11 ms·
Pinker: “News is a misleading way to understand the world”
- startupcorp 10y agoI love Steven Pinker!
- dschiptsov 10y agoOh, really? Could it also be that advertisements are misleading way to collect the facts and press releases are misleading way to evaluate performance?
- hugh4life 10y agoYes news can be misleading, but I think there's a lot of truth in Rene Girard's idea of escalating mimetic rivalry... and Peter Turchin's fathers-and-sons cycle of violence.
- Hoasi 10y ago> As long as media will give endless publicity to multiple murderers, they create a niche for people who want to make a difference for a political cause or their own ego. Right on.
- phn 10y agoThe question is, what less misleading alternative is there? Social media?
- tedunangst 10y agoUnbiased ideologically neutral sites like Hacker News!
- unclenoriega 10y agoI'm so glad I had swallowed my coffee before reading this.
- WalterSear 10y agoAt least when you come to the comment sections, you get a whole load of competing individual perspectives, rather than the single one the original article purveys.
- zghst 10y agoMost popular, pervading opinions are continually challenged, re-examined, and refined. Debates wholly grapple through the complete meaning of the issue from a wide range of perspectives without resulting to name calling, ad hominem attacks, tone policing, etc.
- slededit 10y agoWithin a narrow sphere, but the Hacker news audience is limited in diversity - and because of this so are the range of debates that go on here. Generally speaking Hacker News focuses on upper middle class American issues. When we talk about the less well off its generally from the top looking down. Watch next time for the comments of the form "I'd gladly pay more taxes so XYZ wouldn't have to go through this". Few commenters ever truly see themselves personally getting into one of these situations. In terms of politics this site is heavily westernized. Communism and the Chinese system does have some nice features (along with the bad), but its rare to see threads here explore the benefits. None of this is necessarily bad, and I'd argue this site gives you a broader view of the world than reading traditional news. However its far from a zeitgeist of what's "really happening" in the world.
- mjhoy 10y agoI've found, for myself, traveling a good portion of the US by bicycle tempers my pessimism about the world. Bad things happen, to be sure, and it is good (I think) to stay informed of the news, but it is also good to see how kind, generous and caring most people are, and also how people not of your political, religious, or cultural ilk are not exactly the ignorant or immoral monsters you may have thought.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hacknat 10y agoAnh, this isn't a great model of humanity in my opinion. Most people seem pretty good when you talk to them, but we're all involved in massive negative externalities right now. Pinker might be right that we're less violent than we used to be, but we're just as greedy (if not more), and I think all that ill behavior is being channeled somewhere else. Where? The environment of course. Wealth has spread and poverty has diminished in the world, but we really shot ourselves in the foot doing it. Unless a massive technological innovation comes along in the next 30 years Pinker's observations are going to seem moronic (sure we were less violent, but billions of people ended up dying). Edit: To prove my point do a Ctrl-F and search for "environment" or "climate" in this article, you won't find them.
- harshreality 10y agoI think it's misleading to infer too much from that. Most people are nice to strangers, face to face. Maybe it's that you're suddenly a member of each other's in-group, and forming a basis to exclude the other person (becoming enemies) requires some initial behavioral or ideological incompatibility and enough time for it to germinate into enough of a conflict to sabotage the automatic friendly social interaction. However, just because strangers generally get along when they meet randomly, that doesn't say anything about the major problems that cause people to not get along once they know each other—incompatible ideologies, behavioral patterns that the other person can't tolerate, and so on. To pivot to another realm, a cop can be the nicest person in the world if you hang out with them at a neighborhood barbecue, and the next week they can be harassing people and ruining lives over drug possession.
- Retric 10y agoNews is there to Entertain not Educate. IMO, the steady decline in reporting has a more to do with other forms of entertainment showing up and gaining traction than anything else.
- narrator 10y agoI think a lot of news is there because it's influential. For example, the newspapers are totally awful money losing businesses, yet they stick around because of their political influence value.
- Retric 10y agoHistorically newspapers where money printing machines. Compared to say magazine's the industry has done very well over time and some of them are still rather profitable. However, this is a much broader trend even combining TV, Newspapers, Radio, and the internet we are simply employing fewer investigative reporters.
- jbandela1 10y agoOne way to possibly fix this might be to start a #NoBloodMoney movement that would target advertisers who advertise in news segments about events where people have died. People's deaths should not be used by the media company to make money, nor should people's deaths be used to try to generate interest in your product. If enough people targeted the advertisers ("Ever since watching an ad for <your product> during a news segment about <an event in which somebody died> I just associate <your product> with death and sadness"), I think we could get the media companies to stop running an excess of these kinds of stories. #NoBloodMoney - media companies should not profit off of other's misery.
