10 ms·
U.S. Army fudged its accounts by trillions of dollars, auditor finds
- guimarin 10y agoI'm all about gov't waste, and oh my god numbers are hard, but pretty sure they fudged it by Billions not Trillions. In the article they mention that the total true-up of all the problems was ~65B. So this headline is off by a couple orders of magnitude.
- kevinmgranger 10y agoI'm not seeing that number anywhere in the article, but it does say: >the Army made $2.8 trillion in wrongful adjustments to accounting entries in one quarter alone in 2015, and $6.5 trillion for the year Do you have another source?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hueving 10y agoThat's misleading because it makes it sound like they were off by a total of 2.8 trillion, but that actually means they made that many adjustments. There is no way they were off that far because that's beyond their entire annual budget.
- maxerickson 10y agoIt would probably be better to focus on the number of adjustments that were made rather than the dollar tally (the number of adjustments will give some sense of the scope of the problem without counting the same dollars over and over again).
- lsiebert 10y agoUnless of course they had money from previous budgets.
- stonemetal 10y agoI believe he is referring to this part of the article: >The spokesman downplayed the significance of the improper changes, which he said net out to $62.4 billion. >At first glance adjustments totaling trillions may seem impossible. The amounts dwarf the Defense Department’s entire budget. Making changes to one account also require making changes to multiple levels of sub-accounts, however. That created a domino effect where, essentially, falsifications kept falling down the line. In many instances this daisy-chain was repeated multiple times for the same accounting item. Basically 62 billion was effected, they claim trillions because of "write amplification" across multiple accounts.
- jayess 10y agoSource document: http://www.dodig.mil/pubs/documents/DODIG-2016-113.pdf http://www.dodig.mil/pubs/documents/DODIG-2016-113.pdf
- hyperion2010 10y agoI think you are confusing the flow of money with the total budget. I think the numbers reported here are looking at individual transactions that can easily add up to more than a trillion dollars.
- guimarin 10y agoI'm not confused. The article states that they had 2.8T in adjustments on a ~500B budget. That is totally insane. That the aggregate averages of all those adjustments are 500% of each and every adjustment is inconceivable. Even the most incompetent organizations are not off by that kind of percentage over ALL of their adjustments.
- stock_toaster 10y agoFrom the article: > At first glance adjustments totaling trillions may seem impossible. The amounts dwarf the > Defense Department’s entire budget. Making changes to one account also require making > changes to multiple levels of sub-accounts, however. That created a domino effect where, > essentially, falsifications kept falling down the line. In many instances this daisy-chain > was repeated multiple times for the same accounting item.
- guimarin 10y agobingo, this is an asinine way to do bookkeeping. And reuters shouldn't report based on this kind of waterfall problem. The issue is we're off by ~65B which is over 10% of the budget. That's the scandal someone is misdirecting away from. I want to change the parent to, I get you want to clickbait but seriously??
- gizmo 10y agoI think reuters' description is accurate. If you do your accounting in such a way that all numbers are garbage but the errors mostly cancel each other out it's not a matter of being unable to account for 10% of the budget, it's a matter of not being able to trust any numbers at all. This is deep institutional rot.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Paul-ish 10y ago65B is still significant. 65B is still almost 1.8% of the total budget for 2015. If you say the government spent 620B on defense, that means 10% of that can't be accounted for. Imagine if you couldn't find 10% of your paycheck at the end of the year. It isn't a trivial amount.
- guimarin 10y agoYES. and that's the story that should be highlighted, not some asininely huge number from a shitty accounting implementation. That we are off by more than 10% of the Military budget and 1.8% of the total US budget is nuts. Unrelated: but after Clapper I don't know how anyone has any faith in the US Gov't. this is just another reinforcement.
- josho 10y agoI'm left with two thoughts. First, who is getting fired for this and what outsider will be brought in to fix this to keep it from happening again. Second, is a larger question. Why do US citizens tolerate spending a disproportionate amount of their financial resources on their military?
- DougWebb 10y agoThe answer to your second question, unfortunately, is a combination of "We're scared", "We're number one!" and "Who cares?"
- meddlepal 10y ago1. Nobody 2. Because it allows us to project force globally which is what actually allows us to be the one true global super power.
