4 ms·
>the motivation [for building fallout shelters] had never made much sense to me, since in most cases the supplies would only have been sufficient to last a few
by hollerith 10y ago
>the motivation [for building fallout shelters] had never made much sense to me, since in most cases the supplies would only have been sufficient to last a few weeks or so, while the deadly radioactive fallout from numerous Soviet thermonuclear strikes on our urban centers would have been long-lasting.
Uh, fallout is only deadly for a few weeks or so even after thousands of nuclear weapons are used on a country.
The radioactive elements produced in a nuclear explosion are very different from those produced in a nuclear power plant: the latter can stay deadly for years.
The reason fallout shelters were so popular during the Cold War is that they're a cost effective way of avoiding a major cause of death during a nuclear war.
- 7952 10y agoA few of the fallout products have a long half life and can cause harmful effects. Do you consider those to be not deadly? Could they exist in sufficient quantities to be an issue? Also a ground bursting weapon could interact with other elements present at ground zero so it seems more complex than just "wait a few weeks and it's safe".
- hollerith 10y agoGround bursts do produce a lot more fallout than air bursts, but that's been taken into account. The worst fallout would probably be downwind of the ICBM silos both because of the number and the size of the weapons used and the fact that they'd be ground bursts. Downwind of the ICBM silos, one might have to stay in a fallout shelter for 4 weeks or even a little longer. Fallout can be even higher IIRC within a few miles of the explosion, but implicit in the concept of the fallout shelter (as opposed to the much more expensive blast shelter) is the assumption that the shelter will be outside of the range in which the explosion is immediately deadly to humans (through blast, through heat / infrared radiation and through "prompt" radiation). Note that even before the START treaties, the Soviets only ever had enough weapons to cause immediate death to humans over approximately 5% of the area of the United States. Consequently, many suburban and rural American could and can realistically expect to survive the immediate effects of the explosions with fallout being the main danger in the weeks immediately after the attack. After a few weeks, starvation starts to become the main danger although note that as of a 1985 survey, the US had enough food stored (mainly on farms, mostly wheat, corn, grain sorghums, and soybeans) to keep 200 million Americans from starving for 6 years. This information comes from Cresson Kearny's Nuclear War Survival Skills, revised 1986 or 1987, which is available for free in PDF form on the internet. Kearny was employed by the American civil-defense establishment.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> This information comes from Cresson Kearny's Nuclear War Survival Skills, revised 1986 or 1987, which is available for free in PDF form on the internet. Kearny was employed by the American civil-defense establishment. I'm not sure how much faith to put into that despite the source you just cited. From what I heard, a lot of the nuclear war survival measures (like city evacuation plans) were just methods to calm the population down. I.e. they weren't really meant to work at all, but as long as people believed they will, they carried on with their lives.
- mikeash 10y agoThere is a ton of misinformation out there, and it tends to greatly overestimate the dangers of nuclear weapons. For example, it's a common assumption that global thermonuclear war would wipe out humanity, or even all life on Earth. That's not even close to true. Billions would die and civilization would be wrecked, but the human race would continue. For an example specific to civil defense, the old "duck and cover" routine is widely ridiculed. Which is bizarre, because it's great advice which would have saved many lives in the event of nuclear war. But people don't understand how this stuff works, and just think that nuclear war is a moment where all die, O the embarrassment. With sufficient warning, evacuating cities would have saved many lives. Such warning wouldn't have been available for ICBM strikes, but in the 50s and 60s the threat was bombers, which would have provided hours of warning.
- 7952 10y agoOf course a full on nuclear war could cause hurricane force winds and fire storms. Does anyone really know how far that could spread? There is a lot of vegetation in close proximity to targets, and in places little to stop a fire spreading for hundreds of miles through crops and forest. Also, you would have to deal with the fallout from the nuclear power plants that have just been mixed into those hurrican force winds. Humanity may survive but the effects could be felt far beyond the blast radius of the bombs.
- 10y ago
- akira2501 10y ago> Uh, fallout is only deadly for a few weeks or so even after thousands of nuclear weapons are used on a country. The amount of fallout and types of products generated in a nuclear blast are mostly determined by the altitude the bomb detonates at. If you let it blast a few thousand feet in the air, before it hits the ground, then you are correct. This is typical strategy because it doesn't destroy the ground and the air blast has an absolutely devastating effect on man made structures. However, if you let the bomb get all the way down to the dirt or even slightly below it before you detonate, then much of that radiation is absorbed by all that matter and spread out over a large distance. You can also design the bomb case so that it transmits this radiation rather than absorbing it further increasing the fallout and it's intensity.
- hollerith 10y agoWhen calculating how long Americans would need to remain in fallout shelters, the assumption was made that ground bursts would be used wherever that is the most effective way for the attacker to achieve his objectives. Certainly, they would be used to attack hardened underground bunkers and the ICBM silos. Yes, ground bursts produce a lot more fallout than air bursts, but that has been taken into account when calculating that most Americans would need to stay in their fallout shelters for 2 or 3 weeks at the most. The science behind fallout is well-understood.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIs it? I mean, I'd usually assume you're correct - government agencies and scientists tend to have stuff like that figured out pretty well. But in this case, I've heard numerous claims before that a lot of that was "security theatre" for the people - making them feel like they're being protected, even if nobody expected any of that to actually work.
- dghf 10y ago> Uh, fallout is only deadly for a few weeks or so even after thousands of nuclear weapons are used on a country. From Command and Control by Eric Schlosser: "Strontium-90 is a soft metal, much like lead, with a radioactive half-life of 29.1 years. It is usually present in the fallout released by thermonuclear explosions. When strontium-90 enters the soil, it's absorbed by plants grown in that soil--and by the animals that eat those plants. Once inside the human body, strontium-90 mimics calcium, accumulates in bone, and continues to emit radiation, often causing leukemia or bone cancer.... Along with cesium-137, a radioactive isotope with a half-life of 30 years, it may contaminate agricultural land for generations." Is that incorrect?
- 08-15 10y ago> Is that incorrect? Yes. The Sr-90 from a nuclear explosion will immediately oxidize in the atmosphere, so it is not a soft metal much like lead, but a brittle ceramic much like lime. It also has a half life of 28.8 years, not 29.1. Not that these details matter, but I'd still like to draw attention to Schlosser's tactics: By dumping these irrelevant facts that are only approximately right on you he seems a lot more knowledgeable than he really is. Back to the matter at hand... > Is that incorrect? Maybe, maybe not, but it surely is irrelevant. The radioactivity of fallout is dominated by very short lived fission products and by activation products that form when neutrons interact with vaporized soil. Most of these have half lives of hours to days. The radiation from something that short lived is intense and will kill humans quickly. A fallout shelter is intended to prevent exposure to that kind of radiation. By comparison, long lived fission products like Sr-90 don't matter. In a nuclear war, you worry about surviving the next few weeks. You don't worry about dying from leukemia 30 years later. (It also appears the link between Sr-90 and bone cancer or leukemia is merely a plausible assumption, not an actual observation.)