only by
by rubidium 10y ago
Universal basic income is just communism 2.0. It's adapted for the sensitivities of the American middle and upper classes, who want to help the poor but only by giving money to make the problem go away.
Fundamental premise of UBI is everything is justly the property of the state. The state determines who should get what. Throw in a little capitalism and a little "I want to keep my upper-middle class life" and you get UBI. Everyone gets something, but those who make more get to keep some of that.
UBI in practice would likely lead to massive exploitation of the poor.
see also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12277301 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12277301
- Houshalter 10y agoIt is socialism, and that's great. The problem with communism was that central planning sucks, a lot. Basic income keeps efficient free markets, it just distributes the benefits to everyone, instead of just the rich. >UBI in practice would likely lead to massive exploitation of the poor. What a bunch of nonsense. The poor massively benefit from UBI. What are you even talking about.
- throwawaymsft 10y agoHow does giving everyone a monthly tax rebate (essentially a negative income tax) change who owns the means of production?