7 ms·
It's the creation of wormholes that would violate physics, though, right? AFAIK our current model of physics would work just fine to describe a universe that ca
by derefr 10y ago
It's the creation of wormholes that would violate physics, though, right? AFAIK our current model of physics would work just fine to describe a universe that came into existence with permanent, stable wormholes already in it; that'd just be part of its topology.
- throw98172 10y agoEven an existing wormhole could still cause problems. Consider for example a wormhole between two points with different gravitational potential — say one end is close to the Earth and the other end is further away. Then if you could let yourself fall from the higher to the lower point, and took the wormhole to complete a loop, you would end the loop with more energy than you started with, which is a big no-no!
- mahranch 10y agoHe has it backwards. Our current physics allow for wormholes. They probably don't exist but if they were literally impossible, then we would need to rewrite our current physics. Wormholes are more than likely impossible because to hold one open for travel, you would need some sort of negative matter/negative energy. That isn't forbidden by physics, but it's unlikely that it exists since we haven't seen any. Without negative energy/matter to hold a wormhole open, even if you could create one, just a single proton or electron would cause the wormhole to become unstable and collapse in on itself, and doing so faster than the proton could travel through.
- ars 10y ago> Our current physics allow for wormholes. No, it does not. See my more detailed reply here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12301781 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12301781
- ars 10y agoNo. Using them is the problem. Say you are in a gravity well with one side of the wormhole, and the other side is outside the well. You could "lift" matter outside the gravity well without spending energy. There are other problems as well: Gravity has no discontinuities, as objects move, the gravitational field moves with it. You never have a situation where gravity just suddenly shows up. (The same is true for an electrical field BTW - you can never create one, you can only move an existing one (i.e. split up the positive and negative parts). A magnetic field can be created, but that's because you always create a north and south at the same time. If magnetic monopoles existed you could not create just one, you could only separate the two halves.) Anyway, a wormhole would allow you to have a gravitational discontinuity and that's impossible, it would create a gravitational wave with an infinite frequency. As you know a true square wave is physically impossible - the fourier transform requires an infinite frequency - but that's what you are doing by moving matter via a wormhole.
- openasocket 10y agoYou're assuming the gravitational field can't permeate the wormhole. In your first scenario, the gravity well would extend out of the other side of the wormhole. A wormhole is in no way a gravitational discontinuity, the toplogy for them is well defined. The creation of a wormhole would be a bit tricky, as this does require a discontinuity, but there's no reason to think that's impossible. After all, a gravitational singularity is also a discontinuity, and physicists have no problem with that. Here's a concrete example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ellis_wormhole https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ellis_wormhole That's a wormhole with a well-defined metric that satisfies the Einstein field equations.
- ars 10y ago> You're assuming the gravitational field can't permeate the wormhole. In your first scenario, the gravity well would extend out of the other side of the wormhole. That would be even worse, I replied to the same thing here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12301858 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12301858 > A wormhole is in no way a gravitational discontinuity A movable one certainly is, and a non movable one doesn't make any sense from a relativity point of view. > Ellis Wormhole Did you read your own link? "and there is no gravity" There's a reason they say that. And there is no place in the universe without gravity. It's a mathematical solution, not a representation of the physical world.
- openasocket 10y agoCan you define what you mean here by discontinuity? I meant that the function of the gravitational field is continuous everywhere under the topology of the manifold, the mathematical definition. I see no discontinuity, but perhaps you're using a different definition? The "no gravity" line there means the stress tensor is zero, and this is a so-called "vacuum solution." Essentially all closed form solutions to the field equations are vacuum solutions because it's almost impossible to write a closed form solution otherwise.
- ars 10y ago