14 ms·
I thought AMP was an anti-ad-blocking play. It smells to me like Google is trying to use its dominant position in search to reduce consumer control of the brows
by barrkel 10y ago
I thought AMP was an anti-ad-blocking play. It smells to me like Google is trying to use its dominant position in search to reduce consumer control of the browser; it's a risky road to go down for everyone, including Google.
For me, as long as I disable javascript, the modern mobile web is plenty fast enough. That is, the bits of the web I want to use on the move: mostly text, occasional pictures. It takes real effort to break this with javascript disabled. Most JS on e.g. news sites, blogs, aggregators etc. is tracking and ad related, dynamically adding links to viral content, all that stuff you don't need and dramatically slows down sites through repeated reflow.
- chatmasta 10y agoYep, this was also incredibly obvious to me when google introduced it. It's such a typical Google move to market something as "better for the web" when what they really mean is "better for our pockets." Fortunately for anyone with Apple phones, content blockers should still work on AMP pages.
- sanderjd 10y agoWon't things like AdBlock still work on AMP pages? Do people outside the HN bubble turn off javascript to block ads (or for any other reason)?
- Spivak 10y agoNo, but I can imagine a future where ad blockers start blocking all non-essential JS. It would likely be more conservative than someone who uses policeman or uMatrix but I have no doubt users would appreciate the speed increase -- especially on mobile.
- notatoad 10y agoi've seen this assumption made just about every time AMP is mentioned, that it's somehow about preventing adblock. AMP requires that all your ads are specifically tagged as ads, and that no javascript is modifying the page after it has loaded. Instead of making adblocking more difficult, it seems to be going out of its way to make adblocking easier to do and more difficult for publishers to prevent.
- pawadu 10y agoI don't understand, how is this different for Apple? If anything I would assume the opposite - since practically everyone else can use Firefox (mobile) and all its plugins to avoid this issue.
- mtgx 10y agoStill crossing my fingers that the EU charges Google of antitrust over blocking apps like adblockers in its store.
- the_watcher 10y ago> It's such a typical Google move to market something as "better for the web" when what they really mean is "better for our pockets." It might be better for their bottom line (I haven't thought about it much, but it makes sense that it would be, so I'll just go with that), but that doesn't mean it isn't also better for the web and users. Same thing with Facebook Instant Articles. I now find myself, as a user, vastly preferring these sites on mobile, because they are far less likely to hang or hijack my browser.
- _pmf_ 10y ago> it's a risky road to go down for everyone, including Google What's risky about it for Google? They can back down at any time they want (this includes injecting ads directly in AMP pages, precluding competitors from doing the same because they control Chrome). They have shown again and again that they don't give a shit about lost investments for web developers.
- barrkel 10y agoLarge companies attract a particular type of executive: they see what a company's current strength is, and try to leverage that strength into advantages in other areas by sheer force, rather than competing and producing better products or services. It's perceived by a lot of people as ramming a product or service down people's throats, it creates resentment, and at the margin - where the leveraged strength approaches monopoly - it's illegal. I'm of the opinion that infestation of upper ranks of companies by these kinds of people is what ultimately leads to their demise (or rather, regression to the mean of mediocrity). These people use up goodwill and generate resentment. When they're given too much leeway, they can push hard enough to attract government anti-trust attention and tie the company up in knots for years. They suck the soul out of companies by promoting a nihilistic vision of capitalism. They encourage attributing cynical motivations about any future action of the company (think Microsoft); it can take decades to shake that off. So, the risks are both reputational and potentially regulatory, and they're cumulative. Yes, Google has cost goodwill in the past; but they don't have zero goodwill yet, and nor do they have infinite goodwill.
- Nullabillity 10y agoAny reason you couldn't still use an ad-blocking extension or proxy for AMP pages? If anything it should make it even easier, since there are standardized tags for all ads...
- barrkel 10y agoI haven't examined the technical details very deeply, but from what I understand it's the content producer that has to use specific tags. What Google does to produce a page served up to the end user is then up to them. By intermediating the experience, they have a lot of control over the output, and they can integrate it with the rationale of making everything faster (and integration is exactly what would make it faster, make no mistake - all the ads, third party DOM elements, trackers, etc. not being integrated, and being dynamically constructed instead, is what makes modern news sites especially slow). In extremis, they could do what Opera Mobile used to do, and supply a pre-rendered image to the end user. I don't think they'll do that (it wouldn't be very trackable, for one), but it's possible.
- esrauch 10y agoIt seems like amp is trying to give users the same experience you have but without disabling JavaScript. Is that so obviously nefarious?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zeveb 10y ago> It seems like amp is trying to give users the same experience you have but without disabling JavaScript. Is that so obviously nefarious? Given the massive security and privacy flaws of JavaScript, anything that encourages people to leave it enabled is objectively nefarious.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- andybak 10y agoYou're entitled to your position but please acknowledge there are a lot of tech-savvy people who do want a javascript-enabled web.
- zeveb 10y ago> You're entitled to your position That JavaScript enables privacy and security exploits is neither a position nor an opinion but the truth. > please acknowledge there are a lot of tech-savvy people who do want a javascript-enabled web. Sure there are; I have no problem acknowledging it. They, apparently, have a problem acknowledging that they do not value privacy and security as much as they value novelty.
- esrauch 10y agoI could just as easily say you don't value your privacy and security as much as novelty since you are going to arbitrary websites. People find zero days in image renderers, how do you justify not disabling image rendering? Your user agent and your browsers supported TLS configs are leaking who you are, how do you justify sending that info to every random web server? Even just being on hackernews right now proves you are accepting a negative security impact for some novelty value.
- alistproducer2 10y agoThis is exactly what I came to say. I just keep JS disabled on my mobile and most things I want to read work and it reduces load times by an order of magnitude. If I really want to read something that won't work with JS, then I'll turn it back on for that site but I rarely if ever have to do that.
- magicalist 10y agoThis is nonsense. I think there are issues around AMP and search placement, anointing one specific solution to the problem, but in the end they're just web pages. You might as well say React is an anti-ad-blocking play. It make no sense.