18 ms·
That article struck me as strange, it appears to take a really common phenomena (build for a market you understand) and turns it into a "China" thing. Apparentl
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
That article struck me as strange, it appears to take a really common phenomena (build for a market you understand) and turns it into a "China" thing. Apparently nobody at the times remembers when the "Internet" was practically a US only thing. All written in English, not a lot of support for non-English speakers (even Spanish!), massive assumptions about what time zone you might be in, Etc. And guess what, people in Germany making web sites had to choose to either make German sites for their audience or US centric sites to appeal to the big chunk of Internet users.
China is a market that is large enough by itself to be self supporting, just like the US market. So you can create an Internet business that is "China only" or "US Only" and be successful. And as the size of the markets are comparable your large China only Internet companies can be as large as US only Internet companies.
The interesting bit is that those markets are different enough that approaches in one don't work in the other. Like Google's version of search in China didn't work, nor did Uber's version of ride sharing. We can discuss regulatory hurdles, or society expectations, or technological differences, but at the core of all this they are two very different markets. So you need very different products and organizations to succeed in one or the other. I have yet to see a multi-national/international organization which has the flexibility to achieve that.
One of the most informative experiments so far has been Airbus. It is interesting to look at how it splits itself across countries and works to achieve a common purpose.
- jbooth 10y agoI think you're understating the amount of protectionism going on here. This isn't just a matter of language barrier and it's not even just a matter of the CCP wanting to maintain control. There's a deliberate effort to kneecap American tech companies in order to help their domestic tech companies develop.
- dredmorbius 10y agoYou might enjoy this: a 19th century encyclopaedia edit war over free trade policies between a British publisher and its American partners. https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/4xe2k1/chambers_encyclopaedia_editorial_statement/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/4xe2k1/chamber... Source: https://archive.org/stream/chambersencyclo00unkngoog#page/n13/mode/1up https://archive.org/stream/chambersencyclo00unkngoog#page/n1... I've sketched in some related information at Ello which I need to incorporate. This is strongly related to Friedrich List's National System of political economy. The 18th and 19th centuries were interesting times.
- snaky 10y ago> nobody at the times remembers when the "Internet" was practically a US only thing The FIDOnet was at that times practically a Russia only thing.
- _0ffh 10y agoI think the people who remember the (proto-)Internet being "a US only thing" are hardly more than a few hands full. Because that would have been when there were maybe a few dozen servers or so, exclusively in either military installations or educational institutions. (And, also, well before it was called "Internet".) When the Internet went transnational, it was more or less universities-only for quite some time. Still not many people around, then. People mostly used English as a language, for the simple reason that nearly everybody knows it. It's just the simplest and most sensible option. When the Internet finally really entered the public consciousness in the mid-90's - quite a bit after the first web server outside of Europe was set up in Stanford in 1991 - it had been a transnational thing for longer than not.