8 ms·
The $100 muon detector
- brudgers 10y agoThe paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/1606.01196 https://arxiv.org/abs/1606.01196
- godber 10y agoThe paper contains the following link to the supplementary material which contains BOM, PCB drawings and some code: https://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/102942 https://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/102942 Edit: spelling and a little more info.
- 1_listerine_pls 10y agoAny practical use?
- nefitty 10y ago"Conrad and Axani have taken the detector down into the Boston subway, using the changes in the muon count to calculate the depth of the train tunnels." The main point, though, is to expose younger students to undergraduate-level physics concepts cheaply and easily.
- CamperBob2 10y agoIt's a great educational project for a physics class, from what I can tell. The article (http://arxiv.org/abs/1606.01196 http://arxiv.org/abs/1606.01196) is nicely detailed and accessible to undergraduates. Good introduction to instrument design and construction, especially if (as the author suggests) the students are asked to write their own analysis software for it. As far as applications go, the article offers a few ideas: 1. Measure the relative depths of subway stations across the city, using the measured muon rates. 2. Test relativistic time dilation on the cosmic ray flux by measuring the flux at various elevations, such as in an airplane or on a mountain, compared to sea level. 3. Investigate correlations between the atmospheric temperature/pressure/humidity and the count rate. 4. Investigate seasonal variations in muon rates. 5. Using multiple detectors, measure the angular muon rate by looking at the coincidence rate. 6. Lower the gain of the circuit to look at high-energy stopping muon events. Investigate whether or not one can see the Michel electron from the muon decay. Tempted to build one, but I don't immediately understand how it discriminates between muons and other forms of ionizing radiation that an ordinary Geiger counter will pick up.
- kaybe 10y agoScintillators are able to resolve particle energy, and can be used to measure a spectrum. Muons have very high energy, which can be used to identify them. For extra certainty, you can use two stacked scintillators and only count a signal if it occurs in both of them within nanoseconds. This also allows determining the rough direction the particle came from since a particle that comes in at a low angle will not hit both detectors. Changing the distance between the scintillators will change the solid angle the instrument can 'see'. (as given by 5 in your list) This guide for a student experiment has more background than the paper you linked: http://home.fnal.gov/~group/WORK/muonDetection.pdf http://home.fnal.gov/~group/WORK/muonDetection.pdf
- pif 10y ago> Scintillators are able to resolve particle energy No, scintillators only detect a particle going through.
- nullc 10y agoMy (NaI based) gamma spectrometer disagrees.
- nagrom 10y agoI suspect that this is a question of energy. At high energies, it's difficult/impossible to stop a particle, so you place a row of scintillators out, bend the charged particle path using a magnetic field and measure its displacement (and thus velocity and thus energy). At lower energies, you can stop the particle in, e.g. an NaI detector which is known as calorimetry. Typically, of course, cosmic rays are quite high energy and given the low rate of muon interaction calorimetry is difficult/impossible. A HEP physicist may use both techniques, e.g. by using heavy-metal plates to cause an EM cascade and measure the resultant shower in a crystalline detector. But typically when one talks of scintillator devices (and almost certainly in the case of cosmic rays) one talks of tracking and measuring deflection in magnetic fields if wanting to measure the energy.
- 10y ago
- pif 10y agoWhy, does it need any?
- stephengillie 10y agoImagine outfitting a datacenter with these, and using them to understand the rate of bit flips in your processors. Maybe we'll find some parts of the Earth have fewer cosmic rays hitting there, and are thus are more naturally suited to being datacenters.
- keithpeter 10y agoThe basements of large buildings made from concrete spring to mind, then geographical areas that are at or below sea level. Random thought: anti-coincidence detector? A detector above the RAM chips and one below with data processing set so that if the detector above gets a count and the one below does not or sees a count with significantly lower energy, you know some energy has been absorbed somewhere near the RAM.
- nagrom 10y agoThis won't work because all particle detectors are noisy. Pretty much all tracking detectors need to use multiple coincidences to determine that a muon has indeed passed by. Individual counts by themselves are not reliable. My past life as a particle physicist included design and build of muon detectors using scintillating plastic and (much more expensive) multi-anode photomultipliers to look at nuclear composition of volumes. Something like an underfunded British version of decision sciences http://www.decisionsciences.com/ http://www.decisionsciences.com/ :-)
- InclinedPlane 10y ago> The basements of large buildings made from concrete spring to mind What is concrete made out of? Rocks? What do rocks contain? Radioactive elements. So that's not actually the best way to protect against radiation.
- frumiousirc 10y agoThe energy involved in radioactive decay is far less than that of cosmic rays. If the goal is to protect ICs from bit flips then indeed putting them under concrete or natural rock will reduce them.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoInteresting, I was just looking at the SiPM (its $132 qty 1 (http://sensl.com/estore/microfc-60035-smt/) http://sensl.com/estore/microfc-60035-smt/)), nice to see it in use.
- tim333 10y agoGiven muons can catalyse the nuclear fusion of deuterium and tritium I wonder if you could extend this to your own very low power fusion reactor? Not quite sure where you get the deuterium and tritium. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion
- gravypod 10y agoTritium from firearms optics or iron sight paint and you'd need to make the deuterium. Both quite expensive and still very doable.
- ape4 10y agoThe next sensor for phones?
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoPut it into a usb stick, or a keychain, and we could all be collecting data. The internet of things