6 ms·
How Lending Club’s Biggest Fanboy Uncovered Shady Loans
- paganel 10y agoInteresting article, just wanted to comment on this: > For instance, in June 2011, a user from the Phoenix area requested $25,000 for debt consolidation. The user was relatively risky, with a FICO score in the low 700s. Lending Club rated the loan “E2”—one of its riskier categories—offering it at an interest rate of about 18 percent. But investors were skeptical, and only $20,525 worth of the loan’s notes were sold. Later that month the same person, according to Sims, borrowed the difference, $4,475, at an interest rate of just 7.5 percent. (Sims guessed that Lending Club’s algorithms gave the second loan a higher rating because it was smaller and thus less risky.) To the outside, it looks like one reliable loan and one risky loan; in fact they were both risky. “We evaluate each borrower’s creditworthiness based on the most up-to-date data,” the company says in a statement. It adds that users can exclude “relisted” loans from their searches. The exact same thing happened (may be still happening, AFAIK, I've been out of that industry for ~7 years) in the mortgage business, and it was a legal and well-known practice. At least Lending Club was considering the higher loan as being more risky (i.e. assigning it a higher interest rate), but what I saw happening in the mortgage business was that let's say that you needed $100,000 to buy a house and you had almost nothing, a credit officer will help you get a "personal needs" credit worth $20,000 with an interest of 7-8% that would show the bank that you were now in the possession of at least 20% of the value of house, so that the bank was now able to lend you the rest of the money ($80,000) to actually buy said house, at 3-4%. Often times the two loans were taken from the same bank, so there was no foul-play from the client.
- athenot 10y agoWow. I seem to recall that I was made to sign a statement by my credit union to the effect that the money from my downpayment was free of all lien, i.e. was an asset and not a liability.
- pc86 10y agoWhen my wife and I bought our house ca 2011 we both had to sign a statement saying that our down payment was our money, was not a loan, and surprisingly was not a gift. They also requested bank records showing the balance. The bank official we were talking to said they had had problems with people getting a family member to "gift" them a large down payment for a house they couldn't afford in the past and you basically had to prove the down payment was your money beyond the fact that you had control of it at signing.
- athenot 10y agoGifts were possible (I received one) but the giver had to also sign a document explicitely stating that they did not require repayment and relinquished all rights to the funds.
- pc86 10y agoI think our bank's concern was that if you needed that gift (in order to lower the mortgage payment by having lower principal or getting rid of PMI or whatever) then you were probably buying too much house in the first place. If 20% of the value of the your home is enough to make it financially infeasible and someone loses their job or gets in a car accident you're in for some rough times.
- losteverything 10y agoNever heard of or thought of that. As an executor of several family members Estates and also friends to others it's very often parents give children money for down payments. Almost always, the assistance in getting the house is subtracted from the disbursement of assets (when they die ) I also don't see why someone can simply change their mind "oh yes, you do need to pay me back" after the documents are already been signed and the house bought.
- cowsandmilk 10y agoThe smaller loan is more risky. If it is "personal needs" like you describe, it isn't backed by any asset. In other common scenarios such as using second mortgage or a HELOC to get to 20%, it is second to the primary loan in getting paid off in case of foreclosure. That is, if the home sells for 85% of value in foreclosure, the primary mortgage holder will likely be made whole on both the debt and costs of foreclosure, but the second mortgage might get 10% recovery. And in the case of a "personal needs" loan, they probably get nothing.
- pc86 10y agoIn the event of wholesale bankruptcy, yes small unsecured loans are almost certainly getting $0. I think they mean in the event a borrower is overextended but still relatively solvent (e.g. they just continue spending too much). If I have a LendingClub loan with a $200/mo payment and an $850 balance and am having trouble making ends meet, it behooves me to pay that loan off by any means necessary, because it will free up $200/mo in cash flow relatively quickly. It's unlikely I am in the same position with my mortgage or car payment.
