5 ms·
So you want the tier of graduates not good enough to get a real job to teach the next wave of students? That sounds like a downward spiral.
by brianwawok 10y ago
So you want the tier of graduates not good enough to get a real job to teach the next wave of students? That sounds like a downward spiral.
- WalterBright 10y agoI didn't say graduates, I said students. Students often have trouble getting jobs because they need part time jobs, and industry wants full time. Teaching a class at CC would be part time.
- protomyth 10y agoA lot of CCs having the problem are rather a long commute from an university. We're over 100 miles from the closest 4 year.
- WalterBright 10y agoOn the other hand, a lot of CCs are close by major universities. It doesn't have to work for all CCs in order to be very practical for many of them. Also, college students often go home for the summer, where they have a hard time finding summer jobs. A local CC offering to hire them to teach a summer class in programming would be a win-win for everyone concerned.
- protomyth 10y agoYou'll find a lot of summer attendance in CCs is a lot lower due to summer jobs students take (many low experience jobs are available in summer unlike other seasons). To the point, a lot of 9 month contracts are happening much like regular schools.
- WalterBright 10y agoI don't really understand your point. Is it because it won't work 100% of the time for 100% of the CCs it should never be considered? Because it seems clear to me that for situations where it can work, it should be considered. Of course summer attendance is less. So there are fewer classes. Why is that a problem if there are enough people wanting to learn programming in the summer to form a class? Heck, I learned accounting in summer school. The college had 10x the number of accounting students during the rest of the year, but in the summer they still had enough to fill one class and found a local instructor who wanted to supplement his income. Are you suggesting that should not have happened?
- protomyth 10y agoMy point is its of limited utility to a lot of institutions because students need to earn money and summer is the time to do it. Plus, the accreditation rules have changed in recent years to make people without a 4 year degrees (and indeed in some areas without a Masters) to be problematic for teaching.
- WalterBright 10y agoSo it should not be done at all? > to be problematic Another example of good intentions gone awry.
- protomyth 10y ago> So it should not be done at all? Maybe other institutions could do it and get away with it. I cannot see the average CC with normal staffing, student, and rule patterns. > Another example of good intentions gone awry. ? We have to live with the rules the accreditation boards set. You lose your accreditation and its game over and the whole community suffers from not only the loss of a learning institution, but an employer and social work organization.
- WalterBright 10y agoOf course, such a course in programming doesn't have to be accredited. But for those in favor of bureaucratic rules over getting things done, they'll have to settle for no programming instruction in CCs.
- protomyth 10y ago> Of course, such a course in programming doesn't have to be accredited. If the course is not accredited, it doesn't transfer and it doesn't count towards a degree. If it doesn't count for any degree we might as well do a workshop with certificates and hire a one shot instructor or contract for one from a company. That is something we already do and would not trust to a student. > But for those in favor of bureaucratic rules over getting things done, they'll have to settle for no programming instruction in CCs. I don't think you get the whole CC thing. Not following those rules, like murdering someone, would be an death sentence.
- shagie 10y agoConsidering where I was in college and my skills at teaching then (and even now to an extent - mentoring is another matter), I would be very concerned about me, or my peers back when I was in college to be responsible for teaching a class on programming. And that was when things were simple (you used vi and make). While I am sure that there are many individuals who now come in with more code experience than the typical college student in the early 90s, there is a significant aspect of "are you mature enough to teach?" and "do you have enough experience to help students that need help?" Assisting teaching a class, maybe. But looking at the quality of the code I wrote and the advice I would give based on that code that I wrote, I would be very concerned for the future prospects of anyone who I taught when I was 21 and looking for a summer job.
- WalterBright 10y agoCollege students often provide paid tutoring of students a year or two behind them on an ad-hoc basis, should that be prevented? The choice for CCs isn't between student teachers and experienced degree'd teachers. It's between student teachers and no teachers or teachers who know nothing about programming.
- protomyth 10y ago> College students often provide paid tutoring of students a year or two behind them on an ad-hoc basis, should that be prevented? The skills needed to run a classroom and the skills needed to tutor are quite different. I am unaware of any current rules about the education-level of tutors, and I doubt there are or will be any. > The choice for CCs isn't between student teachers and experienced degree'd teachers. It's between student teachers and no teachers or teachers who know nothing about programming. Student teachers (unless part of a TA situation and supervised) probably aren't a solution either unless we're talking certificates and not college credits. Determining Qualified Faculty Through HLC’s Criteria for Accreditation and Assumed Practices: http://download.hlcommission.org/FacultyGuidelines_2016_OPB.pdf http://download.hlcommission.org/FacultyGuidelines_2016_OPB....
- 10y ago