2 ms·
> Whatever effect they have, unless there's something in the constitution or our laws which prevents them from doing it, then they can infringe away... is there
by mindslight 10y ago
> Whatever effect they have, unless there's something in the constitution or our laws which prevents them from doing it, then they can infringe away... is there something that prevents a company from infringing on your right to free speech?
No, there is not. However, not being illegal does not erase something.
> how exactly is twitter refusing to broadcast your message infringing on your right to speak?
Twitter has deliberately set itself up as a platform upon which users speak with each other. Through success, it has become a de facto common. This specific "refusal to broadcast your message" is based solely upon what you are saying. Controlling what others say is, by definition, infringing on free speech.
A US citizen in NK has ended up in NK voluntarily. Therefore under a misguided [0] theory of contracts-above-all, they have voluntarily chosen not to exercise free speech and thus their right is not being infringed!
[0] As computer scientists, we're well aware that layered complexity inevitably creates contradictions. Any analysis of rights must therefore be in terms of overall qualitative behavior rather than focused on "primitives" that will be easily usurped.
- jjnoakes 10y ago> Controlling what others say is, by definition, infringing on free speech. But they aren't controlling what you say. They just aren't broadcasting it. You can say hate all you want (within the law). Set up your own web site. Buy a plane and fly a banner over the beach. Go set up in a public place and start talking out loud. Twitter isn't stopping you from speaking or sharing your ideas. Calling it "infringement" because a commercial entity refuses to broadcast your message is, in my opinion, incorrect.
- mindslight 10y ago> But they aren't controlling what you say. They just aren't broadcasting it. "I'm not hitting my brother, I'm just flailing my arms and walking forward." Their voluntarily-created situation is that they are broadcasting what you say. By setting up an ultimatum that if you say something they do not like they will no longer transmit what you say, they are forming a control. This obviously isn't absolute control [0], it is limited by how much you rely on Twitter. I personally am not reliant on Twitter, but many people are and that is what we are discussing. Your argument is deliberately eschewing this concept of reliance, essentially attempting to justify all emergent behavior as implicitly moral so long as the primitives have been followed. As I said, this is a dead end. Otherwise we would not even need a legal system because the laws of physics would suffice. > You can say hate all you want (within the law). Set up your own web site. Buy a plane and fly a banner over the beach. Go set up in a public place and start talking out loud. Other avenues of speech do not justify controls on a particular one. If this were true, the government controlling what you could say on the Internet wouldn't be an infringement, because you still had other outlets. In another comment, you allude to your ISP restricting what you can publish online as wrong. How exactly does this differ from Twitter, besides being a different OSI layer? [0] Although there is actually no such thing. Even government is limited to post-facto punishment, and only if they can catch you.
- jjnoakes 10y ago> Your argument is deliberately eschewing this concept of reliance And I believe I am doing that rightfully so. I don't think reliance is relevant. Anyone who relied on twitter did so knowing that twitter can revoke their platform at any time from any user without cause. It's in the TOS. > If this were true, the government controlling what you could say on the Internet wouldn't be an infringement, because you still had other outlets. This is absolutely correct. The only reason the government can not do this is the first amendment. But if that did not exist, then the government somehow stepping in and preventing you from speaking would be just as morally wrong (in my opinion) as twitter somehow stepping in and preventing you from speaking (which I would consider fairly morally wrong, but I don't think this is what twitter is doing). And in the same vein, twitter refusing to broadcast your speech is as morally wrong (in my opinion) as the government refusing to post it on one of their web sites, if they were publishing broadcasted messages of others (which I would not consider morally wrong, assuming the first amendment did not exist). I don't think prevention of free speech by a government should be conflated with refusal to broadcast speech by a commercial entity. If the public wants a forum to share any speech they want to share, they are free to set one up. > In another comment, you allude to your ISP restricting what you can publish online as wrong. How exactly does this differ from Twitter, besides being a different OSI layer? I didn't say I thought an ISP removing my connection is wrong, I said I thought twitter petitioning them to do so because twitter disagreed with my speech and wanted it removed from places twitter does not control is wrong.
- mindslight 10y agoI give up. You will be able to find a "logical" deduction to seemingly justify anything, because our memepool is full of contradictions and you are running the complexity generator forward. This is exactly what the government and corporations do (using the court system) to chip away our rights as they coalesce their centralized singular power. Obviously Twitter wants to be a petty dictator and disclaim any implied responsibility (eg their generally-unread TOS) - that doesn't mean you need to be their banner man. By your same reasoning, the government could claim ownership of the atmosphere and be justified in restricting literal speech. Fundamentally, we're currently building a society where the commons is privately controlled. Rejecting the analysis of freedom of speech for this society implies one does not actually value the concept.