10 ms·
Cortana is yet another feature, that you wouldn't turn on, if it was off by default. I don't truly understand the goal of Cortana, other than "Apple has Siri".
by mrweasel 10y ago
Cortana is yet another feature, that you wouldn't turn on, if it was off by default.
I don't truly understand the goal of Cortana, other than "Apple has Siri". Some of the person assistant features seems handy, but do you really need to talk to your computer? The only place where it seems like something I'd need is when cooking and want to look up a recipe.
Microsoft efforts would have been better spend improving the built in search.
- Houshalter 10y agoThere are a lot of people with very poor typing skills. It's a nice idea, and speech recognition is just now getting good enough to allow it. Google has also put a speech to text button on their search boxes.
- blahi 10y agoYou can type to Cortana. I find it very useful and would most definitely turn it on. It will also become a lot better in the future when software is integrated with it (office coming in the next update). The "spying" has been greatly exaggerated, I think, by people who suddenly found themselves without a reason to hate on Microsoft and it was the obvious choice.
- Sylos 10y agoConsidering that Microsoft's Privacy Statement now asks for complete access to all data on your computer, I cannot see how any privacy concerns should be too exaggerated.
- bmer 10y agoWhat's so terrible about Microsoft having complete access to all data on my computer? I am pretty sure that's a massive exaggeration (could you back up that claim?), but for the moment I'll assume it isn't. So what? Why should I be worried and/or scared? For reference, I am not a White Anglo-Saxon Protestant, and actually come from a group that tends to be (in my opinion) unfairly painted in people's minds. I kind of like the idea of Microsoft having access to all of my data. Maybe one day in the future, people will be like..."hmm...you know that random group X that we generalized in order to hate on? turns out we can't really generalize them so easily -- we even have data to back it up!" I'd be like a primary source in future archaeology!
- oxide 10y agoHonestly, if my data is being used or sold I want something in return. A service, a product, a bribe. Something of tangible value. If my data is being taken and I'm not interested in the service being provided in return, I feel like I'm being ripped off.
- Sylos 10y agoI don't think, I have to explain that your stance on privacy is not the norm, at all, and that other people can very realistically have a different stance, i.e. a major problem with Microsoft (and the NSA and whoever else is involved) sifting through all of their data. As for the part in their Privacy Statement (https://privacy.microsoft.com/en-us/privacystatement/ https://privacy.microsoft.com/en-us/privacystatement/), which boils down to that, it's this section: "Finally, we will access, transfer, disclose, and preserve personal data, including your content (such as the content of your emails in Outlook.com, or files in private folders on OneDrive), when we have a good faith belief that doing so is necessary to: 1. comply with applicable law or respond to valid legal process, including from law enforcement or other government agencies; 2. protect our customers, for example to prevent spam or attempts to defraud users of our products, or to help prevent the loss of life or serious injury of anyone; 3. operate and maintain the security of our products, including to prevent or stop an attack on our computer systems or networks; or 4. protect the rights or property of Microsoft, including enforcing the terms governing the use of the services - however, if we receive information indicating that someone is using our services to traffic in stolen intellectual or physical property of Microsoft, we will not inspect a customer's private content ourselves, but we may refer the matter to law enforcement." "Access, transfer, disclose, and preserve" is what I summarized as "complete access", as that is everything you can do with data, except maybe destroy it, but that doesn't make much sense in a privacy-context. And then "when we have a good faith belief that doing so is necessary", that's the part where you sign away the rights for Microsoft to do that whenever the fuck they want. I mean, they list a few points, for what it would be necessary, so you might be able to make a case in court, that Microsoft could never have had that good faith belief for one of those points, but then one of those points is "protect the [...] property of Microsoft". And without a doubt would Microsoft have a good faith belief that selling your personal data is necessary to protect their property.
- gbl08ma 10y agoYou don't need to talk to use Cortana. I had Cortana disabled until the Anniversary Update came. If you don't agree to letting it see your emails/calendar/personal stuff, it will become a limited version of itself (in fact, it didn't prompt me about it until I actively tried to do something that needed it). I was OK with letting that limited version enabled, and thought I would still not use even that. A few days ago, however, I had to set a five minutes timer. It was much easier to press the Windows key and type "set a timer for five minutes" than to go search for whatever app is responsible for timers. I find the "grandma-friendly command line" part of Cortana much more useful than the voice control part, and I can see why it comes enabled by default. I mainly use Linux and wish I had something like that in my KDE desktop (the Alt+F2 command bar is similar, but nowhere close).
