3 ms·
Yes the butterfly is egregious. At least the breaststroke is a rational refinement of the largely instinctive (even for humans) dog-paddle, and had a long histo
by jessaustin 10y ago
Yes the butterfly is egregious. At least the breaststroke is a rational refinement of the largely instinctive (even for humans) dog-paddle, and had a long history as a modern racing stroke before Native Americans taught everyone that the crawl was faster. Even fairly poor swimmers can breaststroke for long distances. The butterfly seems like a bizarro version of the breaststroke, slightly faster but much more difficult and exhausting. They could add any additional arbitrary requirement to the butterfly, and the result wouldn't really be more arbitrary than it already is.
Perhaps swimming should take weightlifting as an example. This discipline requires lifters to perform two lifting techniques, the "snatch" and the "clean and jerk", and combines those to get the final result. This is similar to "medley" swim races, which may be a reasonable compromise between the current four-stroke insanity and eliminating stroke requirements altogether.
Walking is at least a natural gait. Triple jump is a single event, so it doesn't have the multiplicative effects that swimming strokes have.