6 ms·
Promises and pitfalls of applying computational models to mental disorders
- Houshalter 10y agoWhy is this being upvoted? There is no content here.
- tcj_phx 10y agoYou can read the full paper if you click on the 'DOI' link at the bottom, which takes you to this page: http://brain.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2016/08/18/brain.aww209 http://brain.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2016/08/18/bra...
- wonkaWonka 10y agoThe full paper seems to be more of a study of studies, in that it mostly cites other research projects, and groups together studies that hold water. http://m.brain.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2016/08/18/brain.aww209.full http://m.brain.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2016/08/18/b... In the "challenges" it warns against reinforcing one's own opinion by cherry-picking data that suites preferences, and also falling into chicken-and-the-egg situations, where cause and effect or symptom and disease might invert. There aren't any actual experiments in this paper. It just says bayesian analysis is a useful tool, and cites instances of success.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tcj_phx 10y agoIn June some scientists in Australia published their paper that links an inability to produce cortisol to psychosis: https://www.jcu.edu.au/news/releases/2016/june/stress-hormone-link-with-psychosis https://www.jcu.edu.au/news/releases/2016/june/stress-hormon... Cortisol is produced from Cholesterol (through a couple steps [1]). Cholesterol gets turned into pregnenolone in the mitochondria. My girlfriend did a lot of damage to her mitochondria with cocaine. 5 months after meeting me, she came to appreciate that "drugs" were causing her problems, and tried to quit everything cold turkey. Now she's getting professionally mistreated by Psychiatry. They are trying to suppress the symptom of "psychosis" without caring why it's being exhibited. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Steroidogenesis.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Steroidogenesis.svg There is a ton of "technical debt" in the study of "mental disorders". Most of the research just needs to be thrown out. It would be much more productive to assume that people with mental problems are exhausted, give them cytomel (a T3 analogue), Retinol (Vitamin A), pregnenolone, and sugar, then re-evaluate.
- DenisM 10y agoCan you expand on your suggested treatments? Cytomel seems to be indicated for thyroid problems which are being routinely tested during psychiatry treatment.
- tcj_phx 10y agoThere is a lot of technical debt in treating thyroid problems too. T4 needs to be converted to T3 to stimulate the metabolism; most of this conversion happens in the liver. If the patient's liver doesn't work very well (because she's damaged it with cocaine, for example), she can have normal a normal Thyroid Stimulating Hormone (TSH) level, and normal T4 thyroid levels, but still be hypothyroid. Cholesterol's conversion to pregnenolone requires T3-thyroid and Vitamin A (NOT 'beta carotene', which is a provitamin). By also supplementing Pregnenolone, and maybe progesterone, the patient has a better chance of being able to make Cortisol, if they need it. Also treating with sugar reduces the need for cortisol.
- pasbesoin 10y agoThank you very much for taking the time to write these comments. I have a friend in somewhat similar circumstances, though she does not appear to be manifesting overt psychosis. Nor do I have full insight into her treatment; however, the ongoing appointments are very infrequent. Hospitalization did give her 6 days with a very well regarded addiction specialist, and the ongoing medications as the result of his prescribing appear to be doing good. Among other things, she's become very consistent about getting good quantities of sleep. She's been a bit worried about her diet and weight gain. Some of the cravings, I now see as potentially lining up with your description. Maybe she can "let this go" for a while, while her body continues to recover and rebuild -- to the extent it can. Any opinion on exercise? She runs extensively, although some new soft tissue irritation is now potentially putting a multiple month crimp in this. That exercise is new in her life, as of a couple of years ago. I hope it is sparking her body's capacity to renew itself.
- tcj_phx 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jrapdx3 10y agoIt's a worthy subject, that interests me from in both its computational and behavioral aspects. As is the case in most applications of computing, the crucial aspect is the "match" between the model and the domain being modeled. The behavioral domain is particularly problematic. Humans quite naturally use abstraction as a modeling tool, and the tendency is to construct abstract categories as a basis of sorting the "raw data" of observation. The difficulty in the behavioral realm is that phenomena are indistinct and sharply bounded "boxes" don't correspond very well to the real-world behavioral complexities. In the article the distinction between psychotic and affective disorders is pointed out as an example of the "softness" of phenomenological boundaries. If we conceptualize the distinction as an array of cardboard boxes side by side, psychosis in one box, mood disorder in another one, the compartments of the model will not fit what is seen in a clinical setting. Rather in the real-world conditions resemble sand dunes, rounded peaks flowing into surrounding soft peaks, and no particular place where it could be said one dune stops and another starts. Furthermore the confluence of a surprisingly huge array of factors is involved in the appearance or origin of behavior we'd consider problematic (if we could even agree on that). I'd concur with the idea that computational models need to be consistent with and informed by the reality they are intended to represent, but experience suggests that the more fundamental issue is conceptualization of behavioral reality itself which is far more complex than our usual abstraction of it lead us to consider.