3 ms·
> The neural network is a program that is the result of a search for a function specialized to playing Go. This machine, the program that the parameters across
by visarga 10y ago
> The neural network is a program that is the result of a search for a function specialized to playing Go. This machine, the program that the parameters across the edges in the graph represent, is logically unable to run any other program. Lee Sedol is a Universal Machine in the Turing sense
I am sure he is using different neurons for playing Go than for playing poker. His Go-related neural net is only able to play go.
- Cybiote 10y agoThat doesn't make sense. The brain is highly interconnected and there's no such thing as a "Go" or poker area. Many of the same structures are recruited for different tasks. For example, the part for recognizing faces will also be recruited for reading letters or playing Go. But the important thing here is that AlphaGo is a fixed program. It's no different than chrome or firefox in that it can no longer do learning based modifications on itself. In a sense, it's actually more limited than a browser in that it cannot simulate arbitrary Turing Machines. As a feedforward network, it's not Turing Complete. Lee Sedol meanwhile is at least as capable as a Universal Turing Machine and was learning far more per game and modifying himself while also doing the highly complex tasks of vision integrated motion planning.