4 ms·
I wish I could upvote this 100 times. Especially: "if you find a well-written comment you disagree with, you might even upvote it and disagree in text form."
by rahimnathwani 10y ago
I wish I could upvote this 100 times. Especially:
"if you find a well-written comment you disagree with, you might even upvote it and disagree in text form."
"disagreement sometimes needs an outlet ... you might just upvote the best existing reply that you feel captures your feelings.
But AFAIK the HN guidelines (or pg?) say that disagreement is an acceptable reason for downvoting. It's really poor UX to have a single input that indicates wildly different things.
dang - is there any chance this rule will change? Or any particular reason why we don't want to change it?
- wfn 10y agoSeconding this; especially if you find a well-written comment you disagree with, you might even upvote it and disagree in text form. Making this into one of the guidelines may, I think, be a good idea.
- gkya 10y agoGuidelines are clear on what downwotes are: a tool for pushing down and marking irrelevant comments, not a "disagree" button. But the fact is it's hard for someone unskilled in discussion to distinguish disagreeable comment from an irrelevant one. Also, usually it's hard for most people to accept the falsety of their own thought against a counterargument. These skills, that are objective open mindedness and the incentive to accept criticism and counterarguments require a sort of literacy that's different from tech literacy, which's what I guess the HN crowd does indeed have in abundance. Discussion skills and discussion culture are not things that come with birth or tech knowledge though, they are a separate group of skills that you achieve on its own. Being able to take those actions that you quote require a certain maturity of such skills. HN being publicly accessible and popular to a certain extent, it's impossible to expect everyone to have them. And even a handful of this sort of commenters are enough to spoil the harmony of a discussion group. Further, if there are points earnable on internet, people will want to earn them. This sort of incentive pushes commenters to adopt a more populist style that can gain upvotes with punchy lines and populist comments instead of complete and coherent arguments or well-founded criticisms. Ultimately this is an illness of voting in itself, not specific to HN. See Brexit, Trump, etc. for up-to-date examples. edits: grammar.
- jrs235 10y agoAre the guidelines clear on downvotes? I think there's a misconception that they are, especially pertaining to up and down voting. I just reread the guidelines[1] and see little mention of up and down voting. The only mentioning is don't complain about or bait for down votes. In the past pg has said it's okay to use votes for agreement/disagreement[2]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 Edits: formatting
- gkya 10y agoWhoops, mistaken on that one. Sorry. Though there are people who think similarly here and I am reluctant to make a Lykurgos out of Mr. Graham.
- veddox 10y agoSorry, this is off-topic, but PG on graffiti is simply brilliant: "In this respect trolling is a lot like graffiti. Graffiti happens at the intersection of ambition and incompetence: people want to make their mark on the world, but have no other way to do it than literally making a mark on the world."
- gkya 10y agoYou didn't have to call me incompetent. Nor was I trolling. I'm really offended by this.
- veddox 10y agoI'm very sorry, gkya, I did not in the least mean to offend you - actually, I wasn't even referring to you! I simply read PG's essay that was linked above and came across this quote that I found really good and wanted to share. It had nothing whatsoever to do with your previous comments (which is why I clearly labeled it as off-topic). In fact, if you scroll to my comments further up in the discussion, you will see that we have a very similar opinion as far as downvoting is concerned. Again, my apologies if I have inadvertently caused offense, I certainly did not mean to.
- DonHopkins 10y agoSlashdot has always let users rate messages with several adjectives of different dimensions like relevance and agreement. Is there any consensus (or controversy) about why that does or doesn't work well, or a reason sites like reddit and hacker news don't adopt the same approach?
- DanBC 10y ago> is there any chance this rule will change? Or any particular reason why we don't want to change it? I'm guessing it's a pragmatic approach. We know that some people will always downvote for disagreement. The solution isn't to make them stop (because that's impossible) but to make everyone else supply corrective upvotes. And that's the point that's missing in this thread: a downvoted comment hasn't just attracted downvotes; it's failed to attract corrective upvotes. Since many more people can upvote than downvote many people saw the comment and decided not to correct the downvote.
- dang 10y ago(Sorry I didn't reply earlier; was busy today and didn't see this when I skimmed the thread.) I know this will be disappointing, but no, I think it would be a big mistake to introduce such a rule (that is, to outlaw downvoting for disagreement and say that people must comment instead). The site would be swamped by an avalanche of petty disagreements. Our goal is to optimize HN for intellectual curiosity, which requires a higher signal/noise ratio. Downvotes dampen low-value comments. I know downvotes do bad things too, but that's the good thing they do, and it's big. Taking that away and/or increasing the noise with a flood of people disagreeing about their disagreements would not be an optimization. Downvoting does gets used as an outlet for undesirable behaviors, but it's a non sequitur to blame that on downvoting. Those undesirable behaviors are sadly inevitable and will make use of any tool at hand. In my view they do less damage via downvotes than they would otherwise. A recurring theme in the Perennial Downvote Debate is the idea of having a site where everyone presents their disagreements rationally. That's sadly not possible on the public internet—not even close—so we're not going to risk HN on trying to create it. What we will do is keep looking for incremental improvements. We've found a few (e.g. vouching) in the last couple years, and there are probably more to be found. Edit: this later comment is relevant here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16131314 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16131314
- rahimnathwani 10y agoThanks so much for the thoughtful and detailed reply. Your penultimate paragraph convinced me. I'm glad you folks are so careful when making changes :)