3 ms·
> an antithesis to its origins, where an email went straight to the machine of the final recipient, from the machine of the original sender —with no intermediat
by tedunangst 10y ago
> an antithesis to its origins, where an email went straight to the machine of the final recipient, from the machine of the original sender —with no intermediates besides the DNS servers.
Wow, is that some historical revisionism. Emails used to look like thrash!cmu!ucb!vax!tedu which meant send it to thrash, who will send it to cmu, who will send it to ucb, who will send it to the vax, which will deliver it to tedu. If you had a direct line, you could skip a few hops, but very few people were talking directly to the machine of the final recipient.
- drfuchs 10y agoNo, you're the one with incorrect history. The uucp email scheme with all the exclamation points actually appeared the better part of a decade after ARPANET email with the simple, direct addressing and delivery was in wide use. Perhaps you are confused because UNIX came late to the nascent Internet, while the various 36-bit DEC machines and OSes were there from the very beginning. Many thousands of students and academics were sending email to foo@bar.edu for dozens of values of bar before anybody ever saw !ucbvax! in an address.
- tedunangst 10y agoYes, that works when the network is small enough to put literally every computer in the hosts file. But once your local sysadmin tires of updating the file every time some university across the world plugs in a computer, it starts falling apart. To the original point, if I somehow plugged my time warped laptop into arpanet, nobody would be able to send me email until I made a bunch of phone calls. (But thanks for the correction, I'd overlooked even earlier history.)
- dredmorbius 10y agoThis misses the point. Bang paths were used (and I used them) because we didn't have DNS and MX records. Which meant that routing was done manually, by the mail sender. There was an end-to-end wired connection (usually -- batched and gathered mail, via UUCP was also a thing) between hosts. And pretty much any host, through intermediaries, could talk to any other. Traceroute will show you a fairly equivalent system today. The big difference was that the Internet (or its various ARPA / DARPA precursors) was a lot smaller. A few hundred hosts in the early 1980s, a few thousand by the end of the decade. And everyone knew each other. There was a book, literally, hardcopy print, with every site operator's name and phone number. Twice, for multiple indexing methods. In your example, tedu wouldn't have any cause to deny mail from thrash, or any other host, directly peered, or bang-pathed. At least not until Green Card (which was Usnet, and I remember that too).