19 ms·
First Tesla Taxi in America after 100k miles
- larrik 10y agoWow, as someone who's never even seen a true electric car up close, I'm curious how you can keep it going for a full day of work. Charging it takes hours, right? Unlike gasoline which you can just pull in and be back on the road in a couple of minutes.
- Kalium 10y agoThe Supercharger stations can charge 50% of the battery in 20 minutes.
- alex_hitchins 10y agoDo the superchargers have a detremental effect on the batteries? I would have thought rapid charging would lead to greater wear than a slow steady charge. Anyone know?
- mtgx 10y agoThey do yes. You should only use it when traveling and can't charge it overnight.
- sammydavis 10y agoThe superchargers might have an impact on battery life, but in practice they don't seem to have much impact. The reason is that unlike all other electric cars, they heat and cool the battery pack. The reason why leafs do have a demonstrated huge impact for using their dc fast charging (chademo) is because their batteries get really hot when using chademo. The tesla cools the batteries when charging, heating if necessary too, and that's why people don't such much or any impact on range over time, even when using super charging.
- Phlarp 10y agoA more aggressive charge cycle will affect battery life-cycle, but even the Super-Chargers don't pack enough current for it to be really detrimental. 110v is just woefully inadequate for charging a pack that large.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- billh 10y agoNot from what I've read. The Tesla battery pack has some sophisticated heat management capabilities that dump the excess heat generated while super charging. The most damaging things you can do to the batteries is keeping them 100% fully charged or completely discharging them.
- vvanders 10y agoYup, not an issue. When you're charging at 120kW the whole car hums and cooling system is going full-tilt. Pretty incredible to see 400VDC @ 300A go straight into the pack.
- VLM 10y agoIf you run the math its only roughly 170 continuous horsepower running thru those power cables, assuming 100% efficiency etc. If they added another order of magnitude or two to that charge rate, then it would be impressive.
- sammydavis 10y agoYou have to take into account that the electric motor in a tesla is more efficient than a gas motor (3-4x). The reasoning is that a gallon of has has about 33.6kwh in a gallon (see wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miles_per_gallon_gasoline_equivalent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miles_per_gallon_gasoline_equi...). A tesla has 75 or 85 or 90 kwh onboard, so that's at most 3 gallons of gas! Another way to think of it is that mpg equivalent of evs is around 90-100 mpg. The model S is a huge heavy car, and look how far it can go on 85kwh.
- sjburt 10y agoIf he's driven it 100,000 miles in 2.5 years, and assuming 250 working days a year, it's only 160 miles a day, well within a Tesla's range. He can probably charge it fully at night and have plenty for each day.
- Zikes 10y agoThe article cites approximately 50,000 miles per year. At 5 working days per week of driving, that would equal approximately 190 miles per day. The Model S page on Tesla's web site calculates that at 45 mph with the AC on (a reasonable speed for city driving) the Model S can get nearly 290 miles on a full charge [1]. In addition, if there is a Supercharger unit available, the Model S can recharge fully in less than an hour if less than 260 miles have thus far been driven [2]. Meaning it could be back at full charge following a typical lunch break period. [1] https://www.tesla.com/models#range-calculator https://www.tesla.com/models#range-calculator [2] https://www.tesla.com/models#savings-calculator https://www.tesla.com/models#savings-calculator
- giarc 10y agoNo supercharger in Quebec City, but some destination chargers. https://www.tesla.com/en_CA/findus?redirect=no#/bounds/46.9819379,-71.14270060000001,46.7340768,-71.54944490000003,d?search=store,service,supercharger,destination%20charger&name=quebec%20city https://www.tesla.com/en_CA/findus?redirect=no#/bounds/46.98...
- bluGill 10y ago50,000 miles a year is only 200 miles a day (assuming 2 weeks of vacation), the tesla can do that range without any charges, he just needs to have enough charge an usually long trip at the end of the day. At the rates taxies charge, someone who goes for farther than the charge of a Tesla is going to make the news just for their bill - even if the trip is in a normal gas car. I expect that he plugs in over lunch hour, and at bathroom brakes. This won't get him to full charge, but it is enough to ensure that he can handle a long trip. If he is ever at less than half charge he has made enough money that he can afford to take an hour off to charge.
- Grishnakh 10y agoNot only that, but he'll save time by not having to go to a gas station like regular taxis do.
- outworlder 10y ago> Wow, as someone who's never even seen a true electric car up close, I'm curious how you can keep it going for a full day of work. Charging it takes hours, right? Unlike gasoline which you can just pull in and be back on the road in a couple of minutes. Right and wrong. 110v charging would take days. Supercharging takes minutes. I don't drive a Tesla, I have a Leaf. 110v is enough to recharge overnight for my commute (~20 miles each way). Or about a couple of hours charging at work. Not an issue for commuting. Were it used as a Taxi, I'd have to rely on quickchargers. About 20 minutes from 20 to 80% SOC. It's not linear, so very low and very high state of charger takes longer. A Taxi Leaf would likely be doable for a dense city, very bad for highway driving, as speed kills range (for any kind of car). For a Tesla it's not an issue.
