3 ms·
Even with a circular current, there would be effects that don’t even out over the course of a long race. These add up to a few tenths of a second for the swimme
by kbenson 10y ago
Even with a circular current, there would be effects that don’t even out over the course of a long race. These add up to a few tenths of a second for the swimmers in the outer lanes of the 800 and the 1500. In a race that was decided by seconds, this would not have affected the final result ordering. But in a 50, a difference of a couple tenths of a second due to a push or a pull could be the difference between a medal and not.
I few tenths of a second over 800 or 1500 meters should be (a few tenths of a second) / (800/50) or (a few tenths of a second) / (1500/50) when scaling it to the much smaller 50m, should it not? A few hundredths of a second, or even a few thousandths of a second, given that there's an order of magnitude difference.
- IanCal 10y agoI think they were saying that many of the effects cancel out over multiple lengths, as you're slowed down one way and sped up the other. It's not a perfect cancellation but it does diminish the problem. However the 50m is just one way, so you get the entire effect with nothing cancelling it out at all. There's also then a much bigger difference between lane 1 and 8. If everyone did two lengths, then lanes 1 and 8 would have been penalised a bit (faster one way, slower the other) but they'd have done the same as each other. Lanes 4&5 would have been a bit better. Now picture just one length. Lane 1 never has to swim against the current, while lane 8 has to fight it all the way.
- kbenson 10y agoI agree with your reasoning about how it could affect a one way race, but if that was actually the intention of the referenced portion of the article, I think they went about it in a very confusing manner at best.