7 ms·
Why Do Some Sports Vanish and Some Sports Survive?
- mod 10y agoI don't think the article answers the question it presents. The only answer it seems to provide is "When cultures disappear, their sports disappear with them." I think the answer to the question in the title would also answer a lot of similar questions: "Why do some car makers vanish and some survive?" "Why do some board games vanish and some survive?" "Why do some X vanish and some survive?"
- caminante 10y ago> I don't think the article answers the question it presents. You sure? I didn't need to read further than this quote to answer "Why do sports die?": "In areas adjacent to their temples, young men engaged in a ball game, known as ōllamaliztli, that concluded with the bloody sacrifice of one of the players upon the temple’s altar. Whether the sacrificed player was a winner or a loser we shall never know." I wouldn't try out for that sport ;-).
- red-indian 10y agoThese are my cousins. I disagree with this characterization of our ball game. It's a racist interpretation by ignorant white anthropologists who simply publish sensationalist nonsense with no understanding, nor desire for understanding.
- jitix 10y agocan you please elaborate? was the statement that people were sacrificed incorrect?
- x3n0ph3n3 10y agoHe's trolling. Edit: After reading their comment history, maybe not..
- compiler-guy 10y agoHere is the author's CV: https://www.amherst.edu/people/facstaff/aguttmann https://www.amherst.edu/people/facstaff/aguttmann It's pretty impressive. It seems unlikely to me that he is ignorant and has no desire for understanding. It's possible he is wrong--lots of people are about lots of topics. This is his specialty, but I (and likely no one else around) am in no position to evaluate his claims. So rather than calling him names and insulting him, tell us why he is wrong, or reference additional source material, or something. A simple web-link will do. I mean this in all sincerity. Name calling doesn't stop ignorance, education does.
- red-indian 10y agoI am unclear what about his background as a professor at a university proudly named after the hard core genocidist Lord Jeffery Amherst makes you believe he is a qualified informant in these specific issues? Can you explain? Thank you.
- EnFinlay 10y agoI don't see how the name of the university is a knockout blow to his credibility. What is your source of credibility, other than a vaguely racist username and declaration of kinship?
- red-indian 10y agoHuh?
- prawn 10y agoYou might want to retract "vaguely racist username" and read this very interesting post by @red-indian about names for the indigenous populations of North America. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10829124 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10829124
- EnFinlay 10y agoNow this opens up a whole other thing. The comment you linked mentions that it is considered rude in Canada (which is where I'm from). But it also explains why it is used. I apologize for any accusations explicit or implicit in saying "vaguely racist username".
- x3n0ph3n3 10y agoMaybe you'd like to explain how one might understand human sacrifice in the context you'd prefer?
- aaron695 10y agoYes it's BS, good point. But you seem to have the same problem. It's not your ball game unless you're a time traveler who invented the primitive game X years ago from a society that no doubt killed gays and treated women like shit as all societies did back then and some still do.
- ced 10y agoNot to comment on this particular debate, but I was curious about how homosexuals were treated in native populations, and it's quite interesting. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-Spirit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-Spirit http://www.firstpeople.us/articles/the-two-spirit-people-of-indigenous-north-americans.html http://www.firstpeople.us/articles/the-two-spirit-people-of-...
- billskills 10y agoTwo-spirit !== homosexual Also, Maya !== North American First Nations
- ythl 10y agoMoney. If the organization that governs your sport doesn't lobby the right people, your sport will stop getting coverage. Without coverage you generate no money. Read: wrestling and the olympics.
- et-al 10y agoI agree that money plays a part, but in terms of wrestling, it'll still do fine without the Olympics because of MMA. And as MMA becomes more mainstream, it will be more influential than a sporting event that's broadcasted once every four years. Also, high school wrestling enrollment has been holding steady. http://www.nwcaonline.com/nwcawebsite/savingwrestlinghome/facts.aspx http://www.nwcaonline.com/nwcawebsite/savingwrestlinghome/fa... (click on the male participation pdf)
- compiler-guy 10y agoLobby all you want, but if people don't like to watch the game or participate in it, lobbying won't help it stay alive. In that sense, money is just a proxy for interest.
