which is exactly the reason he should be allowed to see the full details of the cap table to see what makes those shares more valuable than his and estimate his

which is exactly the reason he should be allowed to see the full details of the cap table to see what makes those shares more valuable than his and estimate his stocks value based on that info plus other financial info. It is exactly why this law exists because otherwise it is impossible for someone to value their shares and when you own shares that include a right to first refusal clause it makes it nearly impossible to shop the shares around on the private market