3 ms·
Along with majority rule, you need to have minority rights, and I think that's being thrown out with regards to zoning in the US, and it is causing all kinds of
by davidw 10y ago
Along with majority rule, you need to have minority rights, and I think that's being thrown out with regards to zoning in the US, and it is causing all kinds of problems.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Along with majority rule, you need to have minority rights, and I think that's being thrown out with regards to zoning in the US "Thrown out" implies that specific, identified, previously recognized minority rights have been abandoned. What I think is more likely in the case of zoning is that things that people would like to have recognized as "minority rights" but which have not been are, well, still not recognized as minority rights. But I suppose this would be easier to discuss if you would talk about what specific minority rights you think are being ignored or thrown out, rather than vague generalities.
- davidw 10y agoI'm talking about the right to do things like add another floor to a house, or not have to have a 2 car driveway, or things like that that are very often part of zoning codes. Zoning turns 100 this year, so indeed, at one time those minority rights existed, and still do in other places: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/08/collective-land-ownership-in-palo-alto.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/08/col...
- dragonwriter 10y agoI think its a mistake to equate the absence of a current rule prohibiting something with the existence of a specific right to that thing, rather than the general right to take actions which do not violate laws which themselves do not infringe recognized rights.
- lisper 10y agoThat doesn't make any sense at all. Which minority's rights are being thrown out? (Note, by the way, that you didn't actually answer my original question: why should your opinion about where the limits of zoning should be override the opinion of the residents of PA?)
- davidw 10y agoPresumably, some of those people would be happy to sell in order to let denser housing be built. They're the minority. I think there are things majorities should not be able to decide: http://reason.com/archives/2014/04/02/zonings-racist-roots-still-bear-fruit http://reason.com/archives/2014/04/02/zonings-racist-roots-s... Not that I think most people there or here in this thread are motivated that way, but ... sometimes you should not be able to tell other people how they can use their property. Personally, I care about it because you lot in California are exporting a ton of people up here in Oregon where they then proceed to displace people because our own NIMBYish zoning laws and lack of supply.
- lisper 10y ago> Presumably, some of those people would be happy to sell in order to let denser housing be built. Maybe, but they surely knew what they were getting into when they bought their houses. So what right do they have to complain? It's not like PA's zoning is a recent development. I might be able to make even more money if I build a chemical plant or a toxic waste dump on my suburban property. Should I be able to do that? > [Zoning's racist roots] Unless you have some evidence that the current zoning laws in PA are racist, this is a non-sequitur. > you lot in California are exporting a ton of people up here in Oregon If you think that PA's zoning is what is driving people to Oregon you are completely out of touch with reality. There's a lot of cheap dirt left south of the Oregon border. Also, it strikes me as just a wee bit hypocritical to complain about our zoning because you have failed to keep people out while we have succeeded.
- davidw 10y agoI'm actually happy to have people move here. I wouldn't be able to live where I do without people having moved up from California. The problem is that a bunch of people from a state with nearly 40 million people moving to a place with less than 4 is that it makes for some difficult adjustments. I'm still ok with it, but California is very much exporting people because they cannot afford it. The more the merrier for me, but I guess having lived in Europe, living with other people does not bother me to the degree that it seems to for many people in the US. The racism thing just goes to show that everyone thinks there are some limits to what majority rule ought to be able to do, just as many of us that take a dim view of zoning think that there is probably a line somewhere (your nuclear waste example).