4 ms·
I work in adtech. We all use adblockers, and the rise in their use is a good thing. Digital ads (especially video) are out of control and blocking is necessary
by manigandham 10y ago
I work in adtech. We all use adblockers, and the rise in their use is a good thing. Digital ads (especially video) are out of control and blocking is necessary to combat the terrible user experience and security risks.
However, ads also sustain all the services and content we consume for free and there are clearly common sense standards we can agree to: fast, non-intrusive, secure, static, etc. Any ad vendor that meets these guidelines should be let through (after a transparent vetting process and routine checkups).
Blocking everything just because it's an ad takes away any moral high ground from adblockers and doesn't do anything but hurt the entire ecosystem. A more nuanced approach would let good vendors through which would in turn start to encourage those behaviors by publishers and advertisers, creating progress all through the industry while letting companies stay in business.
It's not advertising we hate, it's the ad experience. Improving that experience is the ultimate goal, not engaging in endless war.
- mercutio2 10y agoI don't think we can agree to this. Ads do not sustain the free services I use; I object to advertising, full stop. You are welcome to think your free services are essential, I will disagree with you in most of the cases that are ad supported.
- hamax 10y ago> Ads do not sustain the free services I use; So you don't need an ad blocker then?
- manigandham 10y agoWhat free services are you using that aren't ad supported? You don't use Facebook or visit any major site (without a subscription)? And value isn't determined by whether you think it's essential or not but your actions in using it. If you're consuming content/services, then you're getting value.
- mercutio2 10y agoI loathe facebook with a flaming passion. That it has captured identity on the internet, and chained it to advertising, is a disgrace. I feel similarly about Google, fortunately there are alternative search engines.
- icebraining 10y agoWhich alternative search engine do you use that doesn't have ads and/or pull results from Google?
- dingaling 10y ago> What free services are you using that aren't ad supported? Personally I use Flightradar24, Weather Underground, Shipfinder and some other lesser-known networks for free without ads because I feed data to them. They even give me ad-free phone apps.
- agd 10y agoFor me it is the advertising I hate. I really don't want/need adverts in my life. If I want to find about new products or see reviews, I can search them out or read about them in publications I like or ask my friends.
- manigandham 10y agoI really doubt it, it's easy to say that and not notice just how much advertising there is and how you're influenced. If it's about wanting a choice, then payment options are slowly starting to become easier and more available, although they're not as good as they should be yet.
- agd 10y agoI understand how much I'm influenced which is why I dislike adverts so much.
- shostack 10y agoThis sentiment will lead to further eradication of the line between ads and editorial. Your articles will soon mostly be ads, ala the Buzzfeed model.
- pdkl95 10y agoBusinesses are free to lower the value of their content, as long as they meet FTC requirements about disclosure. I doubt that this is a profitable long term strategy, but they can drive away their readers if they want to. Adapting to the changing market with a new business model might be a better idea.
- shostack 10y agoUnfortunately, the FTC requirements don't extend to other countries, so unless you're using a geo-filter for the publishers you follow, that might not be something to rely on. Further, many other sites fly under the radar and frankly don't care about the FTC. You might ignore these, but many won't.
- RodericDay 10y ago> It's not advertising we hate, it's the ad experience. Improving that experience is the ultimate goal, not engaging in endless war. I object to advertising in principle. It causes people to become more consumerist. It exists to generate a desire to purchase stuff, usually by promoting feelings that one is missing out otherwise. It messes with buyer's rationale, the greatest aspect of markets, so that you cannot be sure that a product winning in the marketplace is doing so out of quality or out of better advertising. The possibility to make up for deficiencies in quality with proper advertisement encourages a company to spend money into selling product instead of improving product. And if one person is impervious to advertising and getting some content "for free", that still means that some other poor sap who is less educated, more vulnerable to advertising, is buying enough extra to make up for the content you got for free. An exploitative arrangement to be sure. I can be persuaded that it is difficult/impossible to regulate because of how intertwined it is with free speech, but as far as really-existing-ads go, I despise advertising.
- manigandham 10y agoThis is a common sentiment but advertising (and the greater superset of marketing) is critical to the success of pretty much every business on the planet today. It's important to look at it from every angle. Also this assumes that individuals have very little agency and are easily influenced by advertising. They can be, but it's not actually that easy.