3 ms·
It wouldn't be suitable for the general public, but here's how I would do the comparison for potential: - assume a normal distribution of innate ability. - as
by Someone 10y ago
It wouldn't be suitable for the general public, but here's how I would do the comparison for potential:
- assume a normal distribution of innate ability.
- assume a different normal distribution of each individual's variation in scoring (all with an expected value of zero and identical variance, smaller than that of innate ability)
- assume each nation picks its best athletes in trials (doesn't really happen; for example, Bolt wouldn't have qualified for Rio if Jamaica did that)
What you will get is that China and India should each have about 15% of the best performers. However, top performers of other large countries will not be far behind them in innate ability, so that there is a decent chance that their form of the day will make them beat better players. Also, most of the best athletes will live in countries with large populations, and most of those will not make it to the Olympics because they get beaten by their compatriots in qualification, either because of lack of innate ability or due to 'luck'.
End result I guess will be that each country that is large enough (pure guess: 50 million+, say Argentina, Britain, Colombia, France, Germany, Kenya, South Korea or anything larger) should, aan else being equal, get about the same number of medals.
Of course, not all else is equal. Any difference will be due to other factors:
- sport-mindedness (example: New Zealand)
- money invested (example: Great Britain, Qatar (a country that _buys_ Olympic champions)
- genetic make-up (example: Fiji in rugby)
- culture (example: table tennis and China, or India as a negative example for almost any sport that isn't cricket or field hockey)
- religion (many countries send a token female athlete because they have to, thus giving up about 50% of their potential number of medals)
Those are hard to quantify, and can change significantly over time. Britain is an extreme example, with 1 (one!) gold medal at the 1996 Olympics. Lottery money has changed that tremendously, not only for the home Olympics in London.
A final factor is that countries that are willing to spend money will influence what sports become Olympic sports. I don't think it is accidental that there are so many events in athletics and swimming, two sports that the US excels at. Advertising money buys events.
- jdminhbg 10y ago> A final factor is that countries that are willing to spend money will influence what sports become Olympic sports. I don't think it is accidental that there are so many events in athletics and swimming, two sports that the US excels at. Advertising money buys events. I don't doubt that advertising plays a role in which events exist, but athletics and swimming have had lots of events since the dawn of the Olympics, probably because they're easy to set up and they don't take a long time to run. If you were trying to get the US more medals, you might have 3-on-3 basketball, 1-on-1 basketball, 12 minute basketball, H.O.R.S.E., a dunk contest, etc.