- rkangel 10y agoThere's no mention of battery degradation. That's what I'd be curious about. Has anyone got a Tesla with a load of miles on the clock?
- mciancia 10y agoThat was the first things I was looking for in this article... I wonder why they skipped this topic as this is the most important thing related to electric cars
- ythl 10y agoI'm interested in this as well. I was under the assumption that the range of the Model S goes down slightly with every charge.
- alex_hitchins 10y agoI assume the batteries aren't under the warrenty? Is it the case with some EV's that you never own the battery, you have a lifetime lease so the unit gets refreshed every so often?
- ams6110 10y agoI'm surprised that Tesla honors the consumer warranty with the car being used for commercial purposes. That's pretty unusual I think.
- gaadd33 10y agoDo most cars have warranties that only apply to non commercial use? I've never heard of that and it would be interesting to see some examples.
- brianwawok 10y agoMost everything does. My lawnmower has a 3 year warranty. 30 days if commercial use. My blender has a 2 year warranty. 0 days if commercial use. I don't know about cars or not having the exclusion, but it wouldn't surprise me.
- djaychela 10y agoWhile clearly this is a taxi driver, 50k / year is not a lot of mileage for a taxi - I know some people who do more in a company car (I managed similar on a couple of years), and some taxis are team driven, with three drivers sharing cost and shifts - indeed one I knew of years ago did about 120k a year, having several engine rebuilds, and getting over 800k before being sold. The odometer was only a 5 digit one, and I met the guy who bought it, thinking it had 125k on it, when it was actually 825k (long before the UK MOT history database was available)! Anyway, it will be interesting to see how they hold up to these sort of starship mileages...
- busterarm 10y agoThree!? Lucky. New York yellow cab drivers split 12 hour shifts and pay ~$150/driver/day just to lease a medallion.
- chillydawg 10y agoLess meddling in taxi regulations almost anywhere not-NYC. Medallions are a huge scam and are a very powerful market manipulation by the govt.
- busterarm 10y agoLess, but not much less. There's actually an enormous amount of taxi legislation almost everywhere (in the US). There are many, many, many airports where taxi drivers have to pay a huge fee just for the privilege of picking up a fare there. In some places as high as $30-50.
- semi-extrinsic 10y ago"Christian admitted that Tesla’s regular maintenance repairs like brakes and bearings cost more than those on his old car, a Subaru Legacy" And the "drive unit" (electric motor?) has been replaced. Twice. As I've said before, electric cars won't mean a significant decrease in maintenance costs. But, he has managed to save $43 a month on gas! Edit: reading comprehension failed me, as pointed out below, he saves $293 a month on gas.
- 3princip 10y agoTwo engine replacements, in a little over two years? Yikes. How expensive is the drive train compared to a combustion engine? maybe I'm missing something.
- giarc 10y agoDrive train was replaced 2x for free.
- 3princip 10y agoIs that sustainable? For Tesla I mean. They can't keep changing drive trains for everybody at no cost.
- maxerickson 10y agoIt's likely brand building. I doubt they are as generous with the Model 3. I would also sort of expect them to adjust the terms for new buyers of the more expensive cars once they figure out their actual lifetime costs for the warranty.
- johnward 10y agoI'm curious to see what they offer on the Model 3. I'm guess they go back to a more industry standard warranty.
- giarc 10y ago
- post_break 10y agoI don't understand how his warranty isn't void for operating the vehicle as a taxi.
- gambiting 10y agoWhy would it be? When you buy a vehicle, you get a warranty that covers you for either X years or Y miles(or both). What difference does it make if you do those Y miles driving for pleasure or for work? It's the same to the car. I would be really really surprised if they refused to honour his warranty because he was using it as a taxi.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoHe has the 'infinite mile' warranty, which is offered with certain assumptions that definitely aren't holding in his case.
- post_break 10y agoMost vehicle warranties specifically state using a vehicle for work or fleet is not included in the original warranty. Same thing for insurance.
- gambiting 10y agoInsurance, sure. But show me one vehicle warranty that varies between personal/commercial use. I've had Peugeots, Land Rover, Nissan, Citroen and most recently a Mercedes(some of those I've purchased under business contracts and used for work) - none of their warranty booklets made any distinction between personal and commercial use, and frankly - I don't think that by law they can. The only thing that maybe applies if you are using the car commercially is the "heavy use" servicing schedule, so instead of changing the oil every 16 thousand miles you have to do it every 10.
