8 ms·
No would be my quick reaction, it makes no sense and if it was then many other things that obviously aren't would be considered trespass too. You probably have
by dspillett 10y ago
No would be my quick reaction, it makes no sense and if it was then many other things that obviously aren't would be considered trespass too.
You probably have a legitimate claim to call it vandalism though. Easily repaired vandalism (just turn the projector off) but deliberate defacement all the same.
- pc86 10y agoNo you wouldn't. > action involving deliberate destruction of or damage to public or private property. It is neither damage nor destruction unless you use a nearly incomprehensible definition of either word. You might be able to call it disturbing the peace but that's criminal and not civil so removes some ability to seek redress from the building owner.
- phire 10y agoVandalism includes defacement too, even if the defacement is fully reversible (such as spray-painting cleanable surfaces). According to Wikipedia, throwing shoes over powerlines already counts as vandalism (though I wouldn't mind a citation on that). If throwing shoes over powerlines (which anyone can agree is fully reversible) then you should be able to argue that projecting light is vandalism too. Actually, projecting light is worse, is't not actually possible for the target can clean up the defacement, short of forcing you to turn the projector off.
- pc86 10y agoSpray paint is destructive, especially if the surface underneath is painted and removal of spray paint removes that paint as well. I have no idea if shoes over power lines is actually vandalism or not, I'm willing it is in some areas (Los Angeles? NYC?) and not in others (Duluth? Fargo?).
- lorenzhs 10y agoIf I smear insults on your shopfront window with a whiteboard marker, is that not vandalism? It leaves no trace and takes only a minute to remove, no special equipment required.
- phire 10y agoI came here to say the same thing, trespass law appears to be the wrong angle and vandalism would be a better starting point. Vandalism law shouldn't even care if the cost to repair the damage is zero. With regular vandalism offering to clean and repair the damage might convince the victim to not press changes, but it's not a get out of jail free card, they can still press charges. Also, I assume damage to reputation before the vandalism was 'repaired' can be taken into account under current law.
- dbingham 10y agoBut if we take into account damage to reputation aren't we getting dangerously close to infringing on free speech / freedom of the press? If the projected accusations are true, then the damage to reputation is really coming from the person's own actions being widely communicated. Right to control property is one thing, but we have no right to control what is widely known about our actions.
- themartorana 10y agoBut we do have the right to control the medium. You may print facts in your paper, but that gives you no right to burn them into my lawn, or soap them onto my windows, and by extension, use my private property in any way to broadcast them.
- pascalmemories 10y agoNo, vandalism requires actual physical damage of some sort. The article is essentially the legal reasoning from the Nevada Court of Appeal - some fairly experienced legal minds examining the situation (in this case, via an appeal). They're fairly clear in how they examine the situation and that no accepted definition of trespass applies and suggest some recourse to 'victims' who could, rather than incur huge legal fees, simply set their own competing projector to overcome the undesired images. An example of appeal judges being fairly pragmatic and laying a foundation for lawyers handling future cases to suggest better resolutions than expensive litigation - if only they'd read appeal court decisions /and remember them/. However, they do also suggest there is a case to consider the situation a nuisance (s.4) and take action that way. Given they make no mention of vandalism as an avenue, it seems quite evident the experienced legal experts suggest the situation is one of nuisance and should be handled as that if resorting to law. Why should anyone on HN argue with a qualified legal opinion by suggesting alternative legal strategies?
- themartorana 10y agoBecause they disagree with that legal opinion? I argue against the Citizens United decision constantly and that decision came down from arguably the most knowledgeable and important legal minds of today.
- bmelton 10y agoWhat specifically did you find problematic in the Citizens United decision?
- adrusi 10y agoVandalism requires physical damage? So if I draw a vulgar cartoon on the side of a church in chalk its not vandalism?
- GavinMcG 10y agoYou're using the word in a different sense than the person you're responding to. They're talking about the standard for charging someone for a criminal act.
- scottishfiction 10y agoThe full opinion in the article goes on to explain that it would be more appropriate to bring the case under nuisance laws, rather than trespass, or indeed vandalism.
- PeterisP 10y agoThe OP lists a specific legal reasoning arguing that it could/should be forbidden, but under nuisanse laws instead of trespass laws - however, they explicitly made a claim only in respect of the trespass laws.
- adrusi 10y agoThe specific precedent it cites is when actual matter entered somebody else's property, like excessive smoke. Light isn't matter. Projecting something onto someones property isn't all that different from shouting next to it. We have specific laws for when loud sound leaks into other peoples property, so we should probably have specific laws for light.
- PeterisP 10y agoI got the impression that at least they (Nevada) don't have specific laws for loud soud entering property; but loud sound, smells, etc entering property would all be treated similarly as a general nuisance, so this light projection would already be covered by that - if only the complaint asked for redress about that instead of trespass.