3 ms·
Americans are also often shocked to see how challenging lessons actually are in other places, and sometimes kind of frightened by it. I feel like there's a whol
by schoen 10y ago
Americans are also often shocked to see how challenging lessons actually are in other places, and sometimes kind of frightened by it. I feel like there's a whole genre of Internet posts of what students are allegedly learning in other countries. ("Cheryl's birthday" from Singapore is a famous recent example, but there are plenty of others.)
I had a physics teacher in high school who came from Russia and was always frustrated at the lower standards for science education here in the U.S. He would describe what people in Russia were supposed to know by a particular grade level and it was commonly years ahead of Americans -- and he claimed students were expected to take much more time studying overall (although that's not necessarily always useful, and there are presumably also many different kinds of schools in Russia, as there are in the U.S.).
We can surely find some possible tradeoffs and disadvantages of particular educational methods and approaches used in other countries. (People often complain about the rote-memorization issue with the associated lack of conceptual understanding or creativity, and, when we see very difficult educational materials from earlier eras in the U.S., there's the observation that students then may have had to learn many fewer subjects at a time.) But it seems like there's a lot of indication that huge numbers of U.S. students could be learning at a more challenging pace than they are today.
- sliverstorm 10y agoIt's kind of hard to tell what's real anymore thanks to said genre of posts, after hearing the whole gamut up to things to the order of "Well Russian children are expected to know calculus by 8, group theory by 9, and complete their mastery of theoretical physics by 11"
- selimthegrim 10y agoI would post the quote from Vladimir Arnold where he said he taught sixth graders group theory but that would probably be depressing.
- tbihl 10y agoI only spent a semester in another country (in Madrid), but I felt that the lessons were not all that challenging, but they were thorough. Meaning, in my courses there we were expected to know a lot, but once we knew that material we weren't asked to manipulate it in any way that really pushed us. Confounding my interpretation is that one of my courses, as a computer engineering student, was a fluid mechanics course in the aerospace department. Then again, my US undergrad is probably pretty atypical. My school had very heavy core requirements (at least for engineering), so you had a lot of classes each semester. It tends to be a top-ranked US school, but the classes really weren't very challenging, and because of how many we took, they never seemed to go into much depth. On another note, it's not often that I reminisce longingly on my childhood, but that's exactly what happened while I was doing Cheryl's birthday. My favorite things growing up were math and logic puzzles in their pure forms, un-obscured by the tedium that accompanies them in real life. I remember Math 24 from Elementary school, Math Counts in middle school, and some brain teasers and logic puzzles sprinkled throughout both times. If you're needing some for late elementary children, I highly recommend "The Lady or The Tiger and Other Logic Puzzles"
- mathattack 10y agoIt's a little different in college - this is generally where the US catches up.
- pandaman 10y agoRussian system is fundamentally different from the American (or at least it used to be in the USSR): students can choose schools and schools can choose students. For example my school had been admitting everyone for the grades 1-8 but for grades 9-10 there had been a math test. I think about a dozen out of 70 eight graders made to the 9th grade in the same school and the rest had to go to other schools. The class had been replenished with students from elsewhere who also passed the test and went on with 15 hours of math lessons (and 40 hours of homework) per week for the grades 9-10. I don't think something like this could fly in the USA.