5 ms·
I'm still confused by the CDS bit. Is there a good eli5 article on it? I've already checked the eli5 subreddit and couldn't find anything specifically on the me
by komali2 10y ago
I'm still confused by the CDS bit. Is there a good eli5 article on it? I've already checked the eli5 subreddit and couldn't find anything specifically on the mechanism that allowed shorting.
- mcnees287 10y agoIt's just insurance. One side pays the other side if a certain outcome occurs. In exchange for protection from the outcome, the side seeking protection pays a fee.
- roywiggins 10y agoIt's more like buying insurance on someone else's house, when you know they are a meth lab and the insurer doesn't.
- sosborn 10y agoIn that case the insurer should do their due diligence before taking the bet.
- maxerickson 10y agoA hand wavy analogy is that a CDS is bankruptcy insurance. So the guy in the movie got the bank to write him an insurance policy on the mortgages (really mortgage derivatives) that other people held. When those mortgages failed, the policy paid out.
- maxerickson 10y agoI forgot the eli5 part. Let's say you have a little sister. It's been a little while since she screamed about her stuffed frog, but you think she is going to do it again soon. You come to me and say that I can have one of the cookies out of your snack every day if I agree to give you a whole bag of cookies next time your sister screams about the frog.
- chollida1 10y agoSure. The short answer is..... You(party A) and party B have a contract. You want to eliminate the risk that Party B goes bankrupt and can no longer pay you. You go to party C who will take small payments from you each month/quarter and in return they will pay you if party B goes bankrupt. Now the important things to note are: 1) The amount you pay party C is based on how you and party C analyze the bankruptcy risk of party B. 2) The amount that party C pays you when the CDS is triggered doesn't necessarily have to have any relation to your original contract with party B. ie party B might be making a one time payment of $1 million to you but nothing stops you from taking out $10 million in CDS protection on party B. 3) The trigger for a CDS may not necessarily be the failure of party B to pay, ikt might be related to their credit rating, ownership changes, or really any term you can negotiate. 4) you can write a CDS when you aren't even involved in the original party A to party B transaction. This is what happened in teh big short where Michael Burry had no involvement in the Mortgage back securities, but had several banks writhe him a CDS that payed out if the original mortgage backed security had a certain percentage of its mortgages fail. This is where things really went off the rails as companies like AIG wrote the CDS protection for a whole lot more MBS(Mortgage backed securities) than they could possibly ever cover, because their models predicted that there really wasn't any way they could fail in the manner they did. Suddenly a single MBS could have 100x its value in CDS default protection written on it. This leverage is how the 2008 bailout got so big.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoThe 100x is more because companies weren't really able to sell these contracts. Instead, they'd make another one with the opposite position to mitigate their risk. In case of default, there'd be a lot of offsetting payments.
- mcnees287 10y agoI think the comment is referring to the fact that one can write CDS on top of an underlying instrument. So, if I have $100 million in MBS, other parties, or even myself, can write CDS contracts that reference my $100 million MBS. What I have just done is to create more exposure than the underlying MBS. The MBS is still only $100 million, but the total outstanding contracts on the pool (MBS + CDS) is now much larger. What you are talking about is related to offsetting contracts, which is different. AIG was left holding the bag for most of these. They are one of the few who did not offset like you are saying.
- cowardlydragon 10y agoAs I understood it in the Big Short: Christian Bale's character's hedge fund wanted to make a big bet that mortgage backed securities would fail. So he shopped the banks for those that would take that bet. The ones that agreed to take the bet, he paid them a negotiated monthly amount (basically rent) to keep the bet in effect. If he stopped paying rent, the bet was off. The banks thought it would never happen and it was free money coming in. Since they thought the risk was 0% it was free money coming in. ... basically, the banks thought he was crazy, but would take his money to keep the bet going. In the movie, Bale's fund gradually loses money paying "rent" on this bet / option / contract. Things get dicey when conditions that should result in the bet paying off get covered up by the banks and government, and the investors in his fund get pissed they aren't getting any return on their money as promised.
- infinite8s 10y agoIt wasn't a bet - it was insurance, and his payment was the premium to underwrite that insurance. Of course the banks who wrote him the CDS failed to price the risk appropriately... It's like you are arguing that life insurance is a bet.
- iofj 10y agoIsn't that the same as is happening today with bonds ? The government is pushing bond prices down. So companies are using short-term loans to pay all their costs, while paying everything out to investors (clouding the issue is that a lot of this is happening through buybacks). What happens when interest rates go up, even a little ? It seems to me obvious consequences would be: 1) monthly payments go up. Either directly (variable interest) or when you refinance (companies have running debt. Almost always taking out new loan when old one comes due). In that case, interest rates go up slower than the benchmark rate, but they still go up. 2) creditworthiness of all debtors goes down (same as with individuals: you are "approved" for a monthly payment, e.g. 100 dollars/month. At 0% interest that covers 12000 dollars for a 10-year loan. At 1% that covers 11400, or about 5% less. Next time you ask for a loan you're not going to be able to loan 12000, so you can't just roll over the debt. So your ability to get new loans is going to be worse) Also, can someone explain to me why this doesn't result in moral hazard for management of large companies ? If you can loan at, say, 0.25% why wouldn't you just loan the next 60 year's profits now (investment time horizon "until the investors are expected to be dead"), pay it out to investors, and leave, content that you have done far better than you could have done by managing the firm well ?