- mtgx 10y agoAssuming 2 is true, shouldn't Americans then be more concerned with spending those hundreds of billions of dollars a year more efficiently, so USA's power could be 2x, 4x (just by cutting the waste/corruption alone), or even 10x bigger (by using the money buy smarter/more effective technology than say...more tanks, or F-35's)?! People who keep supporting more military spending aren't patriots. Quite the opposite. Those that want their army to run well and effectively are the true patriots.
- lintiness 10y agosure, let's spend our tax dollars more efficiently. point me to the government bureau that magically manages its finances "efficiently".
- galdosdi 10y agoI can think of one. The SSA spends just a fraction of a percentage point of its disbursements on administrative costs. There's probably others. Like private industry, government is huge, contains many agencies at many levels, and some of them are well run and some of them are poorly run and some of them are somewhere in between.
- mindcrime 10y agoBoth presidential candidates have called for increasing defense spending amid current global tension. FFS, I despite this kind of lazy reporting. Hello, there are not two candidates for President!!! So the phrase "both presidential candidates" is meaningless. I suppose you mean Gary Johnson and Jill Stein right?
- chasing 10y agoWhat kind of lazy comment is this that doesn't include James Hedges of the Prohibition Party, Rod Silva of the Nutrition Party, and Vermin Supreme -- the voice of the people who was frankly robbed at the Libertarian Convention just simply he didn't get enough votes. Why must we always limit ourselves to the Big Four?
- mindcrime 10y agoYou're making an unsupported inference here. Neither I, nor anybody else in this discussion that I see, has made any (serious) suggestion that the article needed to mention anybody else. Not even Gary Johnson or Jill Stein, much less Hedges, etc. What the author should have done however, is write an accurate statement by simply saying "both major party candidates for President..." instead of "both candidates for President..."
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mmanfrin 10y agoThere are two candidates with actual chances of winning; so "both presidential candidates" is fine to say.
- mindcrime 10y agoThere are two candidates with actual chances of winning; so "both presidential candidates" is fine to say. There will be at least three candidates who are on the ballot in enough states to win. Beyond that, we should be very careful of making advance declarations about who and can't win. The media even more-so, exactly because they serve to influence who wins and loses.
- jayess 10y agoAnyone who has been in the military would be completely unsurprised by a total inability to track spending.
- ceedan 10y agoThe same is true for almost any government position, unfortunately.
- lsiebert 10y agoAre we storing this all in cash, or are there bank records is what I want to know.
- bogomipz 10y ago"The spokesman downplayed the significance of the improper changes, which he said net out to $62.4 billion. “Though there is a high number of adjustments, we believe the financial statement information is more accurate than implied in this report,” he said." Wow, the bubble that is the military-industrial complex. That's 62 Billion dollars that could have gone to education, infrastructure, or helping the poor. If you were this careless with a fraction of this dollar amount on your personal income taxes you would be thrown in prison.
- catalinbraescu 10y agoHow about not taxing the shit out of the taxpayers?
- O5vYtytb 10y ago> “Where is the money going? Nobody knows,” said Franklin Spinney An ex army ranger once told me that the 'missing' money in the military budget goes to operations like the ones he was part of, which of course he could not tell me about. Of course there is also waste and pork, but I think the majority of this money is for black ops.
- smithkl42 10y agoThough presumably not $6+ trillion, right?
- at-fates-hands 10y agoIf you think about the insane cutting edge technology the Special Forces teams get, 6 Trillion seems a bit. . . .low. Case in point are the Stealth helicopters they used in the Bin Laden raid. Up to that point, no one outside the military and probably very few inside the military knew they existed. A fact that would have been concealed had they not crashed one during the operation.
- sliverstorm 10y agoIt's corruption that really drives the desire to find out where the money is going. Waste & pork are acceptable on some levels, but most people have zero tolerance for corruption on the public dime, and are thus driven to find it. Now, how you can give the data to find corruption without revealing black ops, I don't know.
- BinaryIdiot 10y ago> An ex army ranger once told me that the 'missing' money in the military budget goes to operations like the ones he was part of, which of course he could not tell me about. Sounds like he fed you some bullshit. I see no reason why it wouldn't be placed under a generic category with zero information regarding it possibly even lumped into something else. This is how it worked with classified projects when I worked in DoD contracting; not sure why this would be any different.
