5 ms·
My only issue with carbon fiber is that it is not very easily recycled. Aluminum, on the other hand, is quite trivially recycled. So while spaceships made from
by fastball 10y ago
My only issue with carbon fiber is that it is not very easily recycled. Aluminum, on the other hand, is quite trivially recycled. So while spaceships made from CFRP are great in the short-to-medium term (a single spaceship can get a lot more use), I hope that we figured out how to recycle CFRP sooner rather than later.
- maxerickson 10y agoWhat are the back of envelope energy calculations? The fuel for 1 trip is a lot of energy, what's the energy required for the ship? "Dilution is the solution" was an unfortunate attitude on Earth. It will work for millions of years in space, and hydrocarbons are pretty abundant.
- johnloeber 10y agoNot sure if "millions of years" is actually truthful considering exponential growth and highly localized effects
- fredgrott 10y agoMaybe, we need to think about recycling carbon fiber as.. In recycling the fibers get shorter.. Could not that be re-applied to a different industry as far as re-using the carbon fiber? Body Armour for soldiers as the shorter fibers would be of use there?
- ori_b 10y agoThe problem isn't fiber length. The problem is that the fibers are impregnated with resin, with strong chemical bonds.
- stevenrace 10y agoThe resin has a low Tg (temp at which it turns goopy again) - somewhere around 500*F even for 'aerospace' stuff. Whereas recycling aluminum requires roughly double that temperature to begin to melt aluminum. The carbon fiber is then chopped and used as reinforcement in other material likes plastics. SGL Group, who supplies/partners in production with BMW, even uses reclaimed and production waste in it's production process for the new 7-series. A more technical breakdown and state of the industry can be found here: http://www.compositesworld.com/articles/recycled-carbon-fiber-update-closing-the-cfrp-lifecycle-loop http://www.compositesworld.com/articles/recycled-carbon-fibe...
- geuis 10y agoWhy would you be worried about recycling spacecraft at this point in history? Up until the last 2 years, practically all spacecraft either burned up in the atmosphere, crashed into the ocean or land, landed permanently on another body, or are now sitting in a museum somewhere if they were designed to return. Recycling the material in spacecraft is simply a non-issue.
- colechristensen 10y agoAerospace aluminum isn't as easily recycled as beer cans. If you're building a space ship you have very tight tolerances and specifics needed for the alloying of the metals you use. The aluminum in aircraft is full of strange things that need to be removed for general use aluminum and definitely need to be removed for building new aircraft. You're right that melting and re-casting aluminum is really cheap and efficient for beer cans, it's not so much the same for aerospace aluminum. When it comes down to spaceships, the energy used to produce them is usually a very small portion of the total cost of the mission and we don't make very many of them – recycling isn't and shouldn't be a priority. The Falcon 9 burns 110,000 liters of kerosene every launch, if it were made of carbon fiber, maybe it wouldn't matter how the structure was disposed.
- matthewrhoden1 10y agoI never thought about it but I became curious as to what the differences are, here's what I was able to find: [0] Aircraft grade aluminum alloy's composition roughly includes 5.6–6.1% zinc, 2.1–2.5% magnesium, 1.2–1.6% copper, and less than a half percent of silicon, iron, manganese, titanium, chromium, and other metals. [1] Aluminum cans are typically 1% magnesium, 1% manganese, 0.4% iron, 0.2% silicon, and 0.15% copper. There are a lot of metrics that determine the appropriate use of various grades of aircraft level alloys [2]. I guess from the outside some big considerations are how the metal reacts to temperature change and how well a metal cylinder can handle stress while staying light. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/7075_aluminium_alloy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/7075_aluminium_alloy [1] http://www.madehow.com/Volume-2/Aluminum-Beverage-Can.html http://www.madehow.com/Volume-2/Aluminum-Beverage-Can.html [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium_alloy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium_alloy
- jccooper 10y agoSpaceX in particular uses an AL-Li alloy, which is even stranger.
- colechristensen 10y ago>how well a metal cylinder can handle stress while staying light. Are we talking beer cans or rockets? Maybe they are the same after all :) All spot on. There are lots of alloys used for lots of different things and economics and availability play their part too. When you're designing your airplane every slight detail matters.