4 ms·
Military plans such as these are rarely intended to be acted upon. They're plans from a strategic perspective. A question is posed: What if we executed a first
by Jtsummers 10y ago
Military plans such as these are rarely intended to be acted upon. They're plans from a strategic perspective. A question is posed: What if we executed a first strike? Related questions come up: When should we do it, what would be the retaliation, what would be the economic impact, etc. These get put together into a report, and it's set aside.
Military plans are not statements of intent on their own.
- usrusr 10y agoNot to mention the nice side effect of having a much better idea of how the other side might proceed if they wanted to do a first strike (which is a rather strong "if", but America back in the day surely felt different about that). But what gives the Unz interpretation a bit of weight is the element of "if you ever want to first strike, it's now or never" that was clearly present. This can easily turn a purely theoretical game-plan into a purely theoretical game-plan with a zealous PR department.
- pasbesoin 10y agoAlso, the value in exploring "What is our opponent thinking?" Although they won't know of all your resources and capabilities, they will have some idea of many. And it's valuable to know what they may worry about. As well, how well their concern does or doesn't match reality. In such planning, you need to explore the whole space of thought and possibilities -- from both sides -- and not just the more palatable ones you wish to follow.