- post_break 10y agoChrysler has a specific fleet warranty that calls out using vehicles for work.
- emcrazyone 10y ago"Christian’s old Subaru had to have its engine rebuilt two or three times over the course of about 330,000 miles." Which is it? An engine rebuild is a significant cost and down time and he's not sure how many times it has been rebuilt? Makes me question the validity of the rest of the article's data when you don't know your own basic facts/history especially for is a major repair item.
- honkhonkpants 10y ago"Rebuilt" is also pretty vague. Bottom end? Top end? Rings? Whole engine out of the vehicle? It does seem like this gentleman simply assigns some value to driving around in a Tesla all day, which is fine with me but the article should not try to make it seem economically rational.
- Grishnakh 10y agoThat's a good point. I "rebuilt" the engine in my ex-wife's car years ago because she got stuck in a flash-flood and hydrolocked the engine. All I did was take off the head, give that to a shop that specialized in heads for them to replace the valves on one cylinder and clean up, then I replaced one piston and conrod and all the rings. It worked great for another 80-90k miles until we sold it, and I suspect it's still working fine now. But I never had to pull the engine out, and most of the head wasn't touched (except cleaning up all the carbon deposits on the valves). However, if Tesla has worked the bugs out of their drive units, these cars would make some sense for use as cabs, especially if you're able to charge more than regular cabs: an EV should have much lower maintenance costs than a regular car, plus much lower fuel/energy costs (cabs are driven in the city all the time so they get lousy fuel economy compared to most regular cars). The main problem I see is Tesla's high maintenance charges (e.g., they'll probably charge you a lot more to change a wheel bearing at a Tesla service center than a Toyota dealership would for a Camry), however things like wheel bearings are things that an independent mechanic should be able to handle just fine, assuming they can get their hands on a compatible part and Tesla didn't use some odd-ball part. It'd be even cheaper if this cab driver can do his own repairs like that; wheel bearings are not that hard to change, though some of them require a hydraulic press, but you can get one of those at Harbor Freight for about $60. Others are simple bolt-in affairs that anyone can do with some simple hand tools in their garage.
- readhn 10y ago"So sure, the car cost about $70,000. And it had to have its drive unit (ENGINE) replaced a few times. " That sounds like a failure to me. If this was 70,000$ FORD that had to have its engine replaced 2-3 times then people would be screaming LEMON. But since its Tesla - it is ok somehow. Anyway what matters for taxi driver is the cost per mile. Tesla spending: 70,000 + 3,700 (electricity) + 7,000 (repairs) = ~ $80,000 Toyota camry spending: 23,000 + 10,000 (gas) + 2,000 (repairs) = ~ $35,000 Tesla: 80,000$/100,000 miles = 0.8 USD/mile Toyota camry: 35,000$/100,000 miles = 0.35 USD/mile Cost per mile driven: Tesla > Toyota by 2.3x Total cost: if he was to sell Tesla today he would lose $35,000. If he sold camry today he would lose $13,000 Financially Tesla still does not make sense.
- hx87 10y agoIf the driver can charge >2.3x more for a Tesla per mile, which isn't all that ridiculous (considering the prison-grade vinyl seats, constantly yakking ad screens and near-criminal lack of legroom in Camrys with plexiglas dividers), it starts to make more financial sense.
- readhn 10y agoIf i had a choice to go to the airport for 40$ or for 92$ which would i (or >90% over people) choose? hmmmm. i'll go with 40$ thank you.
- hx87 10y agoIf I were 6'4" (193cm) or taller, I'd take the Tesla for $92 any day. Even my current 5'8" (172cm) self would hesitate taking a Toyota Camry taxi due to the lack of leg and knee room, which is why I almost always avoid them in favor of Uber or Lyft, whose cars don't have the divider.
- kamaal 10y agoI don't think you get the point here. You are not getting married to that car. You are only going to use it for a few minutes. Having to pay 2.3x just for a few minutes for zero additional utility derived isn't something most people do, Unless in a extreme emergency. Even those who are tall would agree.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoI would wonder about the tire costs. Tesla is big and heavy with large blingy wheels and high performance rubber. I guess you can get cheaper than original tired but not a lot cheaper in that size. Also curious about insurance costs.
- vvanders 10y agoInsurance is actually pretty cheap relatively. They're the safest car on the road which really brings down medical and injury costs. I want to say it was ~$30/mo more than our Subaru. Tire costs: yeah. I'm at 35k right now and about to replace my first set of 19" tires for around ~$900. I ran the numbers and I actually pay more per-mile in tire cost(0.023) than electricity(0.02). That said my gas costs still more than make up for it. I was spending ~$300/mo in gas where I now spend ~$40.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoSource for safest car on the road? I don't see it on this list http://www.iihs.org/iihs/news/desktopnews/small-overlap-crash-protection-front-crash-prevention-key-to-2016-awards-48-models-earn-top-safety-pick-award-13-earn-top-safety-pick http://www.iihs.org/iihs/news/desktopnews/small-overlap-cras...
