6 ms·
So, I know disrupting ecologies can have profound consequences that aren't obvious ahead of time, but let's do a thought experiment. Let's assume we have a 100
by kbenson 10y ago
So, I know disrupting ecologies can have profound consequences that aren't obvious ahead of time, but let's do a thought experiment. Let's assume we have a 100% effective way to kill all mosquitoes within 18-24 months.
What are the known disruptions and consequences of this? Do we have ways to combat problems due to that?
What are the probable/theoretical distuptions and consequences? Do we have have to combat these?
Not that I'm suggesting we do this, but with our current understanding, how much trouble do we think it would cause in the case of mosquitoes?
- maxerickson 10y agoYou only need to kill the species that bite humans (at least until others start biting humans). There are extermination technologies being experimented with that have quite a high level of effectiveness: http://fusion.net/story/333793/oxitec-zika-fighting-mosquitoes/ http://fusion.net/story/333793/oxitec-zika-fighting-mosquito...
- roywiggins 10y agoYou don't even need to kill all mosquitos, just the ones that bite humans and carry disease. South America actually did manage to nearly eradicate Aedes aegypti, though the success was short lived. Aedes aegypti is not even native to South America- it's African. So eliminating it from the New World can't do that much damage given that the ecosystem got along fine before it arrived.
- marblar 10y ago> Aedes aegypti is not even native to South America- it's African. So eliminating it from the New World can't do that much damage given that the ecosystem got along fine before it arrived. Could it not have crowded out some other niche that will be left empty if they were removed?
- jamescostian 10y ago> Aedes aegypti is not even native to South America- it's African. So eliminating it from the New World can't do that much damage given that the ecosystem got along fine before it arrived. This logic may have been applicable way back when the first few Aedes aegypti made their way to the New World, but at this point, so much has changed in our New World, and we don't really know all the ecological changes that Aedes aegypti may have already caused. Perhaps, they have become an integral part of our society.
- roywiggins 10y agoI'm aware of that possibility, but their main niche seems to be sucking human blood and passing diseases around. Other mosquitos feed on other animals and plants, but A. aegypti really loves to eat people.
- duaneb 10y ago> Perhaps, they have become an integral part of our society. Perhaps, but I don't believe anyone has demonstrated that mosquitoes have this crucial in impact to he health of the ecosystem. In fact, the aforementioned Nature article explicitly argues against that idea, though obviously it's only a sample size of 1.
- kapitza 10y agoSome of them, I assume, are good mosquitoes. But who's doing the biting? Somebody's doing the biting! We need to build a net. They have to go back!
- flatulent1 10y ago> So eliminating it from the New World can't do that much damage given that the ecosystem got along fine before it arrived. I wonder what kind of South American bug pollinates Cherimoya blooms? The Cherimoya fruit is exceptional, but producing it in California requires hand pollination since some bug that lives in the Andes isn't in California. Hopefully whatever man dumps into the environment won't create some new nasty... flesh-eating locusts perhaps?
- zitterbewegung 10y agoNature has a good article and eliminating misquotes has little ecological impact and obviously large positive impact for humans . http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100721/full/466432a.html http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100721/full/466432a.html
- waterphone 10y agoUnintended consequences still manage to arise most of the time when people think they can play god and mess with nature in that way. Until relatively recently, people didn't even know that hummingbirds relied heavily on eating small insects like mosquitos rather than just drinking nectar. Undoubtedly there are many things like that which we simply aren't aware of.
- CamperBob2 10y agoEverything in engineering is a compromise, and ecological engineering is no different. We still do it anyway. We get to do it because we're humans, and the other species aren't. It is not reasonable to demand assurances of complete safety, or freedom from all possible adverse consequences, before taking action in defense of our own species.
- rch 10y ago> We get to do it because we're humans, and the other species aren't. Beavers get to do a little ecological engineering now and again.
- CamperBob2 10y agoTrue, and I'll bet they don't feel especially guilty about it.
- rch 10y agoI bet coral is starting to wonder what it did wrong.
