3 ms·
This is a confusing metric. If I compare two cities at the top of the list I know well and have spent much time in, Vancouver and Calgary, to other cities I kno
by jandrewrogers 10y ago
This is a confusing metric. If I compare two cities at the top of the list I know well and have spent much time in, Vancouver and Calgary, to other cities I know well, I have a difficult time explaining to myself why those are among the most livable cities in the world. Vancouver is a lovely city, if you have money. Calgary appeals to my mountain West upbringing, but it has most of the downsides of mountain West cities in the US, which are not insignificant.
Those cities are not unlivable by any means but "most livable" seems like a stretch. Obviously their measures are quite different than what some people might assume.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoYeah, "livable" is inherently tied to some kind of value system. It's kind of a useless metric unless they explain in detail their values. "Safety" and "environment" mean totally different things to totally different people. This would be much more interesting if they took, say, three different value systems and did three rankings.
- vacri 10y ago> It's kind of a useless metric unless they explain in detail their values It's a pity that the Economist didn't put a link right there in the first paragraph about that!
- orange_county 10y agoYea they did but they also put it behind a link that requires registration. Besides, the metric value changes depending on who you are and what kind of income you can generate based on the job you can obtain and what you value the most. This is why I never like articles claim to know what's best for everyone.