4 ms·
Calling this a "venture-backed startup" is a stretch. It was really just a con. One couldn't reasonably expect a single author who wrote five westerns all by he
by jessaustin 10y ago
Calling this a "venture-backed startup" is a stretch. It was really just a con. One couldn't reasonably expect a single author who wrote five westerns all by herself to net $250k for her efforts. They didn't really expect to be able to pay back the investor after buying all those goodies for themselves, even if they could have gotten a single book written.
- sigacts 10y agoI agree with your assessment. What is intetesting is that this group structured the deal like a venture-backed company. The LLC documents looked like many other versions I have seen. The Scoundrel folks thought that this formation scheme gave them immunity from accountability.
- will_brown 10y agoI see it quite regularly where laymen create an LLC, find themselves personally liable for company actions/debts and then can not wrap their mind around how they could be liable for an entity that is literally called a limited liability company. It actually reminds me of the people who take the opinion that in the magical world of the DAO no one can be liable for anything because by definition if an action occurred, then it is legal because it was contractually agreed to. It's an important lesson to learn that corporate veils can be pierced and contracts can be voided (i.e. unfair; deceptive; fraud in the inducment; illegal; etc...).
- tamana 10y agoThe word "limited liability" refers to the fact that the owners are liability only for an amount up to their investment, within the scope of the corporation. The limit refers to the investment, not the fact that criminal activity is still legal exposure. Obviously an owner cannot sign away liability for individual criminal activity, same as with any corporation.
- will_brown 10y agoAnd while you have stated the rule, what people don't understand is the exceptions in which members/owners of LLCs can in fact be personally liable above and beyond their investment in the entity.
- 35bge57dtjku 10y agoI'd think a web portal that fits the bill could be constructed for about 10k, maybe 20k. So I wonder if the rest could have actually paid for the 5 novels. > One couldn't reasonably expect a single author who wrote five westerns all by herself to net $250k for her efforts. Why not, that's too low for any author? I would have thought they could find someone somewhere who'd agree to make 5 mediocre, somewhat short novels for 150k total, maybe someone just starting out. Wouldn't that have at least been a real effort and protected them from being charged with fraud? That'd leave them with 80k in profit. They'd still have to get around the part where they agree money won't be used for their salaries, but they'd at least have fulfilled the letter of the agreement. And 80k for a few weeks of work is pretty good, imo.
- DanBC 10y ago> Why not, that's too low for any author? It feels like a bit of a gamble to write a series of books and throw a huge marketing budget at them. That's what publishers have been doing, and it doesn't work for most of their books. Average earnings for published authors in UK is £11k pa. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/apr/20/earnings-authors-below-minimum-wage https://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/apr/20/earnings-autho... > The top 10% of professional authors, those who make £60,000 or more a year from their writing, earned 58% of all the money made by professional authors in 2013, and the top 5%, those making more than £100,000, earned 42.3% of that money. The top 1%, who make mean average earnings of more than £450,000, take 22.7% of all earnings, said the Authors’ Licensing & Collecting Society, which commissioned the UK-based survey. > The picture for lower-earning writers was much bleaker. The bottom 50% of authors were those who earned less than £10,500 in 2013, and accounted for just 7% of the amount earned by all writers put together. And 17% of all writers did not earn anything at all during 2013, said the ALCS, adding that 98% of those authors had published a work every year from 2010 to 2013. I dunno, does this make it sound like the scam / system described in the submission is worth a punt?
- 35bge57dtjku 10y ago> It feels like a bit of a gamble to write a series of books and throw a huge marketing budget at them. How much money would they even have had to spend on marketing the books, given they would have their own web portal? > I dunno, does this make it sound like the scam / system described in the submission is worth a punt? Maybe not if you're trying to make a successful business. But if you're trying to do the bare minimum to quickly score about 80k usd while still protecting yourself from fraud/felony charges, wouldn't this be good news? It sounds like you could easily find an author who'd be happy with 10k or even 15k per year.
- fencepost 10y agoThe description of what they were proposing sounds like a whole stream of shlock Westerns from the late 80s - the Western equivalent of Harlequin romances, complete with series numbers that reached into triple digits. You used to see whole shelves of these in used book stores. Took a bit of searching, but stuff like the Trailsman and Longarm series, some of which may still be alive - and with close to 400 books in the series. I have to agree with jessaustin - this was a con. The fact that they were able to leverage a securities connection into felony charges does not make it venture capital. Edit: see http://www.readersadvice.com/readadv/000214.html http://www.readersadvice.com/readadv/000214.html for a list of some series and books in them.
- chris11 10y agoTheir plan seemed really unfocused too. They wanted to create a major website just to run ads on it. I agree, this just looks like a con.
- chiph 10y agoWell, it worked for the "Million Dollar Homepage" guy. But yeah, I smell scam.
- michaelbuckbee 10y agoThe one interesting aspect of this that jumped out of me was product placement within the novels. Has this ever actually happened? It's ubiquitous in TV and movies, but novels?
- ufmace 10y agoExactly what I thought. It doesn't look like they made even a minimal effort to actually create what they told the investor they were going to create. Sounds more like they slapped together a plausible-sounding story to con some guy out of a pile of cash, and tried to use standard startup investment stuff to shield themselves from liability for running a con. Which also means that trying to take lessons from them seems kinda silly. If you're not trying to run a con, you don't need a web list to tell you how to not look like you're running a con. The only one to take lessons from here is the investor. If you're new to investing, don't invest money in a random startup run by strangers based on a slick pitch. Do hire some people who know what they're talking about to do some due diligence. If you're putting a quarter mil at risk, it's worth at least spending a few grand to make sure they're legit.