4 ms·
> to pander to users who are apparently too stupid to notice that the focus is somewhere other than the text field they're entering into I think you've just in
by viraptor 10y ago
> to pander to users who are apparently too stupid to notice that the focus is somewhere other than the text field they're entering into
I think you've just insulted a lot of people. I've run into the backspace behaviour multiple times and never on purpose. Here's a few reasons why it can happen, apart from stupidly mashing my keyboard, which I assure you, doesn't happen very often:
- touchpad not registering a click on the text field
- element reloading due to weird js and losing focus
- tab switching properly between the first 4 fields, but then focusing some random button instead of the 5th input
- broken custom JS elements which don't quite understand focus and editing
- general keypress hijacking which doesn't do what you want
I don't look at the keyboard as I type and I don't always look at the screen either. I expect the text actions (input and editing) to work on text. If I have to think about which possible, implicit mode I'm operating in, it's a bad design. Or are you saying that before every keypress you visually verify where your cursor is, is it blinking, is the right window focused, are there multiple cursors with fake focus, etc?
- userbinator 10y agotouchpad not registering a click on the text field It's not hard to notice whether an element has focused, and especially if you know you have flaky hardware, be aware of that. All your other reasons are the fault of the website, not the browser. I expect the text actions (input and editing) to work on text. If I have to think about which possible, implicit mode I'm operating in, it's a bad design. You're implying that the computer somehow magically (telepathically?) determines exactly where your input is to go. That's not possible. Or are you saying that before every keypress you visually verify where your cursor is, is it blinking, is the right window focused, are there multiple cursors with fake focus, etc? In a word, yes. It's seriously not hard to see where the focus is. I usually have multiple windows open but there is only one cursor and it's the only thing that's blinking. Many others I've seen maximise their browser window, so there shouldn't be other cursors much less blinking ones visible (unless there is some strange bug which does cause this --- in which case that is definitely a bug to be fixed). If I'm at all unsure, I make sure. Besides, if I'm going to submit some very long text, I'll write it all in a real text editor first and then copy-paste. I don't always look at the screen either. That's like saying "I don't always look at where I'm going when I drive. Why do I keep crashing into things?"
- JadeNB 10y ago> All your other reasons are the fault of the website, not the browser. It would be a beautifully principled stand for a browser to take to refuse to fix the problems of a web site, but the result would be a browser that couldn't navigate the web. After all, the first problem it would refuse to fix would be invalid HTML.
- galacticpony 10y agoYou're extremely self-centered and dismissive of other people's experience, I have to say. I'm sorry, but maintaining your little piece of convenience isn't worth denying other users a more forgiving user experience. You're probably a twenty-something with sharp reflexes. What's "not that hard" to you on whatever websites you happen to use may be a significant challenge for older people who are forced to use terribly designed websites/webapps for work or other services.
- userbinator 10y agoYou're extremely self-centered and dismissive of other people's experience, I have to say. The same could be said of the developers who think they're always right. I'm sorry, but maintaining your little piece of convenience isn't worth denying other users a more forgiving user experience. Judging by the other comments here, I'm not the only one who uses this shortcut. You're probably a twenty-something with sharp reflexes. I'm much older than that. If anything it's the younger generation who are driving most of these unpleasant UI changes and dumbing things down. Reflexes have nothing to do with it. Read carefully, slow down, and pay attention to what you're doing. What's "not that hard" to you on whatever websites you happen to use may be a significant challenge for older people who are forced to use terribly designed websites/webapps for work or other services. That goes back to my original suggestion of having a prompt dialog, and making it configurable for those who don't want the "permanent training wheels".
- viraptor 10y ago> The same could be said of the developers who think they're always right. Browsers often include telemetry which can answer questions like "how many of backspace presses to go to the previous page were accidents" which may prove them right. While I don't know if that or a similar method was used or not, why do you think they just "think they're always right"? What if they did a proper research on the usability of this change and found you're in extreme minority?