3 ms·
I dislike the way that massive debates turn into selective replies, and think it would be good to try a debate of 2 sides, instead of a debate of 500 serial rep
by jodrellblank 17y ago
I dislike the way that massive debates turn into selective replies, and think it would be good to try a debate of 2 sides, instead of a debate of 500 serial replies.
When you visit the site, you see the current state, and you can look down the points and rebuttals on either side and contribute to those bits specifically and 'push' the center line one way or the other.
Tug-o-war style, not HN comment style.
Not sure how well it would work in reality - I'm guessing a bit tediously.
- ErrantX 17y agoThis was my thinking too... pick (or have users submit) some option A or option B news stories and then give then let people post debate comments/points for either choice. Upvotes should hopefully drag good comments to the top - then perhaps a "show of hands" to decide the issue Fighting trolls would be hard.
- prawn 17y agoWhat about some measure of negative karma for not responding to a point? You could either concede that your opponent had made a strong point and/or respond with a counterpoint. If you left a point unanswered, it'd show a hit against your profile and sit in your dashboard of unanswered points.