- davegauer 10y agoI like your idea. I've felt this way for years. The news uses people's death and suffering to get eyeballs on advertisements.
- voidfiles 10y agoHuman misery isn't something most companies want to be associated with. For that reason, many companies don't want their ads to run next to content like that. I've personally had to quickly pull ads off a site because of that fact.
- maxerickson 10y agoI've been occasionally fascinated that newspapers don't have a flag in their CMSs for articles that are crass to plaster with ads.
- CM30 10y agoThe New York Times seems to do this: http://www.niemanlab.org/2015/03/an-ad-blocker-for-tragedies-how-news-sites-handle-content-around-sensitive-stories/ http://www.niemanlab.org/2015/03/an-ad-blocker-for-tragedies... If a story is marked as sensitive, an option is set and ads aren't shown on it. The Guardian has this too. And I've done this on a few sites I've worked with as well.
- 10y ago
- grownseed 10y agoIt’s always about events that happened and not about things that didn’t happen. This conversation and the above quote in particular remind me of this article posted here a while back: "Why the world is not falling apart" (http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/foreigners/2014/12/the_world_is_not_falling_apart_the_trend_lines_reveal_an_increasingly_peaceful.single.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/foreigners/2...) We never see a reporter saying to the camera, “Here we are, live from a country where a war has not broken out”—or a city that has not been bombed, or a school that has not been shot up. I'm all for the right for free speech, but that doesn't mean that deliberate fear-mongering shouldn't be reprimanded.
- qu4z-2 10y ago> deliberate fear-mongering [should] be reprimanded. By whom?
- grownseed 10y agoThat's a fair question and, not being hugely familiar with the legal system, I'm not sure what that would fall under. I'm thinking something along the lines of intentional deceit or unfair/manipulative representation of facts, but I'll admit to not knowing nearly enough about the law to point to anything in particular.
- qu4z-2 10y agoAs long as it needs to be intentional, I could maybe see it. I imagine it'd be difficult to prove intent, though. "Manipulative representation of facts" is tricky, because every representation aside from raw data has been manipulated in some way or another.
- HillaryBriss 10y ago> There has probably been a slight increase in the rate of violent crime in the US in 2015, and I say probably because the FBI figures are still not out for that year. > But even then that wouldn’t even be as high as it was in 2012, just three years ago, and that itself is a huge decrease in the levels of '60s, '70, and '80s in the US, where violent crime has fallen by more than half. So there is probably an uptick for 2015 and 2016. But it’s just a wiggle in a curve that’s been going down, down, down. I'm not a member of the NRA and I don't own a gun. Personally, I'm ok with a ton of gun-control laws. All the gun-control laws you wanna pass, I'm ok with. Second amendment rights are not high on my personal priority list. But, still, I sometimes wonder why there is such a hard push for more gun-control laws every year given this decreasing level of domestic violence.
- etendue 10y ago> But, still, I sometimes wonder why there is such a hard push for more gun-control laws every year given this decreasing level of domestic violence. Another thing to ponder is why the focus on semiautomatic rifles, when 1, violent crime overwhelmingly uses handguns, and 2, the previous assault weapon ban was deemed ineffective by the DOJ. And what is the basis for proposing expanded background checks in response to, for example, the Orlando mass shooting when the shooter not only passed a background check, but had a security guard license (which itself has a more intensive background check).
- zghst 10y agoSame politicians accusing others using fear and ignorance seem to be using fear and ignorance vigorously
- bbradley406 10y agoWhile I dislike describing these things ("He's a gun nut! He'll kill us! People like him should be locked up!" are common reactions to simple facts) there are multiple reasons rifles are lumped in. - Any additional regulation sounds like progress to voters in favor of it. It can be nonsensical, unenforceable, make criminals out of previously law-abiding citizens (CA magazine size laws), be disregarded publicly by police departments, and they will still cheer for it. - They are mostly used for target practice, hunting, pest control, and some home defense. People who vote for gun control typically don't do these things. Questions of the form "Why do you need (X number of rounds | optics | calibers | forward grips)?" sound reasonable to them; if you have ever faced a bear / pack of coyotes / intruders it's pretty self explanatory. - They are the only real firearms that can present a significant threat to trained teams. Rifles can be aimed precisely, deliver a good sustained rate of fire, and punch through body armor, all from 500 yards. - With a good amount of practice and .308-.50 rounds, you can take down opposing vehicles and assets (power stations, fuel tanks, etc), and have enough distance between you and the target to exit the area safely. For those in favor of gun control (beyond what we have currently) on HN, let me ask: How well do you think you would fair in a large riot / national emergency / civil war armed with only a SAFE Act compliant handgun? These things do and will happen, maybe not in your lifetime, but certainly in the future. The laws we enact should not just be focused on making us feel safe. They should consider those that may have to justly defend themselves against a larger force.
