3 ms·
> in the US zones tend to be exclusive but in Japan the zones limit the maximum nuisance in a zone It's not just japan, I'm not sure the US-style exclusive euc
by masklinn 10y ago
> in the US zones tend to be exclusive but in Japan the zones limit the maximum nuisance in a zone
It's not just japan, I'm not sure the US-style exclusive euclidian zoning is practiced anywhere else, if only for historical reasons: in most countries cities grew organically and mixed-use.
- stretchwithme 10y agoProbably very impractical arrangements can only survive when most people have the resources to compensate. In a country with few resources, it never even gets off the ground. And if it ever did, that could have been hundreds of years ago, longer than the US has to learn what works. When we are young, we can do many impractical things. But if we make it to being old, its likely we've let a lot of those things go. So too with cities.
- makomk 10y agoThe UK is mixed-use pretty much everywhere, but you still need planning permission to change a property from residential to commercial or industrial use, or to change it between different classifications of each of those uses. From what I can tell there are legal and possibly even constitutional issues with handling planning restrictions in this way in the US. Basically, it seems the US ended up with rigid zoning restrictions because it's impossible to have the finer-grained restrictions that other countries do.
- masklinn 10y ago> you still need planning permission to change a property from residential to commercial or industrial use, or to change it between different classifications of each of those uses. I'm not saying other countries don't have forms of zoning (japan, the subject of the article, certainly does) I'm saying few to no countries have as exclusive and tight zoning as the US.