3 ms·
That's a great analogy. Although I think it's rather more like DRM - you want a "program" to only "run" if some "key" is present, and your adversary wants to ma
by dTal 10y ago
That's a great analogy. Although I think it's rather more like DRM - you want a "program" to only "run" if some "key" is present, and your adversary wants to make the smallest possible change to the program to run it without the key.
It was something of a lightbulb moment for me when it finally clicked why "perfect" DRM is impossible: no matter how convoluted and obfuscated your locking mechanism is, somewhere in there it all boils down to a final if-then - "did the authentication pass?". And this can always be patched to return "yes" instead of "no", trivially bypassing the whole thing. And you can't get around it even with drastic measures like encrypting the source and providing the key on demand - the key can always be saved. The code can always be made to run, and DRM can always be short circuited.
Carrying the analogy back to biology: so they've made their organisms reliant on a new amino acid. Who's to say it won't learn to synthesize its needed building block? After all, it's all the same atoms. The key can always be saved...
Still, it seems they did attempt to provoke this, and failed. DRM doesn't have to be theoretically perfect to be effective. It's impressive stuff, engineering organisms with an incompatible genetic code - maybe not be a panacea, but it definitely helps.