4 ms·
Given the current less-than-ideal patent environment, not licensing their patents is probably the only way Apple can maintain the level of product differentiati
by wtallis 17y ago
Given the current less-than-ideal patent environment, not licensing their patents is probably the only way Apple can maintain the level of product differentiation that enables them to maintain profit margins that fund the kind of R&D that their primary competitors (PC manufaturers) don't do. The loss of the FingerWorks products is bad for consumers, but there's no denying that the iPhone and the App Store it spawned are a far bigger market than FingerWorks would have ever had. If Apple could license the FingerWorks patents for keyboard use in a way that wouldn't erode their other product lines, they probably would.
It's important to remember that with the iPhone Apple was very much an upstart, with no experience in the cellular industry. They had a very tough time getting into the market because most carriers wouldn't agree to give Apple enough control to ensure that the carriers didn't ruin the user experience. They've now fundamentally changed the dynamics of the cellular industry, and all the device makers have more leverage. If Nokia and the other established phone manufacturers had been free to clone the iPhone as closely as they wanted, then the iPhone would have been mostly marginalized before Apple could even give it 3G capabilities. Apple would not have a particularly successful product on their hands, and the App Store revolution wouldn't have happened.