- will_brown 10y agoBeyond your question of ecological impact of killing all mosquitoes, as others mentioned they don't all need to be killed. Historically, South Florida engaged in annual mosquitoe controlling campaigns. Essentially aerial spraying during the Summer. These were stopped because of the budget cuts related to the collapse of the Florida housing market. Not only did the mosquitoes become intolerable, but before Zika we had a breakout of mosquitoe transmitted Dengue fever. Moreover, the historical mosquitoe controlling never killed all mosquitoes but the were effective in preventing breakouts like Dengue Fever and Zika.
- JosephHatfield 10y agoWhen I was growing up along the Indian River in Florida, they used to send trucks through the neighborhood on summer nights that sent out huge clouds of mosquito killing fog. <s>I'm sure that was perfectly safe.</s>
- will_brown 10y agoI go up there to Hutchinson Island every Summer, at night on the Beach the sand flys (no-see-umps) are absolutely brutal.
- nsxwolf 10y agoWhen the tourism industry screams loudly enough they will find the cash for the spraying.
- chiph 10y agoI doubt they'll bring back DDT spraying programs. But there's no question it was effective. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DDT https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DDT
- Kenji 10y agoYeah, we humans are so good at making animals extinct. I can't believe we haven't done that with human-biting mosquitoes (or other nasties) a long time ago. It is time to do that; nature will find a way without the buggers.
- kbenson 10y ago> Yeah, we humans are so good at making animals extinct. Well, largely by crowding them out of food or space. While species we compete with get the short end of the stick, those that we have parasitical or symbiotic relationships with have quite a different experience.
- Harelin 10y agoIs it possible that mosquitoes spread beneficial pathogens among humans, in addition to the deadly pathogens they are known for? The concept of overprotective parents preventing their children from building their immune system comes to mind.
- fnj 10y agoSince the definitions of pathogen is not just "microorganism", but "microorganism that can cause disease", the idea of "beneficial pathogen" appears to be a contradiction in terms. That said, hormesis is a conceivable factor.
- Harelin 10y agoYes. What if mosquitoes inoculate us (and/or other animals) against diseases during childhood? Absent mosquitoes, I wonder if we would become more vulnerable to those diseases entering our systems through other vectors.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoI did a bit of research a while back, and it seems like no mosquito fills a vital role in its local ecology. They pollinate flowers, but less effectively than other insects. They're prey for insectivores, but no known insectivore preys primarily on mosquitoes. Their prey doesn't usually die, so there's nothing whose numbers they're keeping down.
- advertising 10y agoThey did this in Brasil decades back. Mandatory home inspections where they had patrols go through every single house and eliminate water pools where mosquitos could breed, mostly all made by humans. I believe the eliminated mosquitos for a certain period of time but this technique didn't work in the states because Americans were adverse to government agencies coming into their homes and telling them what do to.
- advertising 10y agoHere - http://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/while-brazil-was-eradicating-zika-mosquitoes-america-made-them-into-weapons http://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/while-brazil-was-eradic...
- maxerickson 10y agoLots of places in the US have mosquito control boards that go around inspecting properties. For example, this page lists residential site inspections as one of the methods being used to combat Zika virus in Florida: http://www.miamidade.gov/solidwaste/mosquito-control.asp http://www.miamidade.gov/solidwaste/mosquito-control.asp Searching on "mosquito control board inspections" returns lots of similar results. I suppose people might not always follow recommendations.
- advertising 10y agoThey did this in Brasil decades back. Mandatory home inspections where they had patrols go through every single house and eliminate water pools where mosquitos could breed, mostly all made by humans. I believe the eliminated mosquitos for a certain period of time but this technique didn't work in the states because Americans were adverse to government agencies coming into their homes and telling them what do to.
- DelaneyM 10y ago> What are the probable/theoretical distuptions and consequences? This is actually a pretty well-researched question! (Wish fulfillment I assume.) A good summary of research is here: http://science.howstuffworks.com/science-vs-myth/what-if/what-if-mosquitoes-went-extinct.htm http://science.howstuffworks.com/science-vs-myth/what-if/wha... (includes links to studies) TL;DR: probably worth it for humanity