- 10y ago
- jayess 10y agoThis appears to be the source document: http://www.dodig.mil/pubs/documents/DODIG-2016-113.pdf http://www.dodig.mil/pubs/documents/DODIG-2016-113.pdf
- jimrandomh 10y agoSome of this money is going to secret operations, but also a lot of it is getting embezzled. If even the inspector general can't get a truthful accounting, then there's no way the army is able to prevent that.
- randomnumber314 10y agoIn my experience, this will cause anger and outrage, someone high up will be sacrificed--but that's it. The military is an absolute money burning machine. In my seven years of experience the following were in-the-open examples: * End of year spending binges on equipment no one wanted or needed to max out budgets, to justify the next budget year's sum * Pre-inspection trashing of inventory to mitigate write ups for discrepancies between on-hand and on-book items. * I met a team of inspectors in Iraq who were tasked with finding some number of billions worth of equipment that was paid for, but no one was able to locate. * Getting rank often involves pushing through big expensive projects, no matter the need, in exchange for bullet points on personnel review files. * My favorite: an enormous dining facility was built on a base in Iraq, but it was too close to the exterior fence, which presented a situation where there would potentially be slow-moving line of hundreds of military, closely grouped together, within "throwing distance" of the perimeter fence. Thus, the contractors were required to complete the building, to make-good on the contract, to force the military to pay them in full, for a facility that was unusable due to above.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- analogmemory 10y ago> * End of year spending binges on equipment no one wanted or needed to max out budgets, to justify the next budget year's sum This seems pretty standard in any large corporation. The best times to ask for new "shit" is during the holiday season. Thanks corporate Santa! :/
- toddmorey 10y agoI will NEVER forget working as a student in the college bookstore during EOY spending. I watched department chairs throw anything and everything into shopping carts, as if they were gameshow contestants trying to beat the clock. "What is this Mathematica software? What does it do? I'll take 4 copies." The idea of course was insanity to me: if you didn't spend your department budget, you were in danger of having it reduced next year. So you were punished for leaving money on the table.
- _audakel 10y ago"DFAS also could not make accurate year-end Army financial statements because more than 16,000 financial data files had vanished from its computer system." I am impressed. I did an internship at a financial company and helped do end of month closing balance adjustments. We had a onsite and remote paper copy storage of each document, an onsite server room that hosted a copy, a off site tape copy and an offsite digital back up. Hard to think of what must have happened to get that level of mishap.
- noir_lord 10y agoDepends if it's a mishap or a 'mishap' I guess. I used to work for a massive retail company and our variance on the total at the end of a single day when cashing up was usually 1p, over 1 pound and people would start looking into it, over 10 pound it had to be reported to loss prevention. It's a different world I guess.
- niels_olson 10y agoScot Paltrow cover's this beat regularly http://www.reuters.com/journalists/scot-j-paltrow http://www.reuters.com/journalists/scot-j-paltrow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scot_J._Paltrow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scot_J._Paltrow All the services are at fault. Part of this no doubt has to do with the sheer amount of turnover in the military: people change jobs every two or three years, sometimes in one year. The civilians have more insight, but the active duty officers are virtually guaranteed to make errors in cost estimates for new programs and only shut down old programs after there are obvious overruns.
- ryanmarsh 10y agoWell considering me and my soldiers' pay were fucked up regularly requiring us to visit S1 this doesn't surprise me.
- red_blobs 10y agoIs this really a surprise to anyone? Government historically has no incentive to save money, because if they do, they will get less money the next time around. I worked for a nonprofit organization based on government funding for almost a decade and this is exactly how the industry (anything based on funding from the government) works. We were told to buy the most expensive of everything and if we had a surplus, we had to spend (and many times waste) the rest. This is why we need to have less government involved in our economy, not more.
- twunde 10y agoI can't imagine how the DoD could clean up it's books. There have been long standing complaints that the military uses non-standard accounting software. Combine that with a lack of historical knowledge as personnel rotate in and out within 3 years or so and frankly disincentives aligned against the effort at every level and you have a massive project on your hands to get the right data. I'd have to imagine it would be a 5-10 year project