3 ms·
with voting you also end up with low quality commenters gaming the system, because voting itself is an attempt to gamify culture. One only has to look at Reddit
by krapp 10y ago
with voting you also end up with low quality commenters gaming the system, because voting itself is an attempt to gamify culture. One only has to look at Reddit to see how "high visibility" and "high quality" don't often correlate. Sometimes they do, but not always.
Also, with voting, you have meta-debates about voting, people complaining about voting, voting rings and brigading, etc. Voting also presents the problem of earlier posts persisting at the top regardless of their quality.
Of course it's possible to gamify imageboard threads as well since they sort by the last comment, but a purely chronologically sorted thread wouldn't have any such issues.