3 ms·
> the Hyperloop concept was that the tracks should be much cheaper, since all you need is a steel tube [Technical nitpick first: tube is a structural element,
by semi-extrinsic 10y ago
> the Hyperloop concept was that the tracks should be much cheaper, since all you need is a steel tube
[Technical nitpick first: tube is a structural element, while pipe is something that can hold pressure.]
The price of pressure-rated steel pipe is roughly proportional to the diameter squared. At 132 inches in diameter, the hyperloop pipe itself would cost at least $600/ft. It would also weigh > 1000 lbs/ft, so the support system would be absolutely massive and probably double that price. That's just the cost of raw materials.
For comparison, Elon Musk's total cost estimate is $1400 per foot per pipe [$6 billion total cost, 380 miles, two pipes], so I'm inclined to say that his estimate might be a bit optimistic.
From what I can tell, total cost per foot for maglev is estimated around $6000/ft. [US highway construction cost per lane per foot is also around that number.] But I understand those numbers as the total cost including also engineering work, shipping/logistics, actual building work, buying the land etc. While my $1200/ft estimate is just raw materials.
So if we as a very coarse estimate say raw materials is 1/4 of the price, hyperloop is not significantly cheaper than maglev.
- schiffern 10y agoSmall correction: you used the diameter of the large Hyperloop design, but the cost estimate of the small one. It should be $7.5b or $1870/tube foot. Fyi there is a cost breakdown on pp55 of the Hyperloop PDF, which lists the tube construction costs as half what you specify. What kind of "pressure tubes" are you referring to for these cost estimates? http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-20130812.pdf http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-201...
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoI was estimating based on interpolating between carbon steel and 316L stainless, ASME Schedule 40 pipe. You can have that up to 144 inches.