6 ms·
The cops' response will be: "Bullshit. You have to know the password, and you're going to sit in that cell until you tell us what it is." Don't try to hack aro
by bitwize 10y ago
The cops' response will be: "Bullshit. You have to know the password, and you're going to sit in that cell until you tell us what it is."
Don't try to hack around the law. You'll fail.
- Qantourisc 10y agoHow about under stress you have trouble remember the password, and thinking of the wrong password, can corrupt your knowledge of the right password (in my experience and knowledge this can actually happen yes)? How about old encrypted backup zips ? Encrypted media files from your browser by media streaming services ? How about pressure ? How about some people cannot remember a password without being in the right place (yes this exists) ? How about passwords you use for more then service ? What about public encryptions keys stored on your computer, are they encrypted data or random bytes ? How about the stenography data probably encoded in the music you downloaded from your music provider ? These sort of laws create many problems one can not hope solve without a few punishing/ruining the life/killing of a few innocent bystanders.
- pif 10y ago> How about under stress you have trouble remember the password Reply will be: "You'll get plenty of time in jail to relax and think about it".
- someAccount1231 10y agoI know we're talking about Canada in the article, and that there are differences in the laws around this. There's a guy currently sitting in a US jail, I think in Georgia, held on contempt of court charges. He was originally charged with murder, and during his trial, he managed to goad the judge into an absurd argument, part of which involved the defendant wanting to defend himself. I'll skip the details. There's a Rick and Morty cartoon out there about it... Anyways, to my point. The judge has the power to keep this guy in jail more or less indefinitely. You can argue with the cops, you can argue with your lawyer, but if it's in the law and you try to argue it with the judge, you're staying in jail.
- bobdole1234 10y agoCanada has strong protections against indefinite incarceration.
- DanBC 10y ago5 years isn't indefinite. It's definite. 5 years is a ridiculously long time, but it's what England implemented for RIPA if the encrypted material is thought to be images of child sexual abuse.
- noir_lord 10y agoI'd have to look it up but if I recall correctly in the UK not disclosing your password carries a penalty of 2 years maximum. Which if you think about it is stupid since in a situation where you have encrypted data that proves your are a terroist, paedophile or serious criminal, 2 years for not disclosing your password vs 10+ for disclosing it is simple game theory. Not to mention the stigma of going to prison for not disclosing your password vs the above mentioned crimes.
- perfectfire 10y agoIt's not "hacking" around the law anymore than stopping at a red light instead of blowing right through it is "hacking" around traffic laws. If I literally do not know the password the onus is on the prosecution to prove that I do know it before they can put me in jail. And if you think the police get to hold you in contempt of court or convict you of not following the password reveal law you clearly have no idea how the justice system works.