- chatmasta 10y ago"If you don't read the newspaper, you're uninformed. If you read the newspaper, you're mis-informed." Mark Twain
- coliveira 10y agoIt is good to read the news if you have an understanding of what the media is trying to achieve. There should be a "News 101" class at every university to help students navigating the deluge of information - especially to help them understand what the media conglomerates are and how their business works. Mostly everything that is written follows an agenda that is set by advertisers, political positions of the owners of the particular media group, and national interests. If you don't understand this, reading the news is just like being brainwashed.
- michaelbuddy 10y agoUniversity? Try 3rd grade.
- peter303 10y agoThis analysis is called "deconstruction", i.e. understanding the cultural background and the advocacy of the author. This not only applies to news, but any media- movies, literature, art, etc. Supposedly people should learn how to do this in high school.
- zghst 10y agoHence why I have a great deal of distrust of any media. They always bend the facts to twist their narrative, it's better to hear from the horses mouth or watch directly what happens around the world
- anonymousDan 10y ago"Terrorist movements always fail" Ehhh, no.
- forgotmysn 10y agocare to elaborate?
- rmchugh 10y agoPlenty of terrorist movements throughout history have succeeded, perhaps we don't call them terrorists though because they have had the chance to rebrand themselves. Just to give an example from Ireland, there was terrorism on both sides of the religious divide. If we agree that the independence movement failed (and I don't think that things are that simple), then we are implicitly saying that the loyalist terrorists (together with the rest of the British armed forces) won. Just like a language is a dialect with an army, a freedom fighter is a successful terrorist. And let's not forget that terrorism is a prime strategy of successful states, such as the US or Colombia, where right wing death squads successfully defeated a guerrilla movement.
- tn13 10y agoA good example is of Pakistan which was created after the founder Muhammad Ali Jinnah raised a "call to action" which was basically shedding blood of innocents in random parts of India. Thousands of people died as Mohandas Gandhi roamed around preaching restraint. As the death toll started mounting the British government and Indian National Congress has no choice but to accept partition and exchange of population which was another very bloody affair capable of shaming entire humanity. No one calls Jinnah a terrorist or views Pakistan as a result of a terrorist movement but it indeed was.
- anonymousDan 10y agoExactly. Slightly tongue in cheek, The Boston Tea party would probably be viewed as a terrorist attack if it happened today.
- alwaysdoit 10y agoThe news is a method of attempting to become informed about the state of the world exclusively through the examination of outliers. It's broken by design.
- blubb-fish 10y agovery well put - concise and to the point!
- betolink 10y agowell, IMO news should also cover the issues that affect the masses, yes, an accident in a refinery is an outlier but a vote on carbon taxes in congress is something that affect us all. The problem with today's mainstream media is that they don't talk a lot about the big issues but those outliers. If we focus on the things that matter well yes we're not in the middle ages but we're not in the best shape possible as a civilization.
- tn13 10y agoI highly recommend Pinker's books. They will give you some rather politically incorrect view of the world. You may feel free to disagree with him but you will find them interesting read with potential to change how you look at the world.
- slackstation 10y agoNewspapers used to make a healthy profit from tiny ads. Network news used to be run at a loss by the tv networks. The introduction of CNN made news into a huge money maker. Craigslist ate the lunch of most newspapers. Now, the internet (especially social networks) has made everything a race for attention. Now the New York Times has to compete and worry about Buzzfeed. All of these trends now just reward attention more than anything. The standards for journalism are eroded when outlets like Buzzfeed allow anyone to write content, get it indexed by Google and then track how popular that piece of content gets and automatically promote it. In a world like that, we get the loudest, angriest, most emotionally wrenching things; context, nuance and facts be damned. Whatever you think of his politics, Donald Trump wouldn't be where he is without his savvy use of the media. He has exploited the weakness in our current system all the way to top of one of the two major parties in the most powerful country in the free world. All to the horror, shock and dismay of the vast majority of people who work in the media disagreeing with Trump's politics.
- cylinder 10y agoYou're disregarding the role of subscriptions in supporting newspapers. The internet obviously has made print news delivered to your doorstep obsolete. Even now, subscription-only news outlets are doing okay, such as the Financial Times, and niche papers.
- forgottenpass 10y agoRemember when Ezra Klien's Vox wasn't going to be just another left leaning content farm? I wonder why they don't write about what happened there instead of just interviewing Pinker about the news?