- jessaustin 10y agoI think wrestling is back on? But the broadcasts definitely should be improved. First they should hire someone like Joe Rogan for over-the-top commentary. If the problem is too many competitors, then start merging weight classes. There are definitely potential fans around for entertaining combat sports.
- at-fates-hands 10y ago>> If the organization that governs your sport doesn't lobby the right people, your sport will stop getting coverage. Without coverage you generate no money. Likewise if both of these things happen (getting money and coverage) there is still a huge chance nobody watches and you still lose Read: - US Soccer (NASL and the MLS) - The NHL - The X-Games
- ColinCochrane 10y agoMLS has been doing rather well. Attendance has been increasing steadily for the past decade[1]. The NHL, while certainly not as popular as the NFL or MLB, is pretty consistent as far as attendance numbers go, comparable to the NBA [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Major_League_Soccer_attendance#Season_averages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Major_League_Soccer_attendance... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Major_League_Soccer_attendance#MLS_attendance_vs._other_North_American_professional_leagues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Major_League_Soccer_attendance...
- cobbzilla 10y agoWhile we're wondering why some sports fare better than others, anyone want to lay odds on the long-term survival chances of the wild and wacky game of Buzkashi? It's the sport where your team, on horseback, tries to get the goat carcass into your opponent's goal. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buzkashi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buzkashi
- andygates 10y agoGeographic spread seems to help with sports, so is this still a regional specialty, or are there buzkashi sides in the Afghan diaspora? Most importantly, have the blue blazers homologated a Standard Buzkashi Goat? /s
- wppick 10y agoWhat I find interesting is that the person who would design the game dynamics for a new sport and the game dynamics for a new video game, like call of duty, essentially have the same job description. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Game_design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Game_design What's even more interesting is how deep game design actually goes in human culture/history. Anything competitive between humans could potentially be modeled as a game. You could even think about war as a game (there are rules, teams). I could imagine ancient humans saw hunting as a game. Play is also super important for the proper development of children. As for why some sports/games survive while others fail, I'd argue that it's the same reason anything designed lasts the test of time, gets replaced, or becomes obsolete
- technotony 10y agoIf you are interested in taking this idea further, all life is game, I'd recommend the philosophy book 'finite and infinite games'. Can be applied to all kinds of aspects of human life, eg a startup is a game played by founders who win with a successful exit. With this philosophy text, Carse demonstrates a way of looking at actions in life as being a part of at least two types of what he describes as "games", finite and infinite. Both games are played within rules, as agreed upon by the participants; however, the meaning of the rules is different for the two types of games. The book stresses a non-serious (or "playful") view of life on the part of "players", referring to their choices as "moves", and societal constructs and mores as "rules" and "boundaries". In short, a finite game is played with the purpose of winning (thus ending the game), while an infinite game is played with the purpose of continuing the play.
- agumonkey 10y agoWhen thinking about games I have a feeling that it channels our survival / killing instincts into symbolic versions to gather the benefits (new strategies, pleasure, bonding, physical improvements).
- astazangasta 10y agoI don't think all life is a game in this way; with a game we hold ourselves to the rules for their own sake - the pleasure we get from play is that of acting within the sandbox we've defined. It is a sketch of life, a model, a way to explore an idea. In the context of a game we might be adversaries, but I am intimately aware of the boundary, and that we are at play - our adversarial relationship is not "real". We often say, "It's just a game", and the just is crucial to the difference. This is different from social mores, which are boundaries we respect because transgression has consequences we care about. There are real ends; it's NOT just a game. There is no space or context beyond what happens in life, as there is in a game (taking place within the shell of the true life). The purpose of play, and playing games, is to prepare us for the actual contests with outcomes that we are invested in. Of course we might USE play, and games, as tools in the course of achieving real ends (like the Olympics as a goal for furthering peace), but this is different from those ends (peace) being a game in themselves.
- namaemuta 10y agoA bit of off-topic but I've always wondered if e-sports could be perdurable as well since the interest of the developers goes towards making more money than making it better (improving its rules, adjusting times, etc.).