- pc86 10y ago700 seems an odd bar for "relatively risky," perhaps they mean in relation to the entire platform (minimum 660 to borrow)? I know these are personal unsecured loans but for example if you're car shopping 700 is generally the line above which you can get qualified for the best rate on any vehicle your income supports. I've had bad credit in the past and unless you have such a high income you can pay down debt without really trying, it takes effort to get into the 700's. I actually took out a LendingClub loan with a high 600's score in 2013 or so and I got the best rate they offered at the time (around 14% on a 36 month note that I ended up paying off in ~18). Granted that was about $7k not $20k but there does seem to be a small disconnect between the numbers in the FA and my experience both in life generally and with LendingClub specifically.
- douche 10y agoThat seems awfully high for an interest rate. My credit wasn't much better in 2014 when I took out a similar-sized personal loan, and I only had 6% interest on it.
- pc86 10y agoIt is, but remember these are all unsecured loans without income verification, and both LendingClub and the investors are taking a piece of the profit. Both LC and Prosper now offer 6% loans to 720+ FICOs with the (unverified, as the FA states) income to support it. The lowest may have been 10-12 back then but I remember being surprised because it was less than half my CC rate and I was expecting high teens. I was using it for CC consolidation so really anything below the ~28.99% I was paying was a pretty big win.
- paganel 10y ago> 700 seems an odd bar for "relatively risky," perhaps they mean in relation to the entire platform (minimum 660 to borrow)? Yeah, sorry for not mentioning it, but I'm from Europe, I should have probably used Euros as an example instead of $. On top of that I'm from Eastern Europe (yeah, we used to take out Euro-denominated loans even if it's not our local currency, even CHF ones, which backfired in a really bad way). Anyway, around 2007-2008 those were the approximate rates for personal credits, and for mortgages I think it was 2 or 3 percentage points above LIBOR (which I might me wrong, but was around 2-3%). That kind of explains why lots of European banks are in trouble (I think Italian banks' "bad-credits rate" is at around 30%). The story for how I found out how to parse LIBOR rates daily and about how astonished I was that such an important metric was hidden somewhere on a *.co.uk site in bad HTML format is for another time. Suffice is to say that when the whole LIBOR scandal broke up I was not surprised at all.
- zby 10y agoNot much substance in this one - the summary would be something like: - LendingClub inflates figures by encouraging employees to use the service - there was an affair with mis-dated loans - but this is not covered in any detail - LendingClub data does not include information about repeat borrowers (one example given was about someone who tried to take a 25K loan - but got financing for only 20K - then it borrowed the rest, apparently with better rates, because smaller loans are less risky) - this might be a big thing actually - but it needs more data - there are privacy issues for borrowers (obviously)
- dforrestwilson1 10y agoYeah I'm an LC loan investor and this doesn't move the needle for me. What other bank or lending institution publishes this amount of loan data? Does this imply that LC is more transparent or less than most lenders? Investors in the stock may be hurting, but my loans are still in the black, and have been for the past 4 years since I started.
- pc86 10y agoDoes the article's statement about investor demand outpacing borrower demand jive with your experience? I've been thinking about putting some money into LendingClub (was a borrower several years ago and had a good experience) but I've been hearing for a while that it's very difficult to get the good loans because they get snapped up quickly, often by large lending institutions. Often what is left are very risky and/or very far from being funded.
- dforrestwilson1 10y agoI don't have good insight into the potential for demand/supply imbalance or how loans are distributed. I would like to believe that LC gives all investors a fair chance at equivalent loans, but I only use the auto-trade mechanism and match the portfolio. What I HAVE noticed this month is that my cash is piling up. It looks like LC is currently not offering the best rate to potential borrowers? I'm OK with that personally.
- 10y ago
- seibelj 10y agoHow to pick good Lending Club loans: C or B only. 3 years only. Minimum income 70k. No defaults, late payments, public records, collections, etc. (not a single one! even from 5 years ago!). DTI no higher than 70. Do not lend for medical, business, or wedding. No monthly payment higher than $500. No one with less than 2 years at current job. If you want to do the machine learning analysis, go ahead, you'll come to the same result I did. This is optimized for minimal defaults while still getting a solid return (~10%). I keep LC as a small amount of total investment portfolio, but there is certainly money to be made.
- zwily 10y agoDo you mean DTI of 7%? 70 is pretty high...
- bryanbuckley 10y agoPast performance is not indicative of future results. Also, to increase your chances of making a profitable loan (same as insurance underwriting) you need to gather more information than what is commonly available and being acted upon.