3 ms·
Good luck Elan? Last time I checked, Apple had bought Fingerworks which had a patent portfolio that I'm told was "fairly large" and had been developing since b
by KirinDave 17y ago
Good luck Elan?
Last time I checked, Apple had bought Fingerworks which had a patent portfolio that I'm told was "fairly large" and had been developing since before the 2000's. I'm pretty sure that what's going to happen is that Apple's going to pull out a trump patent and get Elan's patent invalidated due to prior art (which was itself approved by the patent office).
Why do we even engage in the polite fiction that patents are meaningful anymore? They're just government-sponsored lawsuit cards now. Do they do ANYONE any good in our modern legal system?
- wtallis 17y agoIt's easy for software people like us to fall into the trap of thinking that all patents are bad, because software patents have so many problems. (Terms that are way too long for the pace of the industry, too many vague and overly broad patents being granted, patents being granted for what is arguably mathematics, no provisions against patent trolls, etc.) We see and read about mostly the bad side of the patent system, and unless we actually try to find a good side, we'll assume there isn't one. To give an example, I'm listed as a co-inventor on a pending patent application (though I will never get any royalties from it). The patent is for a type of device that costs more than a hundred thousand dollars to build. The owner of the patent will be a small business that deals with such small volumes that they will mostly have to license the patent to other companies in order to fulfill demand, but they hope to build and sell several of these devices themselves. When the project to develop this device started, most of the experts in the field told us that it was impossible. Now that we've published the basics of how our design works, it would be fairly easy for the large players in the industry to replicate our results without having to buy anything from us. If our patent application isn't granted, then the only way for the company to recoup their costs would be to treat the results of my research as a trade secret. (It's too late for that, though, and I've never signed an NDA.) Going the trade secret route would be a loss for the market, as I've already mentioned that the inventors can't meet the demand on their own. Getting a patent is a good compromise that allows my employer to recoup his costs, but also ensures that our invention can be put to good use.
- barrkel 17y agoPatents are government granted monopolies. How do you know that a free market solution wouldn't come about if it wasn't for the government interfering?
- wtallis 17y agoWithout patents, I see there being 3 possible outcomes for my employer: 1. Get screwed. The big players profit from our discoveries, using their name recognition and economies of scale to ensure that we get essentially no business from our invention. We don't recoup our investment. Anticipation of this scenario stifles innovation among start-ups and small businesses. 2. Treat our discoveries as trade secrets, and attempt to have a monopoly. We end up being able to sell enough to recoup our R&D costs. However, we're not able to meet demand, so most of the market goes on buying the current technology (more expensive and less efficient) until one of the bigger players can reverse-engineer our stuff or re-invent it. Clearly, this is sub-optimal for the market as a whole. 3. Treat it as a trade secret, but using only contract law, license it enough to meet demand. We are able to recoup our R&D costs, but without patent filings as evidence, we run a high risk of this deteriorating to case 1 with insurmountable legal costs. All three options lack the guarantee that our findings will eventually become public domain. What other free-market solutions do you see that would be better?
- ssp 17y agoBut presumably the big companies have patents that read on other parts of the device, so that they can just prevent any devices from being made altogether. It seems this would give them all the advantages in a negotiation.
- wtallis 17y agoActually, in this case, I don't think there are any major looming patent threats. Part of this is because this industry is much slower-moving than software (so that 20 years isn't forever), but part of it is because what we've done is sufficiently different that no reasonable patent for an existing device could cover the core of our invention. (As I said above, conventional wisdom was that this was impossible, right up until we made it work.) One way of describing our research would be to say that this technology has been evolving down a certain path for 50 years, and we backed up a ways and went off in a different direction. (It's not quite that revolutionary, but it isn't that active a field.)