4 ms·
So how can consumers respond to this corporate chicanery? In a capitalist system, the natural recourse is for citizens to turn to the private market for alterna
by Apocryphon 10y ago
So how can consumers respond to this corporate chicanery? In a capitalist system, the natural recourse is for citizens to turn to the private market for alternatives. Could this provide an incentive for Aetna's competitors to make it easier for Aetna's customers to switch to them?
One would assume that libertarians and free marketeers would cheer the concept of boycotts, as it is one of the mechanisms that citizens are empowered with in a laissez-faire society.
- rayiner 10y agoWhat corporate chicanery? They took a loss on exchange plans last year. They have every right to pull out of the exchanges until the government makes them stay. I'm a supporter of single payer. But the health care market is a sterling example of the "worst of all solutions" espoused by the Democrats. Instead of simply raising everyone's taxes to pay for public services, they try to get companies to do hidden cross-subsidization, propping up money-losing individual plans with profits from group plans. And then they berate companies for pulling out of money-losing enterprises, as if providing healthcare for people who can't afford it is the job of private companies rather than the government.
- Apocryphon 10y agoIt's more about opposing their attempts to thwart antitrust law. After AT&T's merger failed, T-Mobile used the money and the public fallout as an opportunity to reinvent themselves as a company that caters to the public. I'm wondering if this could be a similar opportunity for Aetna's competitors. If the government is unable to prevent monopolies, then consumers should step in by punishing companies that seek to monopolize. Edit: Again, that's one of the concepts behind libertarianism, isn't? The idea that instead of relying upon government regulation, there's almost some economic reputation system in place which would cause consumers to reject doing business with bad actors. So in theory, the recourse here would be for the individual consumer to reject Aetna directly in response for their monopolistic practices.
- onewaystreet 10y agoThe headline is misleading. Aetna didn't threaten to pullout if their merger wasn't approved, they said that they would be forced to do so because they would be losing too much money. That isn't "attempting to thwart antitrust law," it's simply stating the facts.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Apocryphon 10y agoThen so be it. If Aetna is unable to withstand the rigors of the post-Obamacare climate, then they should fail accordingly. Their competitors seem to be able to hold on without resorting to monopolistic tactics. Better they fail now, before they become too big to fail through mergers and acquisitions.
- harryh 10y agoThe issue is not that the ACA is causing Aetna to fail. Aetna makes an enormous amount of money on employer sponsored health care plans. Where Aetna was losing money was on the public exchanges, a new line of business that didn't exist before the ACA. And it's not just them. Nearly all of the large insurance companies are pulling out of the exchanges because they're losing money. A lot of people believe this is because, as they are currently constructed, the public exchanges are untenable. And that's a very big deal if it's true. Not for the profitability of insurance companies, but for public health care policy in this country.
- rayiner 10y agoYou make it seem like forcing a company to serve an unprofitable market is the same as regular market competition. It's not. It's extremely distortionary. And it hurts competition--it basically means only huge insurance companies that make big profits on group plans they can use to offset losses on exchange plans can afford to enter the market.
- 10y ago
- Analemma_ 10y ago> ... sterling example of the "worst of all solutions" espoused by the Democrats. Instead of simply raising everyone's taxes to pay for public services ... Nope, I'm not letting this slide by. The Democrats did try to do exactly what you propose in the 90s. If it had worked, we would've had a first-world health care system two decades ago. But it was screamed down by the Republican Congress with the usual taxes-liberty-communism-Stalin rhetoric. The ACA was intended as an improvement over the nightmare we had pre-2010 that was still digestible to Republicans. Remember: it's fundamentally a Republican idea. It's similar to what Gingrich proposed as a counter to Clinton's plan (which is what really boils my blood about conservation opposition to it), and it's more-or-less identical to what Romney implemented when he was governor of Massachusetts. So yes, the ACA is a "worst of all worlds" compromise, and of course it sucks. Almost all the Democrats I know agree that it should be scrapped and replaced by a single-payer system tomorrow. But since that doesn't seem likely to happen, the ACA is what we've got. And your blaming of the Democrats for the failure of a Republican idea implemented because the Democrat's much better idea isn't politically possible is despicable and disingenuous in the extreme.
- tptacek 10y agoYou're a supporter of single payer? Health care is something like a fifth of the whole US economy. You're comfortable with the USG setting prices for it?
- harryh 10y agoI don't know about single payer, but health care is tricky. What do we do (as a society) about this guy: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12307526 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12307526 He has his gallbladder out and all of a sudden he's a super risky person to insure. How do we get him in a risk pool where his premiums won't be unaffordable?
- tptacek 10y agoBy shifting more of the group insurance market onto the individual market, perhaps mostly by eliminating current incentives for employer group coverage, to minimize the adverse selection problem. Incidentally: two members of my immediate family have the same problem he does. No history of serious illness, no current health problems, probably healthier than the median in both cases for their age cohort, but uninsurable outside the exchanges due to bogus pre-existing condition rules.
- harryh 10y ago1) Can we make the individual mandate in the individual market strong enough to really eliminate (or at least minimize) the adverse selection problem? I am unconvinced that we can. Perhaps though. 2) Are you really convinced that the pre-existing rules you encountered were bogus? Are insurance companies just dumb when it comes to this sort of thing? I tend to assume, absent other evidence, that insurance companies will be profit seeking so would only turn people down if they expected to (probabilistically) lose money on the deal. Perhaps they're just not smart enough to discern differences at this level though? I don't have much experience in this area.
- tptacek 10y ago
- grandalf 10y agoWithout a law requiring insurance companies to participate, why should they? Let's not pretend they have anything other than self-interest at stake. Why not pass such a law? Because that would effectively mean semi-nationalizing a fairly large industry, and if we're going to do that, why not just create an actual single payer and a risk pool the size of the US population and skip the idea of having private firms involved at all. The biggest problem with the idea of single payer "insurance" is that it's not actually insurance. It bundles in a variety of things such as pre-payment for services, wealth redistribution, price controls for services, and some actual insurance. A social safety net is a good thing. But if we expect to benefit from the benefits of a competitive system, we have to let firms actually compete. The core issues have to do with the lack of "insurance" market for things that are actually prepayment (like giving birth, dying of old age after $50K worth of end of life care, etc). By mandating that consumers buy the "insurance" and mandating that insurers bundle all the non-insurance services into the package, the government essentially controls the market and avoids both the benefits of market competition and accountability for tough decisions such as which care should be covered, etc. There have been many threats from industry and government. Government can nationalize and can pass laws that reduce profits, and firms can pull back, can merge with each other, and do other things to increase their market power. The bottom line is that the entire system is ripe for corruption and lack of accountability. Let's face it, for a healthy young person, catastrophic insurance is next to free. Yet all of us are paying fairly high premiums so that old people can be exploited by a healthcare system that happily gives them ineffective surgeries and sells them overpriced and largely ineffective pharmaceuticals. The system was already corrupt before Obamacare, Obamacare simply cemented many of the most lucrative public/private deals. Both sides intended to scheme a bit after the programs got underway. So we'll see a bit of tit for tat with regulators and perhaps watch one or two of the entrants leave the market allowing the profits to be divided fewer ways.