5 ms·
I think it's clear from the wide differences in performance of multitouch devices that there's a lot of room for valid patents to muddy the waters.
labs.moto.c
I think it's clear from the wide differences in performance of multitouch devices that there's a lot of room for valid patents to muddy the waters.
labs.moto.com has done some good testing of smartphone screens and found the iPhone to be far more accurate than the competition. My own experience with some non-phone multitouch devices has also shown Apple to be the only one to get it truly right. Even Wacom's Bamboo tablets can barely manage to recognize two-finger gestures, whereas a MacBook Pro can handle jitouch, and recognize those complex gestures well enough for me to consider jitouch indispensable.
It's hard to believe that the differences could be due only to software or even relatively obvious improvements in Apple's hardware, so somebody deserves some patents, and it's probably Apple (unless they stole somebody else's technology). The ensuing litigation storm then is more a result of how lucrative the multitouch market is than it is a symptom of messy patent laws.
Ultimately, I think it was probably Apple that did (or bought) the research necessary to make a multitouch sensor that is better than a gimmick, and for that they deserve a period of exclusivity to recoup their costs and give them some profits to invest into the next big thing. On the other hand, 20 years is a long time for those of us with lesser budgets to wait for such a cool technology. What we should be hoping for, then, is that somebody more inclined to license their technology can or has independently developed a multitouch sensor that is as good as or better than what Apple's been shipping, and that they can prove this in court if necessary. Reducing the term of these patents might be helpful, but I don't think that there's justification to eliminate hardware patents like these.
"Ultimately, I think it was probably Apple that did (or bought) the research necessary to make a multitouch sensor that is better than a gimmick, and for that they deserve a period of exclusivity to recoup their costs and give them some profits to invest into the next big thing. "
The only area that patent exclusivity should be granted are in those technologies, processes, and methods that would not have been developed (and divulged) otherwise. If superior Multi-Touch would have happened anyways, then there is no reason to grant Apple a patent on the process.
Remember - the entire purpose of patents is "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts..." - if the progress is going to happen anyways, there is no need to issue a patent.
The current lawsuits are about innovation that has already happened. Most of the players are mobile phone makers that are trying to compete with the iPhone by cloning its most distinctive features. If Apple can successfully use patents to thwart those efforts, it forces Nokia et al to one-up the iPhone instead of just making clones that they can sell to different carriers. (Where's the plethora of multitouch screens with haptic feedback that we ought to be seeing?)
The fact that good multitouch was developed by Apple (really, FingerWorks, which Apple bought in 2005) instead of Synaptics or Cirque (who make pretty much everybody else's touchpads) suggests that there was significant innovation, rather than multitouch just being the logical next step.
Interesting you brought up FingerWorks. I really like their keyboard. Unfortunately Apple bought it, discontinued the keyboard, and now nobody can make one because Apple holds the patent. How is that innovative?
Anyways, what's wrong with clones? It's time to market that matters. If somebody clones an ipad, or whatever, then the markets will decide who the winner is.
Unfortunately with the bajillions of already existing patents, it is very difficult and costly to innovate in an incremental manner (incremental improvement tends to be efficient improvement) without infringing on something.
Given the current less-than-ideal patent environment, not licensing their patents is probably the only way Apple can maintain the level of product differentiation that enables them to maintain profit margins that fund the kind of R&D that their primary competitors (PC manufaturers) don't do. The loss of the FingerWorks products is bad for consumers, but there's no denying that the iPhone and the App Store it spawned are a far bigger market than FingerWorks would have ever had. If Apple could license the FingerWorks patents for keyboard use in a way that wouldn't erode their other product lines, they probably would.
It's important to remember that with the iPhone Apple was very much an upstart, with no experience in the cellular industry. They had a very tough time getting into the market because most carriers wouldn't agree to give Apple enough control to ensure that the carriers didn't ruin the user experience. They've now fundamentally changed the dynamics of the cellular industry, and all the device makers have more leverage. If Nokia and the other established phone manufacturers had been free to clone the iPhone as closely as they wanted, then the iPhone would have been mostly marginalized before Apple could even give it 3G capabilities. Apple would not have a particularly successful product on their hands, and the App Store revolution wouldn't have happened.
Unfortunately Apple bought it
I suspect the founders of the company would disagree with you on the "unfortunate" part.
How is that innovative?
