4 ms·
I don't say this lightly, but wasn't the open source license of MySQL the main source of its success? As I recall, it didn't really get huge until they loosene
by tomcam 10y ago
I don't say this lightly, but wasn't the open source license of MySQL the main source of its success? As I recall, it didn't really get huge until they loosened up the licensing terms. And wasn't that one of the main reasons it made $1 billion? Not criticizing – his business is his business. Just curious.
- ben_jones 10y agoWould PHP have become popular if MySQL had maintained a strict license? I wasn't a web developer at the time and am genuinely curious what the database landscape was like back then.
- kyriakos 10y agoPostgre would probably been used instead. The demand for an easy to use Web scripting language existed, php fit the bill that's what pushed mysql to become popular.
- oblio 10y agoI kind of doubt it. The Windows port of PostgreSQL was kind of lacking for a long time (8.0, released in 2010, brought the first native Windows server version) and a large group of PHP developers were Windows developers.
- mpol 10y agoI don't remember Postgres having much traction around 2000 or before. Since there was "always" MySQL available, Postgres wasn't in need of development, for most people MySQL was sufficient. If MySQL had been less open, Postgres might have gotten momentum years earlier to fill that gap on the low web-end. I can imagine Postgres popularity in recent years is because people are replacing Oracle databases with Postgres, they are looking for a way out of that. Or even more, newer companies don't even look at starting with Oracle, but start on Postgres right away.
- z92 10y agoMySQL replaced mSQL [miniSQL]. A bare minimum SQL server that didn't even have table joins. But was used with PHP on the web regardless. Because the alternate was to code your own text file database. MySQL was so much better over it all. Postgress did exist at that time. Was called Postgress95. I compiled and ran it on a linux machine. And it crashed as soon as I tried to connect from a remote host.
- montywi 10y agoPHP was supporting MySQL way before MySQL was Open Source. MySQL was released in 1995 under a liberal but commercial license (You should pay if you make money with MySQL) but was changed to GPL in 2000 "when we had got enough money in the bank to be able afford the switch".
- macmac 10y agoThe existence of an open source version was surely a big part of the success, but so was the existence of a commercial option.
- montywi 10y agoNot that MySQL was created before Open Source was coined. MySQL was hugely popular (several millions of users) way before it was GPL. David and I always planned to make MySQL Free Software, but we needed first to get enough momentum to be able to afford it. We also needed to come up with a business model that would work with GPL. MySQL was the first software that was using Dual Licensing on GPl.
- pmorici 10y agoDid you read the article? It addresses this question and talks about the reasons to use the traditional style open source license that MySQL used vs. this new BSL license.
- GavinMcG 10y agoOne of the HN Guidelines is to avoid that introductory bit: > Please don't insinuate that someone hasn't read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that."
- cowsandmilk 10y agoThe article does not discuss the history of MySQL. MySQL existed for 5 years before it went GPL[1]. Understanding what license was used for the first 5 years of the company and whether that impeded success would be useful. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20010601152026/http://mysql.com/news/article-23.html https://web.archive.org/web/20010601152026/http://mysql.com/...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]