- vvanders 10y agohttp://www.businessinsider.com/tesla-tesla-model-s-achieves-best-safety-rating-of-any-car-ever-tested-2013-8 http://www.businessinsider.com/tesla-tesla-model-s-achieves-...
- cpr 10y agoSome years back, when taking a local taxi in the Shoreline Connecticut area (Old Saybrook, Westbrook, Clinton, etc.), the taxi company owner told me she would buy only certain years of Audio 5000's at 200-300K for not much at auction, and then, with normal maintenance, they'd go to 700-900-1000K without problems. I'm afraid I've forgotten the years involved.
- readhn 10y agoYes certain Audi models were bullet proof! Also Mercedes certain models were known to go well over 500,000miles. They were used widely as cabs in europe. Saab, volvo another honorable mentions... but boy did the things change... SAAB is gone RIP. Volvo became a complete POS as well. Try doing this in an Audi or Mercedes or Volvo today and see how fast your bank account depletes to keep it running.
- dang 10y agoUrl changed from http://jalopnik.com/heres-how-a-tesla-taxi-held-up-after-100-000-miles-1785360286 http://jalopnik.com/heres-how-a-tesla-taxi-held-up-after-100..., which points to this.
- mungoman2 10y agoThis article reads like a paid ad... is it?
- caiob 10y agoCanada ≄ America
- mars4rp 10y agothe problem is he is comparing a brand new maintenance cost to a car with 300K miles on it!! any brand new car is going to cost less in repair compare to a car with 300K Miles!
- Maarten88 10y agoIn the Netherlands there are many Tesla taxis, especially around Amsterdam and Schiphol airport. Taxis drive more than regular cars so I see them all the time, to the point that most Tesla's on the road are taxis. I think this creates an "interesting" marketing challenge for Tesla here: taxi drivers are not well respected and most people do not want to be mistaken for a taxi driver. Being seen as a typical taxi brand will impact the image of Tesla in a negative way, like it has done here with Mercedes (another typical taxi here, if you see a Mercedes E series here it's usually a taxi, so normal people looking for a premium car buy a BMW or Volvo)
- pkulak 10y agoI'm not sure that Tesla considers it's current luxury status very important. Ever since Musk's first master plan he's maintained that producing luxury cars at all is just a means to an end of affordable electric cars. Maybe we can debate weather a $35,000 car is "affordable", but at least Tesla seems to think so. Prius's seem to have a lock on the cab market where I am, and those things just keep flying off the lot into private hands. Personally, when I see a car as a taxi, I can't help but think that thing has got to be reliable as hell.
- melling 10y ago$35k is about the average price of a new car. http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2015/05/04/new-car-transaction-price-3-kbb-kelley-blue-book/26690191/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2015/05/04/new-car-... That makes it affordable enough to make a difference.
- thesimpsons1022 10y agoThat doesn't mean the average person can afford it. More likely that the average person purchases a 10,000 dollar used car.
- Alterlife 10y agoIn a few years, perhaps a 10,000.00$ used Tesla.
- cloudjacker 10y agoThats really interesting, thanks for breaking down the numbers! Ultimately it looks like it is nice consumer friendly option, but the repair costs are being subsidized by Tesla at great expense to Tesla, and even then the total cost compared to the gas car is only marginally better. The primary takeaway here is that the more expensive car has better resale value, from name and build quality. Which is the only saving grace in this equation. After Elon's crowdsale cars come out at the lower price, its game over though!
- blinkingled 10y ago>brakes, bearings, and parts of the suspension, which was considered normal wear after 100,000 miles. Wtf? I don't know of any regular car that's needed all of that changed and it was deemed normal. What's so different about brakes, bearing and suspension in a Tesla? I know 250k Priuses that haven't needed any of these.
- ianferrel 10y agoAre those regular cars in service as taxis? Most cars do the majority of their driving on freeways, where breaks and suspension have it pretty easy. Taxis, not so much.
- blinkingled 10y agoGood point but neither the article nor any Tesla documents seem to make the taxi distinction - making it sound like it's normal wear for any Tesla.
- haylem 10y agoWell, actually I think you quoted it yourself: > [...] which was considered normal wear after 100,000 miles. It's not really clear, but I think the "considered normal" applies to the point of view of the interviewed taxi driver.
- driverdan 10y agoYou do not go 250k on a single set of brakes. 100k is a pretty long interval for a heavy vehicle. Bearings typically last longer than that but in heavier cars they are known to go sooner, eg Audis eat wheel bearings.
- gsmethells 10y agoThey need a Tesla taxi near where I live. I need a ride in one!