Technology once sold as an expensive niche keyboard is now in the hands of tens of millions of people worldwide. Darn.
If somebody clones an ipad, or whatever, then the markets will decide who the winner is.
How is that innovative? When products do not differentiate, they compete on price, which drives prices down to levels incapable of sustaining any significant innovation.
> Technology once sold as an expensive niche keyboard is now in the hands of tens of millions of people worldwide. Darn.
And if the other 99% of the world want to use said thing in more inovatives way, apple forbids. And they can forbid even if original reasearch got to close results. Darn
this comment came from a previous fingerworks customer (i imported their products). And they where more useful, more inovative, and cheaper then the iphone itself. So despite the reach of apple market, it had more reach before.
The iphone is just a better market model.
> Technology once sold as an expensive niche keyboard is now in the hands of tens of millions of people worldwide. Darn.
Why not have the best of both worlds and open up another market? There's also an opportunity cost, because smaller companies cannot use this technology and innovate. Smaller companies tend to innovate more than bigger ones (yes even Apple). So yes, darn.
> How is that innovative? When products do not differentiate, they compete on price, which drives prices down to levels incapable of sustaining any significant innovation.
Oh, but products do differentiate and technology does improve. For example, software, unencumbered by patents, has been sustaining (and increasing) significant innovation for quite a while. Also, software does not only compete on price.
Also, it's innovative because companies have to push the envelope and cannot rest on their laurels to just use their position to rake in the cash (like Microsoft and IBM did).
It comes down to simple economics. Protectionism hinders innovation.
Why not have the best of both worlds and open up another market?
Ask Fingerworks. They could have licensed their technology to other companies if they had wanted to and found other companies willing to agree to their terms. Evidently they found being acquired by Apple to be their best option. And Apple, in possession of the same information, declined to continue participating in that market. I don't see what's wrong with either company acting in its own interests on this. The market was apparently not a viable one, and both parties have profited enormously in spite of not being a part of it.
There's also an opportunity cost, because smaller companies cannot use this technology and innovate.
You're talking about opposed concepts here. Using somebody else's technology is not innovating, it's copying. It also has nothing to do with "smaller companies": Fingerworks was a very small company and somehow, in spite of your claims, they were able to innovate. And they acquired the original patents. Where we the cries of protectionism hindering innovation then? Why was it ok when they were in the way of others using that technology?
As I said before: had Fingerworks not been able to secure a patent on its inventions, Apple (or any other company) could have simply copied their technology instead of acquiring them or licensing it. Competitors would clone and drive prices down, established companies with greater manufacturing, marketing, and distribution capabilities would have crushed them in short order. And Fingerworks wouldn't have had any leverage against them except their potential value as employees. Is this not a worse scenario for small and innovative companies than the one where they have significant bargaining power?
Oh, but products do differentiate and technology does improve.
You've ignored the context. You specifically said clones, and I specifically used the word when to indicate that I was talking about some circumstances and not all circumstances. When products do not differentiate (i.e. when they clone each other), innovation stagnates. Why differentiate when you can just do what your competitors do, but cheaper? Why innovate when you can just tack on some blue LEDs and silver trim to differentiate?
When products do differentiate, innovation flourishes. (At no point was I saying anything like "all products do not differentiate" or "all products only compete on price", as these are obviously untrue.)
Note that I say nothing about the size of the company (it doesn't matter) or the value of the differentiation (different doesn't mean good).
software, unencumbered by patents
There are articles on HN about software patents on a daily basis, and their existence comes up in plenty of stories not directly about them, such as the arguments over HTML5 video codec support, wherein even the "patent free" Theora video format was developed originally by a small company (On2) seeking to profit by licensing its patented technology. You can argue that such innovation might have happened without patents, but you can't argue that they did.
Software is also covered by copyright, which you seem to have ignored entirely, even though it serves effectively the same function of preventing creations from being ripped off. Again, though: I was not talking about software at all, much less software in general. I was talking about hypothetical iPad clones, just as you were.
it's innovative because companies have to push the envelope and cannot rest on their laurels
Why would they if any invention they create is immediately available to their competitors? Doesn't that reward the strategy of simply waiting for others to invent and cloning them? Doesn't that make it harder for small companies to break into old markets new inventions, when the established players can simply rip those ideas off? Doesn't it eliminate one of the main reasons that a big company would ever acquire a smaller company? Doesn't that in turn drastically reduce the value of invention?