6 ms·
To Seattle Millennials, the Future Looks Scary
- pinewurst 10y agoI totally respect that the subjects of this article are trying to retrain themselves for well-paying careers. What's weird to me though is how many of them, even after observing family economic difficulties, studied things that could never result in a non-poverty life and ran up huge financial loan burdens. "Seattle, where she came after college in Utah to study musical theater" "She counts the months until the tech job she hopes to get after Ada can help pay off the $22,000 student debt she has left." "...studied philosophy and the history of science at St. John’s College in Annapolis, Md., has had jobs as a barista, a taxi dispatcher and a deli worker. She has $72,000 of student debt and has never been paid an annual wage, she said, of more than $17,000." I'm a history and philosophy of science and technology person myself, but it's never paid or pretended to.
- mikestew 10y agoWhat's weird to me though is how many of them, even after observing family economic difficulties, studied things that could never result in a non-poverty life and ran up huge financial loan burdens. That's what I was thinking after reading the opening paragraphs: "...and you didn't learn a damned thing from it, did you?"
- shepardrtc 10y agoMillenial pop culture promoted romantic lives of being artsy and unique, following your dreams, and trying to save the world. They were told that money wasn't everything and they should try to live more meaningful lives. Not terrible notions in the slightest, but not focusing on a well-paying career has consequences, and one of them can be a life of poverty. A few years of barely being able to pay the bills and having a lower quality of life can change motivations.
- pnathan 10y ago> Millenial pop culture promoted romantic lives of being artsy and unique, following your dreams, and trying to save the world. High school guidance counselors, the music and TV shows produced by the adults in the room, and many of our parents, thank you very much. People learn what they've been taught, and a core message to 90s children was "follow your dreams and it'll all work out". It was considered very crass to run the numbers.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Millenial pop culture promoted romantic lives of being artsy and unique, following your dreams, and trying to save the world. So did Boomer pop culture, in spades (Its not like the "Hippie" identity was created by Millenials.) Gen X, not so much, though.
- mikestew 10y ago"Seattle, where she came after college in Utah to study musical theater" Newsflash, Millenials: there has never been a time to my knowledge when you tell someone you're working on a degree in "musical theater" and their response would not be, "oh, studying to be a waiter, eh?" "Tech, they say, means military drones, loss of privacy and cyberbullying." Don't worry, you won't be working at any of the companies involved after your javascript bootcamp. Chin up, tech also means accounting systems at insurance companies. It won't be exciting work, but it'll pay better than musical theater. (Tech also means that phone you can't quit staring at, so if you'd like help off that high horse...)
- intopieces 10y agoI'm completely baffled by this comment. I went back and re-read the article to try to pick up on the sentiment you're criticizing, and I just can't find it. The derision w/r/t the woman's educational choice is so trite I'm wondering if it might be satire. Not everyone's goal in life to maximize money earned. Some people value a certain passion over riches, and many other believe that those with a lesser-paid passion deserve to live decent lives, not burdened with excessive debt. As for the 'tech' comment... it resonated well enough with me, and seemed genuine. I didn't detect any 'high horse' as you call it. It seems like you went into this article looking for something to criticize instead of attempting to empathize with the situation the individuals face.
- monkeywork 10y ago>Not everyone's goal in life to maximize money earned. Some people value a certain passion over riches, and many other believe that those with a lesser-paid passion deserve to live decent lives, not burdened with excessive debt. If you can't make a living that doesn't burden you with excessive debt then your passion isn't a career it's a hobby and you should treat it as such.
- intopieces 10y agohttp://www.theonion.com/blogpost/find-the-thing-youre-most-passionate-about-then-do-31742 http://www.theonion.com/blogpost/find-the-thing-youre-most-p...
- maverick_iceman 10y agoWhat exactly is the point of this article? Everyone featured in this article are living a vastly more fortunate life compared to the majority of the people alive today.
- earthtolazlo 10y agoQuite a lot of condescension here towards people trying to make a better life for themselves. Were you all really that smart at 18?
- spc476 10y agoAt 18, senior in high school I knew I wanted to go into film making or cartooning. But I realized (even at 18) that success in either career involved not only talent and skill, but just as much luck as well. I liked computers and understood quite a bit of programming (having grown up during the Golden Age of Home Computers, the 80s) and decided to get a degree in computer science as a fall back. So yeah, some of us were that smart at 18.
- cup 10y agoCan you tell us about your family, your parents involvement in your education and tertiary study decisions, rough socioeconomic condition etc. Just curious.
- spc476 10y agoUS citizen, grew up in a small town in North Carolina until 10, then moved to South Florida. I lived in a single parent household (with Mom) and the only involvement in my education was making sure I didn't miss the bus. She never even asked about homework (which was good, since I never bothered doing it). For rough socioeconomic condition I would say upper lower class (section 8 housing in North Carolina) to lower middle class (by the time I graduated high school). If I wanted to learn something, I was pretty much on my own. I found school to be largely a waste of time but I had little say in attending elementary, middle and high school. I still felt the same way by the time I was graduating college, but I wasn't quite ready to enter the Real World and college was a good excuse to avoid it. I received a Pell Grant for the first semester of college, but the paper work was insane so I ended up working my way through college. In this, I was fortunate that cheap (as in "too easy to get") student loans had yet to flood the market with money so tuition wasn't insane. That, and I attended a Florida State college as a resident (cheaper than going out of state) and it was only a few miles from home so I saved money there.
- nv-vn 10y agoI feel like this article tries to touch on way too many issues at once to make any meaningful dialogue.
- cylinder 10y ago"my income, one of the highest in the world, is not guaranteed for life!" This Anxious in America series is questionable. The last one about the vape lounge was widely derided even by the Times' usually sympathetic commenters. That said, they may be reporting on Millennials anxiety but not endorsing it as justified. Just informing us this is how they're thinking.
- taurath 10y agoWe've seen our parents put half their house's furniture on a credit card and lose their 20+yr jobs 3 years before retirement from a downsize. Tech jobs went through a huge crash once already, and with tech now so firmly entrenched into the economy a general economical recession precipitates a tech collapse (where's the ad money coming from if nobody has a job). If you were born in '85, you've come of age during the first tech collapse, and then 9/11, and then the 2007 great recession. Its burned into me to expect the economy to take a big hit every 6-8 years. So, maybe, even if you're making 100k a year, you probably are thinking that buying that 2/1 lowest on the market starter home for $500k is a recipe for disaster. But if you'd gotten in 15 years ago, you'd see 300% returns like your parents have on that house.
- jackcosgrove 10y ago> Its burned into me to expect the economy to take a big hit every 6-8 years. Good, because that's how it usually is. The 80s and 90s were remarkable for their economic growth and lack of recessions. The business cycle is about 6-8 years. Our parents had to get mortgages when interest rates were 17%. Our grandparents grew up during the great depression, and worked when marginal tax rates were north of 50%. Every generation has something to contend with.
- 10y ago
- nickthemagicman 10y agoWhy did they mention her burlesque dancing? It adds literally nothing to the discussion.
- ianai 10y agoI think skepticism is good. people need to question the systems in place. The US economy is not efficient and it does not provide for everyone. It actively destroys peoples' lives for the benefits of others and holds others down. further, rosy colored glasses lead people astray. Yes, be careful. (It's also still better than the other governments people have tried, but that really feels like winning a lost contest)