- aruggirello 10y agoOTOH in KDE Plasma 5, if you have the great event calendar widget, setting a timer is just a couple mouse clicks away :)
- dietrichepp 10y agoYou can do some of that online. Please forgive the LMGTFY link, since I'm really just trying to demonstrate a feature of Google's search engine: http://lmgtfy.com/?q=5+minute+timer http://lmgtfy.com/?q=5+minute+timer
- gbl08ma 10y agoYeah, but I don't have Google mapped to a keyboard key, but even if I did, googling for "5 minute timer" (and similar variants, like "1 minute timer" or "30 seconds timer") yields the usual search results for me. At least Cortana is (at least since the Anniversary Update) consistent with what features it offers to each user, unlike Google which will randomly not present those built-in tools. And since I can't try it, I'm wondering: to use Google's timer, do I need to leave the tab open until it ends? Because in that case it's nowhere as nice as Cortana, which just goes into background...
- 10y ago
- drzaiusapelord 10y ago>other than "Apple has Siri". And google has Google Now. Amazon has Alexa. I think if you want to be competitive in the OS world, you'll probably need something like this. The real problem is how heavy handed MS is with pushing its features. >but do you really need to talk to your computer? On mobile, yes, considering Win10 is also a mobileOS. In desktop mode you would just type in the cortana box if you prefer. I also imagine there's a larger vision for Cortana. The product is pretty half-assed right now but I could see it being used for a lot of admin functions we're used to via control panel or hotkeys. It would be nice to say, "Cortana switch the display to the wireless projector" or "Cortana, update the nvidia driver." Remember that scene when Scotty scoffs at the 20th century computer you couldn't talk to in The Voyage Home? Of course we want to talk to our computers. I want to order it around, not hunt and peck through menus and control panels or try to find something with endless swipes. People like to talk and give orders. As technology becomes more featureful, we'll be using a voice a lot more. I know I do already with Google Now on my watch and Alexa at home.
- Nullabillity 10y ago> On mobile, yes, considering Win10 is also a mobileOS. On mobile, still no, because none of them actually work properly. And didn't the mobile division recently shut down? > I also imagine there's a larger vision for Cortana. The product is pretty half-assed right now but I could see it being used for a lot of admin functions we're used to via control panel or hotkeys. It would be nice to say, "Cortana switch the display to the wireless projector" In exchange for losing the discoverability that projectors are indeed supported. It'll also be wonderful to have to Google for exactly how to word it so that Cortana will actually parse it correctly. > or "Cortana, update the nvidia driver." At this point I wouldn't be surprised if the next update completely removes the ability to do this...
- cptskippy 10y ago> The real problem is how heavy handed MS is with pushing its features. Google Assistant, Alexa, and Siri are all on by default.
- 10y ago
- elorant 10y agoMy dad, at 78, uses it a lot. Like most seniors he doesn't feel comfortable using a PC and Cortana eases that discomfort. It somehow makes the computer seem a bit more friendly and usable. I know it sounds bizarre but for someone who started using computers at 70 makes a lot of sense.
- melling 10y ago"do you really need to talk to your computer?" Yes, and we've been waiting decades for it. And we've been waiting for Minority Report for a decade and a half too. The future is late. Btw, please skip the part where you try to explain why no one needs it. You simply lack imagination.
- Longhanks 10y agoThis is not Star Trek. Speech recognition isn't nearly as productive as typing with a keyboard or clicking the mouse, so apart from people not being able to type or click, nobody really 'needs' speech recognition. It's a gimmick.
- zeroer 10y agoBillions of people can't type.
- oz 10y agoSometimes, I put something in the freezer for a quick (30 mins) cooldown. Me being me, I'll forget about it aso soon as I close the freezer. I've lost several beers that way. Now? "Ok Google...set timer for 30 mins." Much quicker than unlocking, finding the Clock app, and fat-fingering the time widgets. This also works for reminders and a host of other things. Speech recognition is not a gimmick.
- braythwayt 10y agoI agree. I use speech recognition all the time on my watch. The killer app for this? "Children! 10 more minutes, then we're turning screens off. Hey Siri! Set a timer for ten minutes." Much easier than fiddling with the crown to set a 10 minute timer.
- melling 10y agoYou're a code monkey who sits at the keyboard all day? Most people have to get to a desktop, but would rather pull out a mobile device to get the job done. Of course coders have made progress at using dictation: http://ergoemacs.org/emacs/using_voice_to_code.html http://ergoemacs.org/emacs/using_voice_to_code.html Like I said, you lack imagination. Also, no one said you need to use speech for every task. It might simply help with RSI so you don't end up like this: http://www.looknohands.me http://www.looknohands.me Also, most people aren't coders. Designers, for example, might be using Photoshop with a Wacom tablet and would like to not have to use a keyboard. "New layer" "Layer hide" " "move layer up/down". "Text tool. Change text to San Francisco regular 16 point "