3 ms·
People who argue we should do nothing though have a sticky moral quandry: if you can show evidence of something bad happening (and there's a lot, and plenty mor
by XorNot 10y ago
People who argue we should do nothing though have a sticky moral quandry: if you can show evidence of something bad happening (and there's a lot, and plenty more to come) then you have to argue that these are all acceptable losses.
Which tends to open more sticky questions like refugee policy, or just how many you're willing to let die in famine from drought, and so where should the aid budget of the biggest, highest emitting countries be allocated.
EDIT: For example, what should our policy on disappearing pacific island nations be? What should our military posture be if we can expect more divergence from established geopolitical norms by extremized climate conditions? How much should be banked to deal with the increased major climate events per decade, compared to historical norms (aka how frequently is a katrina scale hurricane expected to make landfall going forward?)
Turns out, once you start adding up those costs, we don't really want to pay for any of them, but it would also just be morally repugnant to suggest that, really, abandoning the poor of coastal cities is what we want to do. Don't worry, we'll pray really hard and donate far less then <10% of our yearly incomes to help when it happens. But only while it's in the news.
- humanrebar 10y agoThose are all interesting and terrifying scenarios, but there's no science showing cap-and-trade or particular levels of carbon taxes will produce better outcomes. If they're both dead-end approaches, we need to focus even more on less obvious solutions or building up infrastructures and organizations to deal with the consequences. Pouring more good resources after bad in those cases will only make us less likely to be able to help refugees, build better levees, etc.
- JoBrad 10y agoCap and trade and carbon taxes are political solutions to address the scientific problem. It's hard to make people do something, and that's what they're trying to do. Don't confuse a solution you don't like with the science showing the problem.
- humanrebar 10y agoLikewise, we shouldn't conflate science and non-scientific solutions. We are confusing solutions we like with the science showing the problem. Calling people irrational and unscientific for seeing that is unfair and, again, not in keeping with healthy scientific exploration.