6 ms·
Which does at least HINT that it might be what it claims to be. That's a pretty impressive 0-day which they just gave away as a freebie, who knows what they did
by Someone1234 10y ago
Which does at least HINT that it might be what it claims to be. That's a pretty impressive 0-day which they just gave away as a freebie, who knows what they didn't give away.
I will say we'll never get real confirmation if this was actually stolen from the NSA, but if the other bundle contains a bunch of nice original vulnerabilities people will presume it was.
- salem 10y agoMakes you wonder if they could have made more money by pretending to find them and reporting them to the respective bug bounty programs.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wcummings 10y agoBug bounties almost never pay market value for exploits. Only reason to participate in them is charity.
- kbenson 10y agoAnd legality. I'm not sure why people seem to entirely discount that portion. There's more reward by selling on the black market, but there's also more risk associated with that.
- MichaelGG 10y agoYeah. Homeowners don't pay market value for me not robbing them, either. After all, think how much that jewellery is worth. And the damage of ID cards and passports. A laptop alone could get me $250, but no one wants to give me even $10 for telling them their door is unlocked.
- peterbotond 10y agoMost people only care about tangibles. When i politely advised about security holes, i was told that "we don't need people like you' or just called the police. I understand.
- rdtsc 10y agoWhat's illegal about selling them? Is there an anti-security-consulting-market legislation? In general what are some risks invovled (I am just not very familiar and wondering in general). Is it a tax issue, the chance IRS could come after you for undeclared income?
- wcummings 10y agoNothing, there are businesses doing it in the US paying taxes on their income.
- kbenson 10y agoDepending on jurisdiction and the particulars of the sale and who you sold it to, I think it's possible you could be charged as an accomplice if the exploit is used in a crime. For example, if you had any reason to believe the individual or organisation you sold it to might use it illegally, and someone singles you out after they do use it illegally, I don't think it would be hard for a prosecutor to make a case. I also don't think under those particular circumstances that's necessarily a bad thing. IANAL though.
- lawnchair_larry 10y agoThey discount it because it's not true. Nothing illegal about looking for vulnerabilities in products and being compensated for your findings. It's only illegal to attack someone else's deployment.
- dtemp 10y agoGetting a CVE on your resume isn't bad either.
- schoen 10y ago> Only reason to participate in them is charity. Maybe believing that it's good when fewer vulnerabilities exist and when attackers are less able to exploit things? Does that count as charity?
- jessaustin 10y ago...noun: the voluntary giving of help to those in need.
- moyix 10y agoWashington post got former NSA TAO employees to go on record (anonymously) confirming the leaked toolkit comes from NSA: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/powerful-nsa-hacking-tools-have-been-revealed-online/2016/08/16/bce4f974-63c7-11e6-96c0-37533479f3f5_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/power...
- wang_li 10y agoGood. Given that these tools no longer can be considered available only to the NSA, they might start working with vendors to close these particular set of holes.
- DanielDent 10y agoI wonder how this leak affects their "vulnerabilities equities process". The publicly available data would suggest that thus-far NSA-hoarded vulnerabilities are definitively known to actors who appear willing to act against US interests. Vendor disclosure means those vulnerabilities can be patched and US interests can cease being vulnerable, but could also confirm NSA awareness of vulnerabilities - which could in turn cause attribution concerns for past or present operations the NSA is undertaking or has undertaken using these vulnerabilities (in addition to providing additional credibility to the leaker). What a tangled web.
- rdtsc 10y agoWorked with the US govt (selling to it) and can tell by browsing those files, there is a high chance it came from a 3 letter US govt agency. It was just by looking at stuff they reference, packages, tools they use. The language and phraseology in comments (excluding bundled software like requests and scapy of course). After many years you start to get a feel for stuff like that.
- fapjacks 10y agoYes, I think so, too.