3 ms·
Exactly this. I had a friend that skipped a grade, and the age difference affected her. She was 17 in her first year of college, unable to fully participate, f
by Broken_Hippo 10y ago
Exactly this.
I had a friend that skipped a grade, and the age difference affected her. She was 17 in her first year of college, unable to fully participate, for example. Many kids that are held back a year find other sorts of problems as well - sexual maturity and hormones a year ahead of their classmates, for example.
The other problem i've seen with "advanced" students is complete seperation from other students, with the implicit expectation that the students should be more mature because they were smart. One school system did this from a young age, and in high school there were multiples that simply had trouble socializing with 'normal' students. Really had a detrimental effect on some of them.
I would approve of specialized sorts of schedules for such 10 year olds, however. Part of the day in the classes needed for their level, while going back to enjoy the other classes with their emotional and developmental peers. Art, music, physical education, lunch, recess, and some of the reading (after all, it would be fun stories at an emotional level they understand), etc. Perhaps even special advanced classes with a lighter homework load designed for the advanced student, for example, could be worked in.
- mgkimsal 10y agoI was pushed ahead a grade, and didn't have many issues in elementary school, until we moved in the middle of 5th grade. Had to deal with a whole new set of people who I'd not grown up with, and that then carried on to middle and high school. No doubt the adolescent period would have been more difficult had I stayed in the original school, but I think it would have had less contributing factor. I did occasionally get in to some 'trouble' with 'peers' (not really my peers, but others in the school) being 'advanced'. Example: 4th grade - teacher gets sick - our class is split in to 2 to go sit with 5th grade classes for the last 2 hours of school. "just sit and read". Fine... but the 5th grade teacher was covering math lessons, and was asking questions - "who knows ... (fill in the blank)?". Silence in the room, except for me raising my hand. "I know!" She was thinking I wanted to leave the room, and kept ignoring me, until I spoke the answer. Pissed off the other 9-11 year old kids having a 8 year old answer their math questions (it was something to do with fractions). I got a scratch-n-sniff pine tree sticker for my answer, and was told to keep reading my book and not disturb the class any more... Still had that sticker until a few years ago (it didn't smell any more).